Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EuchreJack]

very well, I vote for EuchreJack.

Good job, fine chap.

Now we fight!

You are scum!  SCUUMMMMMY SCUMMM SCUMMMBUCKETTEDY SCUMMM!
I mean, you can't even be bothered to read!
And, and, you didn't make a reads list yet!

You are so soo ssooooo scum!

[EuchreJack]

(As for my absent reads list, I ahem need to go off to work now.  Maybe later?)

[a1s]

very well, I vote for EuchreJack.

Good job, fine chap.

Now we fight!

I am scum!  SCUUMMMMMY SCUMMM SCUMMMBUCKETTEDY SCUMMM!
I mean, you can't even be bothered to read!
And, and, you didn't make a reads list yet!

You are so soo ssooooo scum!

a what list?

[notquitethere]

Jack is refering to a list of "reads". You list all the players and say what you think of them all.

[a1s]

Ok, that's a valid point- I'm pretty shit at "reading" people. In my other game a1s didn't have to read anyone (because a1s wasn't town.)

[TricMagic]

And now you're joking. Eh.

Going to stick to my gut and go with Jack then. Almost hammered. Any last pleas, maybe that read list you promised to do later?

[ToonyMan]

So probably any "save things for later" tactic is a losing tactic.
Why do you want town to lose, Toonyman? 

How does town coordinate who uses actions at night without mafia knowing? Why are you encouraging players to use their one-shots as soon as possible? People can do whatever they want, I decided to give NQT"s question some thought and the conclusion I came to is everyone using their ability on N1 sounds like it will probably work out poorly, especially if mafia nokill because we then don't learn anything.

The most ideal situation would be if a kill actually happened and a Flower caught it in the act, the chances of this happening are low. We trade one of our Flowers for a mafia, and even then we could have our Roots then protect the confirmed town Flower for at least a night or two (or at least scare mafia enough not to try for it). This wouldn't be possible if all our Roots blew their one-shots on N1.

I guess if you do use your one-shot early it's important not to make that obvious to mafia and bluff that you can still action. This will create uncertainty for them which is important to keep our high priority town players alive.

Could this be the legendary Toony/Web scumteam?

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

If so, we're boned, so might as well not even consider it.  Like seriously, what are the odds on getting Toony and/or Web voted out Day 1? ZERO

What are you gonna do about it?

Does voting me out as town help town win? I mean, if so, I don't particuarly mind going out.  But what are we NOT looking at?

Does town!Jack not care about living? I think your nonchalance is suspicious.

very well, I vote for EuchreJack.

Good job, fine chap.

Now we fight!

You are scum!  SCUUMMMMMY SCUMMM SCUMMMBUCKETTEDY SCUMMM!
I mean, you can't even be bothered to read!
And, and, you didn't make a reads list yet!

You are so soo ssooooo scum!

Jack why are you insincerely playfighting here?

Ok, that's a valid point- I'm pretty shit at "reading" people. In my other game a1s didn't have to read anyone (because a1s wasn't town.)

How does each player make you feel? If you got more to say even better.

[Jim Groovester]

Does voting me out as town help town win? I mean, if so, I don't particuarly mind going out.  But what are we NOT looking at?

You tell me.

You are scum!  SCUUMMMMMY SCUMMM SCUMMMBUCKETTEDY SCUMMM!

Yeah this bothers me too.

[Maximum Spin]

Could this be the legendary Toony/Web scumteam?

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

If so, we're boned, so might as well not even consider it.  Like seriously, what are the odds on getting Toony and/or Web voted out Day 1? ZERO

I don't see it. They're not doing the thing. Remember Radio City?

Man, is this really the voting spread we're getting today? I guess out of these options I'd vote for a1s. Would anyone be tempted into switching to someone else, though? I'll even vote for web or Toony if you want, Jack, just to see what it's like.

[EuchreJack]

I'm actually OK with lynching a1s, since their lack of activity reminds me of their last game when they were scum.

So probably any "save things for later" tactic is a losing tactic.
Why do you want town to lose, Toonyman? 

How does town coordinate who uses actions at night without mafia knowing?

I had an idea on that.
Each player says who they want to protect, track, and roleblock.

For example, I would Protect Jim, Track ToonyMan, and Roleblock a1s/Web.

Players can then use that info to analyze what I might do, and avoid double-town-roleblock/track/protects.

[EuchreJack]

very well, I vote for EuchreJack.

Good job, fine chap.

Now we fight!

You are scum!  SCUUMMMMMY SCUMMM SCUMMMBUCKETTEDY SCUMMM!
I mean, you can't even be bothered to read!
And, and, you didn't make a reads list yet!

You are so soo ssooooo scum!

Jack why are you insincerely playfighting here?

Toonyman, I demand an apology!
I was very sincere in my playfighting!

[notquitethere]

I had an idea on that.
Each player says who they want to protect, track, and roleblock.

I see, so scum can check which one of them isn't being tracked, and which of their potential targets isn't being protected? I don't think this is a pro town suggestion!

[EuchreJack]

I had an idea on that.
Each player says who they want to protect, track, and roleblock.

I see, so scum can check which one of them isn't being tracked, and which of their potential targets isn't being protected? I don't think this is a pro town suggestion!

Or, town can cover everyone.
And town can figure out who scum would have picked to do the kill.
Hey, at least I'm trying to strategize! What have you done lately, pal?

[EuchreJack]

Reads list:
MaximumSpin - Isn't trying to get me lynched
TricMagic - Seems like his town self. As said before, his scumself is more subdued
Fluffe9911 - Is trying to figure out their first game of forum mafia, is not hyper-defensive (would be a more normal behavior in first game as mafia). The desire to not vote wrong is normal for newbie town, whereas newbie scum tends to be bloodthirsty in voting
notquitethere - I think more likely to vote me Day 1 as town. Lack of graphs is concerning, but seems like a happy cloud instead of a nightmare cloud.
Webadict - Who knows? 50% chance is lying about being a stem, for whatever that is worth
Jim Groovester - Seems like an ass, and not the good kind.
ToonyMan - Doing that "Jack is town" then flipping the switch and going "nah, Jack is scum". Dunno if that is just normal Toony interrogation behavior, or maybe he just doesn't like me. Maybe I've been mafia too often, so he's just panicking.
a1s - Hasn't been around much, and hasn't contributed.  Both things they did in the previous game as scum.

[TricMagic]

EuchreJack, might want a better reason than "haven't been around." And you have 3 blues.