Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

If a1s is a Loyalist, this is probably their setup:
(Primary) Machine Gun: You shoot two targets for 2 damage each.
(Secondary) Medical Kit: You heal your target for 2 HP and remove Bleed from them.
(Passive) Body Armor: You start with 2 additional HP.

a1s would've claimed healing me, though.  It makes no sense to heal me.

I think they think you're town.
I mean, they shot me and Knightwing, and you were working with confirmed town Tric, so...

Is your suggestion that it's Jim and Knightwing?

[EuchreJack]

So, I'm worried that I might have missed claiming a shot, and I will be shot & gone myself, so here are the shots that I took:
Phase 1: Long Rifle Shoot Maximum Spin & Semi-Auto Pistol Shoot a1s
Phase 2: Shoot Jim with Long Rifle and Pistol
Phase 3: Shoot Web with Long Rifle and Pistol
Phase 4: 

[EuchreJack]

If a1s is a Loyalist, this is probably their setup:
(Primary) Machine Gun: You shoot two targets for 2 damage each.
(Secondary) Medical Kit: You heal your target for 2 HP and remove Bleed from them.
(Passive) Body Armor: You start with 2 additional HP.

a1s would've claimed healing me, though.  It makes no sense to heal me.

I think they think you're town.
I mean, they shot me and Knightwing, and you were working with confirmed town Tric, so...

Is your suggestion that it's Jim and Knightwing?

I'm leaning that way, yes.

[EuchreJack]

The Jim & Knightwing interactions remind me of when Jim & I were on a scumteam.

[EuchreJack]

Oh hey, Web moderated that game.

[Jim Groovester]

I think I would enjoy this game a bit more if the phases were 48 hour in length. 24 hours feels restrictive.

So, my current theory is that at least one of Web or Jim is scum. Because seriously, if they were both town, at least one mafia would be dead.

So, can I count on Web & Jim to shoot each other (and not me)? In fact, that sounds like great advice for everyone.  Shoot Jim or Web, but not Jack. Thanks much.

You can't count on me to shoot anybody. I am out of rounds.

So,

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

webadict healed Knightwing64
webadict shot a1s
a1s shot Knightwing64
a1s shot EuchreJack
Knightwing64 shot ?
EuchreJack shot webadict with long gun and pistol (for total 1 damage because webadict is Evasive apparently)
TricMagic shot EuchreJack probably
Jim shot nobody
Mystery healer healed webadict

Knightwing64 had health reduced to 5, took >2 damage
EuchreJack took 5 damage
webadict gained 1 health
a1s took no apparent damage
Jim took no apparent damage

If webadict is indeed telling the truth about healing Knightwing64, then Knightwing64 took >2 damage, but there's no claimed source of damage on Knightwing64 other than a1s' machine gun shot.
a1s claims to be at 1 hp (still), so either a1s possessed more health than they claim, they took no damage, either by nobody actually shooting them, or damage mitigation through soft or hard cover, or they were saved by a player with the Medic passive and a Medical Kit.

So is the only mystery about Phase 3 who damaged Knightwing64 in addition to a1s sufficient enough to bring him down to 5 hp, why a1s is still alive, and who the mystery healer is?

[webadict]

It's not impossible for Jim to be scum, but it's entirely unlikely for Jim to be scum.  Jim shot me with his primary weapon on the same Phase as the Flamethrower, so it's not at all likely that he's scum here.  Additionally, Jim using his primary weapon on Max on Phase 1 is a solidly Town move.  I don't really see how it's possible for Jim to be Town.  If you want to claim Knightwing is scum, that's an entirely different story, and I don't have solid proof unless he's the one who healed me.

[webadict]

I don't really see how it's possible for Jim to be Town.

*not be

[Jim Groovester]

Knightwing64 and I were scum together in Demon Mafia. I'd say our interactions are not reminiscent of that game.

[EuchreJack]

It's not impossible for Jim to be scum, but it's entirely unlikely for Jim to be scum.  Jim shot me with his primary weapon on the same Phase as the Flamethrower, so it's not at all likely that he's scum here.  Additionally, Jim using his primary weapon on Max on Phase 1 is a solidly Town move.  I don't really see how it's possible for Jim to be Town.  If you want to claim Knightwing is scum, that's an entirely different story, and I don't have solid proof unless he's the one who healed me.

I should shoot YOU for that logic.

Obviously, Jim's partner used the flamethrower.  Both mafia players get a freebie from the Mafia Gift Bag.

[EuchreJack]

And Knightwing No-claim could use a flamethrower, obviously.

[EuchreJack]

It's probably just Jim & Web, and the rest of us are probably already dead.  This sucks.

[webadict]

It's not impossible for Jim to be scum, but it's entirely unlikely for Jim to be scum.  Jim shot me with his primary weapon on the same Phase as the Flamethrower, so it's not at all likely that he's scum here.  Additionally, Jim using his primary weapon on Max on Phase 1 is a solidly Town move.  I don't really see how it's possible for Jim to be Town.  If you want to claim Knightwing is scum, that's an entirely different story, and I don't have solid proof unless he's the one who healed me.

I should shoot YOU for that logic.

Obviously, Jim's partner used the flamethrower.  Both mafia players get a freebie from the Mafia Gift Bag.

Okay, maybe I should explain it better:

Why didn't Jim save his cannon and just explode me in one shot on a Phase, instead of shooting me just the once.  Unless your suggestion is that he ALSO shot me with 3 damage worth of 1 damage shots on the same Phase, there's no reason to use his gun like that.

[webadict]

I still don't know why you think it's NOT a1s

[Jim Groovester]

Jack, why do you shoot me Phase 2?