Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[a1s]

There are two players you need to kill to win. Who are they?

If you follow my logic to it's conclusion, it's Tric and Jack. They have exposed themselves as the most likely Traitors.

My main issue is that there are two traitors among us. Jim, web, knightwing, and you a1s. So, knowing yourself to be town, which of the two are traitors?

For the sake of argument, if I had to choose from Jim, web, wing and a1s I would choose Jim and web. Only they're not, are they? because it's you two.

[a1s]

In case it's not abundantly obvious, I am asking you to name two players BY NAME that will win you the game when they are dead.

I don't know, and neither do you. But I've said my piece and I've made my peace with being dead next turn.

[TricMagic]

Web, your thoughts on this? You just made a fairly big mistake a1s. Jack and I, we're not really know to be stealthy. While it's true this can be a gambit to kill off town one by one publicly, you have to ask is it likely? Our theater performance would have to be extremely high for that to work.

[TricMagic]

Marks A1s.  I'm gonna take a guess and say you don't want your traitorous friend to be revealed.

I can guess the team is A1s Knightwing?

[webadict]

@Jim:  Should've been 2 damage unless you got marked.

@Tric:  Hmm, nah, I think you've got this handled.

Personally, I don't see how it's not a1s, but I think that means it's either Jim or Knightwing, and either way, that's a won gamestate.

[TricMagic]

@Jim:  Should've been 2 damage unless you got marked.

@Tric:  Hmm, nah, I think you've got this handled.

Personally, I don't see how it's not a1s, but I think that means it's either Jim or Knightwing, and either way, that's a won gamestate.

Well, Jack knows what to do now, hopefully. Will need help given it's a traitor here, but that in itself would be proof. 8 damage total and they're still alive, can just pop them next time. Or use the semi-auto to finish it anyway.

[webadict]

If you Mark a1s, Jack and I both deal 8, so anyone extra can get to 9.

a1s probably doesn't have armor, since he confirmed taking 1 damage, but it still might be a good idea to go all in on damage, just in case.

[TricMagic]

Jack's already shot them, so they're at 8 HP.

[webadict]

Jack's already shot them, so they're at 8 HP.

I am not paying attention.

[EuchreJack]

Jack's already shot them, so they're at 8 HP.

6hp.

a1s is town

There are two players you need to kill to win. Who are they?

If you follow my logic to it's conclusion, it's Tric and Jack. They have exposed themselves as the most likely Traitors.

My main issue is that there are two traitors among us. Jim, web, knightwing, and you a1s. So, knowing yourself to be town, which of the two are traitors?

For the sake of argument, if I had to choose from Jim, web, wing and a1s I would choose Jim and web. Only they're not, are they? because it's you two.

Mafiaso wouldn't be wasting time trying to argue with Jim/Web.

We also have NO evidence that Web actually shot Jim. It's the fatal flaw in this setup.

[EuchreJack]

If you Mark a1s, Jack and I both deal 8, so anyone extra can get to 9.

a1s probably doesn't have armor, since he confirmed taking 1 damage, but it still might be a good idea to go all in on damage, just in case.

Props on figuring out WHY I shot a1s.

[EuchreJack]

Jack's already shot them, so they're at 8 HP.

6hp.

a1s is town

There are two players you need to kill to win. Who are they?

If you follow my logic to it's conclusion, it's Tric and Jack. They have exposed themselves as the most likely Traitors.

My main issue is that there are two traitors among us. Jim, web, knightwing, and you a1s. So, knowing yourself to be town, which of the two are traitors?

For the sake of argument, if I had to choose from Jim, web, wing and a1s I would choose Jim and web. Only they're not, are they? because it's you two.

Mafiaso wouldn't be wasting time trying to argue with Jim/Web.

We also have NO evidence that Web actually shot Jim. It's the fatal flaw in this setup.

Disregard this. I typically talk myself OUT of the correct answer.

[EuchreJack]

You can't win the game without killing people so it's not really a surprise that people end up dead.

Justify you sitting on your high horse and tell me your magic solution to the game that kills all the traitors with no dead loyalists.

Dead loyalists come from traitorous fire and mistakes.
I kind of skimmed the thread (I am not good at this game,) so I didn't notice they agreed to murder poor max in plain sight (I was wondering how they got so coordinated without a dedicated discord, but actually Tric called marking max and Jack announced he would shoot him) My final concern was that they only pumped max 7DMG full of lead (3 from the shotgun and 4 from the rifle), which kills townies, but not tractors. Jack specifically avoided overkill by shooting me. What is the explanation for that? (no sarcasm- I'm bad at the game and don't know)

Wait a minute...are you REALLY that dumb?

[EuchreJack]

@a1s: Read this link, tell me why you're stupid, and maybe I won't shoot you.

[TricMagic]

Not really making any sense Jack. I don't think there are ay investigative roles in this game?