Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

Is that so?  I don't see that, but perhaps you have biases that I don't understand.  Why do you not suspect NQT?  How does your read of KW differ from Vector?

It’s not that I don’t suspect NQT, he’s one of the ones I’m not sure about, I’d just rather see other people flip before him.

Frankly KW and Vector are in the same boat. Neither of them have posted much, and I’m not huge on making decisions based on nothing. Vector did give an excuse pre-game though, which is why I’m voting KW in the hope that they actually post.

Where I’m at is FoU is scumlocked, and there’s probably scum among KW, Vector ,NQT, Jim, and Max, in approximate descending order of likelihood.

[hector13]

You also said there are investigators that are possibly looking at NQT too, so his slot being solved that way means I’d prefer to look elsewhere for a D1 vote.

[TricMagic]

The main issue is that town or scum knightwing will just coast along never committing to anything. It's just what happens. Count up the number of posts he's made this game and their content, it's likely not much.

[webadict]

Is that so?  I don't see that, but perhaps you have biases that I don't understand.  Why do you not suspect NQT?  How does your read of KW differ from Vector?

It’s not that I don’t suspect NQT, he’s one of the ones I’m not sure about, I’d just rather see other people flip before him.

Frankly KW and Vector are in the same boat. Neither of them have posted much, and I’m not huge on making decisions based on nothing. Vector did give an excuse pre-game though, which is why I’m voting KW in the hope that they actually post.

Where I’m at is FoU is scumlocked, and there’s probably scum among KW, Vector ,NQT, Jim, and Max, in approximate descending order of likelihood.

I don't agree on FoU, Jim, or Max.  Jim, because Kook.  Max because he's not scumtelling.  And, FoU because he seems like he's putting in thought to his reads, and he usually acts a bit wilder as scum.

I'm moving to being a Hectorite on the PM issue. No one's PMing me and now I feel like I'm missing out.

Also, I look forward to being town cleared at the start of D2. Hopefully not every investigatory role will waste a night on this, but if one does then it's a win for me.


Anyway, what is the argument that KW is town? Like, what about his posting filled Jack et al with so much confidence?

Knightwing64: I want to say is town, but not posting enough. Could be as confused by the setup as I am, which would account for the lack of effort. Slight town.

Town but don't deserve it
Knightwing64

I would PM you, but I think you're scum, so I don't see how that would benefit me.  If you decided to PM other people, you'd be getting more PMs, so there is that.  Just do what I do and claim to random people you think are Town.

[EuchreJack]

Is that so?  I don't see that, but perhaps you have biases that I don't understand.  Why do you not suspect NQT?  How does your read of KW differ from Vector?

It’s not that I don’t suspect NQT, he’s one of the ones I’m not sure about, I’d just rather see other people flip before him.

Frankly KW and Vector are in the same boat. Neither of them have posted much, and I’m not huge on making decisions based on nothing. Vector did give an excuse pre-game though, which is why I’m voting KW in the hope that they actually post.

Where I’m at is FoU is scumlocked, and there’s probably scum among KW, Vector ,NQT, Jim, and Max, in approximate descending order of likelihood.

Why do you think those folk are scum, in descending order of likelihood?

[EuchreJack]

Anyway, what is the argument that KW is town? Like, what about his posting filled Jack et al with so much confidence?

Knightwing64: I want to say is town, but not posting enough. Could be as confused by the setup as I am, which would account for the lack of effort. Slight town.

Town but don't deserve it
Knightwing64

It's more like "Knightwing isn't the most important player for me to examine"
But let's turn that question around: Why are you so sure Knightwing is scum?

[hector13]

I don’t see any thought in FoU’s reads. He basically has five null reads and has an upset tummy read for his sole scumpick, and he appears to be making zero effort in solving those.

PPE: those are the players I am not sure about. KW popped up and then left, Vector has posted once as far as I can tell, NQT is… it feels like he’s doing things just to look like he’s doing things, but he’s here, and the previous two aren’t.

Jim seems a bit more serious than usual, but he did PM me with a quote of me saying I don’t want PMs just to spite me, which was funny, and gives a little town-cred over the others. Max is quite difficult for me to read so he generally always sits as a null read.

[hector13]

Ugh distractions.

FoU has been promoted by me a handful of times to elaborate on his read of me and has prevaricated each time with talk of Sharpness and soliloquies and fingertips. It doesn’t mean anything.

[Vector]

Storm is over, no chickens flew away. I haven't been able to reread yet but I'll do some good posting later tonight after work.

[Mamobo]

Vote Count
------------------------
-> Knightwing64 --4-- hector13*, Maximum Spin*, notquitethere*, Jim Groovester*,
hector13        --2-- Knightwing64*, FallacyofUrist*,
notquitethere   --2-- EuchreJack*, webadict*,
FallacyofUrist  --1-- TricMagic*,
Vector          --1-- ToonyMan*,
webadict        --1-- Vector*,
EuchreJack      --0--
Jim Groovester  --0--
Maximum Spin    --0--
ToonyMan        --0--
TricMagic       --0--
No One          --0--

Not Voting      --0--

6 to Hammer. Day ends on January 07, 2023 at 19:00 Central Standard Time (~26 hours remaining).

[Jim Groovester]

Anyway, what is the argument that KW is town?

Feeeeeeeeeel, mostly. I don't think Knightwing64 can do anything except wear his heart on his sleeve, and this feels Knightwing64 not having anything to hide.

[notquitethere]

It's easy to appear like you have nothing to hide if you don't say anything for half the game but ok. I think the game where he won as a serial-killer ally showed he's capable of being underestimated.

[webadict]

It's easy to appear like you have nothing to hide if you don't say anything for half the game but ok. I think the game where he won as a serial-killer ally showed he's capable of being underestimated.

Which game was that?  The only game I recall with a Knightwing SK win was with Knightwing being Town.

[ToonyMan]

It's easy to appear like you have nothing to hide if you don't say anything for half the game but ok. I think the game where he won as a serial-killer ally showed he's capable of being underestimated.

Didn't he literally claim that in-thread? I'm pretty sure he straight up told everyone "guys I am town but can also win with a SK if they exist" and that was 100% the truth. Because he submitted a role name that had Dubious in it or something.

[notquitethere]

Right, and he still won with the bad guys! That wasn't a town win!

I'm struggling to take seriously the "KW is always open" perspective. You guys don't seriously believe KW is dumb enough to go "oh damn, I got doppelganger and now a bunch of people are chatting to me in a quicktopic"?? If anything, you'd expect a town!KW to be more forthcoming than he has been, right?