Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

Web, first, you pushed for that lynch really quickly. Second, you had already lied once before. Third, Knightwing you idiot.

I'm actually really mad, because I think that had TricMagic shot literally anyone except me on Night 2, the game would've been a win for Town.

If TricMagic had shot Deus Asmoth on Night 1 LIKE HE WAS FUCKING SUPPOSED TO, this game would've been won.  IN FACT, IF HE HAD SHOT ANYONE EXCLUDING TOONYMAN ON NIGHT 1, IT WOULD'VE PROVEN HIM!

I cannot overstate enough that TricMagic managed to lose a won game for Town.  If anyone wants proof that voting TricMagic on Day 1 was wrong, this is all the evidence you need.

[ToonyMan]

I think Max played well and I have to question the life choices of certain players.

[EuchreJack]

Town's tracking abilities were unfortunately nerfed by Max killing Toony on Night 1.

Deus had a Town result on Toony, and Toony had a no-action on Web.  Had anyone else been shot than Toony, I think Mafia would have lost.

When I get more time, I can put together a more detailed writeup of the game.

[Maximum Spin]

I'm actually really mad, because I think that had TricMagic shot literally anyone except me on Night 2, the game would've been a win for Town.

I also had a bulletproof, so maybe not. There was actually nobody Tric could kill on N2. And realistically, I bet I could get him and KW to vote you out and then nightkill him.

[Deus Asmoth]

I cannot overstate enough that TricMagic managed to lose a won game for Town.  If anyone wants proof that voting TricMagic on Day 1 was wrong, this is all the evidence you need.

You say this like you're not the one who spend D1 gaslighting me over my correct read on Max.

[webadict]

Web, first, you pushed for that lynch really quickly. Second, you had already lied once before. Third, Knightwing you idiot.

So... You believed Max was a Town Roleblocker, blocked me, and I somehow still killed through the roleblock on ToonyMan, a player I claimed I was protecting?

BECAUSE THAT'S THE LOGIC YOU WOULD'VE HAD TO USE!

I'm actually really mad, because I think that had TricMagic shot literally anyone except me on Night 2, the game would've been a win for Town.

I also had a bulletproof, so maybe not. There was actually nobody Tric could kill on N2. And realistically, I bet I could get him and KW to vote you out and then nightkill him.

Unlikely.  You being alive would only raise eyebrows if TricMagic shot you.  Your roleblocking me Night 1 only makes you as the possible scum other than Deus Asmoth.  No one else shoots ToonyMan there.  You would've had to prove that both Mafia had resistance to Town Roleblocking.

I cannot overstate enough that TricMagic managed to lose a won game for Town.  If anyone wants proof that voting TricMagic on Day 1 was wrong, this is all the evidence you need.

You say this like you're not the one who spend D1 gaslighting me over my correct read on Max.

You spent the entire Day being combative.  I told you exactly what you were doing wrong, and you fought with me the entire time.  You can say I was gaslighting you, but I wasn't.

[Maximum Spin]

Unlikely.  You being alive would only raise eyebrows if TricMagic shot you.  Your roleblocking me Night 1 only makes you as the possible scum other than Deus Asmoth.  No one else shoots ToonyMan there.  You would've had to prove that both Mafia had resistance to Town Roleblocking.

Yeah, if I were arguing it to not Tric and Knightwing. But like, your first paragraph already shows that Tric suspected you despite my roleblock for no reason!

[Deus Asmoth]

You spent the entire Day being combative.  I told you exactly what you were doing wrong, and you fought with me the entire time.  You can say I was gaslighting you, but I wasn't.

So you just saying things that you want to be true isn't just an in game thing, you do it all the time? Cool. The fact of the matter is that I asked Max to justify a single action, he threw a tantrum and you decided that somehow made me scum. You can argue that my responses to you were combatitive, but you had fully earned it.

[Maximum Spin]

The fact of the matter is that I asked Max to justify a single action, he threw a tantrum and you decided that somehow made me scum.

You were actually wrong, though. I really did everything I would have done as town, and the fact that it looks shady to you helps me because the people who have played with me more will defend it. I did something similar in day 1 of BeBYOR2.

[webadict]

You spent the entire Day being combative.  I told you exactly what you were doing wrong, and you fought with me the entire time.  You can say I was gaslighting you, but I wasn't.

So you just saying things that you want to be true isn't just an in game thing, you do it all the time? Cool. The fact of the matter is that I asked Max to justify a single action, he threw a tantrum and you decided that somehow made me scum. You can argue that my responses to you were combatitive, but you had fully earned it.

I see.  So, you just sound combative.  That makes sense.  I don't see why you wouldn't listen to what I was saying when I was doing my best to get you to look Town.  It took until the last two minutes of the Day to get you to vote Jim, for instance, in spite of three other players trying to get you to do the same.

Unlikely.  You being alive would only raise eyebrows if TricMagic shot you.  Your roleblocking me Night 1 only makes you as the possible scum other than Deus Asmoth.  No one else shoots ToonyMan there.  You would've had to prove that both Mafia had resistance to Town Roleblocking.

Yeah, if I were arguing it to not Tric and Knightwing. But like, your first paragraph already shows that Tric suspected you despite my roleblock for no reason!

Knightwing would be easier to convince.  TricMagic is a loose grenade, but Knightwing usually thinks things through.  Usually.

[Knightwing64]

FUCK

DAMN YOU TRIC


The only winning move when Tric is involved seems to be ignoring his existence. Dammit, I thought Max was town because he Unvoted Tric


TRIC HOW AM I THE IDIOT

ME VOTING MAX INSTEAD OF YOU MADE NO SENSE

Jeez, if you abandon the gag at the start of the game, then start using it later in the game after someone called you out on not using the gag is obviously sus behavior, no? Max was fairly low-key.

No matter how you look at it, Tric was the sus one.

My revenge for Tric grows ever stronger. I demand a part 2 to finish the series with

[Knightwing64]

Max and Tric being mafia.


Post cut off.


Fwjefvmvrgwnrgwjgrmwrgvjjvfqe,qfveqevjffvjeww,fevevwmfejfv

[webadict]

To be fair, Knightwing, there were pieces of information that made Max the likeliest scum that you didn't sift through.  Max's best play was definitely rushing you into voting without looking at it, since I think he accurately identified that either of you would jump on a vote without realizing hammer.  His unvote allows him to potentially get TricMagic to vote Knightwing, as an insurance card.

I think your best move (if possible) would be to post while he had voted TricMagic to prove your were Town, and then have them argue who was scum for you.  Hammers being active means that someone can prove their Town by not Hammering.  I'm not sure if you saw that or not, but it was a possibility.

I think, thinking it through, Max might've made the right play as scum.  The right play as Town was to vote Knightwing, since Tric is cleared of the kill (double shot on the Bulletproof Vest), but I think relying on TricMagic to decide is probably too dangerous as scum.  I think TricMagic still votes Knightwing here, though, so Max played it really well to get in a position like that.

You can rush any Day except the last one!  Never rush the last Day!

[ToonyMan]

My revenge for Tric grows ever stronger.

Remember this my young Padawan: Embrace your emotions, let them fill you with rage and hatred.

[Jim Groovester]

Jim wins by doing nothing?

Jim totally did something: he agreed to let me bus him hard from the very start. Without that I think we would have had a much harder time.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)