Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

Posting to show I exist!

You do exist! You don't seem very interested in finding scum, though.

I was going to shitpost in this game the whole time by copy-pasting AI chat responses, but then I thought better on it.

What would the input for that have looked like?

I don't know I didn't try it. I'm on my phone right now so it would be annoying to respond to this with an AI even if I would have found it funny.

[ToonyMan]

The mafia are Fallacy and ToonyMan.

Big words big man, how about...

The mafia are Max and Jim.

Now tell me why we're both wrong.

[ToonyMan]

What, Webadict isn't in this game?? I was going to vote him until he fake-claimed cop.

I think I can read a1s well so let's go there. What color are you feeling?

[zemaj]

<snip>

Do I believe zemaj is town?

Probably, I don't know their experience with the game but they look like town.

<snip>

why, thank you!  I've played at guessing games about goblets potentially partially filled with poisonous potions.  I'm also an avid armchair psychologist.  As for how that works out for me?  ~50/50, tbh...

Oh, and zemaj. He's not scum, I just want to see his reaction.

HEY!  Don't be fake FoSing me!  If you are going to try fingering me without even buying me a drink first you need to mean it!

Are you sure you exist? Maybe you're actually secretly a hydra of Org and Dermonster.

I don't know who either of those two people are so that means I must exist!

you are confused... therefore you are!

The mafia are Fallacy and ToonyMan.

well, I mean, Fallacy is obvi-scum... posting solid game theory and trying to engage in misguided attempts to start meaningful discussion.  How weak of a play can one person make?

Toony otoh, has said he thinks I'm town, which I like, so you are going to have to make a more precise point on that sledgehammer-fine argument to get me to come off my exalted position of having the very best opinion... my own.

***

was waiting for some more salient bits to float to the surface, but I'll just go ahead and leave this here, see what happens with that.

[ToonyMan]

I'm going to say zemaj is town. I don't get the impression they're working with someone else in secret.

I think I even have zemaj completely figured out. Which is a good thing.

So...

Town
FoU
zemaj

TBA
Fluffe
Jim
Max
a1s
IronyOwl

[FallacyofUrist]

In fact, everything FoU has said has been unhelpful! And that is because they don't know what they're doing! They don't know what they're doing because they're playing a game from an unknown position! They're playing the game from an unknown position because they're probably town!

I've been playing mafia for like 5 years now

Do you really expect me to know what I'm doing

The mafia are Fallacy and ToonyMan.

Then you're the doctor! zemaj is the cop, Toony and a1s are the mafia

I'm the student, Jim is the master, and fluffe is clueless

It all makes sense in my head.

[Maximum Spin]

The mafia are Fallacy and ToonyMan.

Then you're the doctor! zemaj is the cop, Toony and a1s are the mafia

I'm the student, Jim is the master, and fluffe is clueless

It all makes sense in my head.

At least one of those is either definitely wrong or definitely right.

[zemaj]

Oh My...[/sulu]

First day of my first game and one person threatening me with a good time and another who already has me all figured out.  Never thought I'd be so popular...

[Jim Groovester]

As usual I would like to note that I'm not scum this time.

Hrrrm.

HRMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

aside from the slightly prickly, direct, and timely response to an obvious joke alluding to how there were only two players (well, three, if you count my post, but I really don't know if that would be proper in context) posting in-thread despite the game having been on for >2h at that point?

no reason, really... but thanks for sharing the LAMIST reaction

This is just how I normally act. I appreciate your efforts in using apparent snap reactions to gather information, however.

That's obviously not what you're doing, but I'll treat it like that anyways.

I read this post in passing and it didn't catch my eye and then went to play noita for several hours but now I'm back reading the thread.

What's the insinuation that you're making here?

I was going to shitpost in this game the whole time by copy-pasting AI chat responses, but then I thought better on it.

That sounds like something Jim would do, actually (see his role in my most recent BYOR).

