Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

I'm disappointed that Knightwing hasn't done my assignment - or at least - hasn't told me he wasn't planning on doing them.

I still kind of just want to clear the replacement slot so the game doesn't suffer.

[FallacyofUrist]

FoU may have more luck staying alive if they voted Knightwing (or Vector).

But Knightwing is literally obvtown. He doesn't act like this if he's being coached. There's literally no reason to vote him other than to pressure him to put more effort into the game.

[FallacyofUrist]

I don't like a Vector execution either. The argument for clearing an empty slot is valid, but then Day 1's execution is wasted. We could execute someone based on actual scumminess instead of just for being unfortunately absent. We get more information out of the game state that way.

Ironically, that's something NQT, my current scum candidate, would probably advocate.

I'm probably in a position where I can sacrifice Knightwing to save myself, because there's too many people going after him, but I don't like that, because he's obviously town. There's no way a scum Knightwing doesn't get coached privately. I'm just too confident in my read to be willing to make that decision.

[ToonyMan]

FoU may have more luck staying alive if they voted Knightwing (or Vector).

Knightwing is literally obvtown.

Why?

[TricMagic]

I'm mostly hoping my vote on him will get him to sit up. If he's town, no way mafia aren't going to pick him as the lynch.

[ToonyMan]

There's no way a scum Knightwing doesn't get coached privately.

[FallacyofUrist]

FoU may have more luck staying alive if they voted Knightwing (or Vector).

Knightwing is literally obvtown.

Why?

Stop evaluating him with conventional scum tells. If you or hector was acting like this I'd go after them in a heartbeat. But this is a player who hasn't really learned to play the game yet. He's getting better, but his lack of engagement doesn't really say anything about his scumminess, because it's Knightwing.

The emotions read as genuine.

I am really confident in this. So yes, I would sacrifice myself for him, because it's just not fair of me to vote out Knightwing for my own sake.

There's no way a scum Knightwing doesn't get coached privately.

Memeing is good advice though

[TricMagic]

Lurkers get launched, just how it is Knightwing.

[hector13]

That just means the scum can get away with merely not being the least active player.

Do you really think that after almost 72 hours of action, the best vote is a policy vote?

[ToonyMan]

I've been mafia with Knightwing a couple times. He was mostly absent in the scumchat besides making Inspector Gadget noises. I gave some advice but it could only go so far. I'm not sure the "mafia would be coaching him" defense works here. If anything, a mafia!Knightwing is probably being told to try to appeal to people's emotions or something so that we don't vote him since that almost worked in the past.

[hector13]

Yeah I think in Jade Court KW spent huge portions of the game MIA as scum.

[notquitethere]

Fallacy

To quote you:

Pick a better target.

I'm not sure why you think KW being useless is something he'd never do as scum. Three possibilities present themselves:

1. You genuinely feel you have a deep meta read on him
2. You're scum and know he's not on your team
3. You're scum and you know he is on your team

Not a great set of possibilities, Fallacy

(ninja x7 with people saying much the same)

[EuchreJack]

I'm mostly hoping my vote on him will get him to sit up. If he's town, no way mafia aren't going to pick him as the lynch.

Hm, why do you think mafia are not already voting Knightwing?

[EuchreJack]

Fallacy

To quote you:

Pick a better target.

I'm not sure why you think KW being useless is something he'd never do as scum. Three possibilities present themselves:

1. You genuinely feel you have a deep meta read on him
2. You're scum and know he's not on your team
3. You're scum and you know he is on your team

Not a great set of possibilities, Fallacy

(ninja x7 with people saying much the same)

You forgot "Scum on the block to be lynched appealing to emotion"
"Please oh please don't lynch me, just look at how Townie I am being, for I am truly Town. Watch as I heroically sacrifice myself by stabbing my own corpse!"

[EuchreJack]

I will legitimately be sad if Fallacy flips town, fyi