That's advanced shitposting. Definitely something I want to do but also something I am too lazy to do.

JimGroovester

hey wtf i dont even know you man

FallacyOfUrist

Alright, you're okay.

Posting to show I exist!

You do exist! You don't seem very interested in finding scum, though.

My honest to goodness first instinct after reading this was to make commentary about old school Bay 12 Mafia meta, but I'll give you a bit more time to work.

Posting to show I exist!

thumbsupemoji.jpg

Well, I can't argue with that. Do you think I'm mafia?

No clue!

You're leaving a much different impression this game compared to the late game of Wormwood Mafia. In that game you were fucking ready to rumble, but here the feistiness is missing.

The mafia are Fallacy and ToonyMan.

But how!?

early game ToonyMan

Alright, pretty standard early game ToonyMan.

What, Webadict isn't in this game?? I was going to vote him until he fake-claimed cop.

I honestly made the same mistake.

Oh, and zemaj. He's not scum, I just want to see his reaction.

This vote is bad.

In fact, everything FoU has said has been unhelpful! And that is because they don't know what they're doing! They don't know what they're doing because they're playing a game from an unknown position! They're playing the game from an unknown position because they're probably town!

Do I believe FoU is really town this time?

I think I do.

ToonyMan going to bat early for FallacyofUrist.

Inclined to feel like this is town ToonyMan. Maybe in this game I can do what I honestly feel like I should do every game I play with ToonyMan and literally sheep him and let him carry me to victory.



My gut wants to boldly say

that it's Max and Fluffe9911

But I don't have much to point to for that feeling. Need to see a lot more game. Of the players that have posted, ToonyMan feels best. FallacyofUrist and zemaj are okay. Everybody else is sort of middling.

[zemaj]

Come on, people!  I already made another completely offtopic post! 

Letting one through could be unfortunate, but two in a row is just... careless.


***

we need to speedrun this a bit, so lets go ahead and pull out some D2 tricks:

MY LIST in order from pinging the Scumdar10000^TM least to most:

zemaj - a paragon of insight and a marvel of townieness
Toony - several posts with light prods & even reads
IronyOwl - few posts, but one did have a prod attached.
Fallacy - has tried to move conversation, even made a posit or two... trying to be TL?  Sus, but not comdemning
Max - 2 posts, throwing two names with nothing further on first, but making an assertation I can agree with on second... meh, its D1, still...
Jim - lots of posts right at the start, then nothing... went to bed?
Fluffe - posts read much like the name-sake
a1s - no posts

[zemaj]

DAMMIT JIM!

now my joke just looks silly... because of what you did... and not because it was silly... ass...

[Jim Groovester]

Jim - lots of posts right at the start, then nothing... went to bed?

Thedayislessthan24hoursoldletmeplayNoita

[Jim Groovester]

Spoiler: Meanwhile, in Noita.... (click to show/hide)

https://imgur.com/a/Tg9ZvfI

[FallacyofUrist]

aside from the slightly prickly, direct, and timely response to an obvious joke alluding to how there were only two players (well, three, if you count my post, but I really don't know if that would be proper in context) posting in-thread despite the game having been on for >2h at that point?

no reason, really... but thanks for sharing the LAMIST reaction

This is just how I normally act. I appreciate your efforts in using apparent snap reactions to gather information, however.

That's obviously not what you're doing, but I'll treat it like that anyways.

I read this post in passing and it didn't catch my eye and then went to play noita for several hours but now I'm back reading the thread.

What's the insinuation that you're making here?

That he's a new player trying to act stereotypically 'cool' because he doesn't know what else he should be doing, yet.

Every game is a learning game.

[notquitethere]

Vote Count
- Toonyman
- Jim Groovester
- MaximumSpin
- FallacyofUrist - [1]  Jim Groovester
- Fluffe9911
- a1s - [2] Toony, Zemaj
- Zemaj - [1] FallacyofUrist
- Irony Owl
- No Elimination

~64 hours remaining