Aye some very good points Webadict. This allows us to get much closer with the grid! (Juicebox, yer points are bleeding useless. Of course your night actions are unconfirmed as you claim not to do any. One of your day actions was confirmed but that's neither here not there.)
Updated Claims
Confirmed
Cap'n NQT: Gunsmith'd Juicebox, learned he's a killer AND he's not a third party (that's nice to know aye)
EuchreJack: Learned about the good Cap'N NQT's activities, confirmed them to a tee. If I'm lying then he's on me team.
Jim Groovester: Toonyman confirms being gifted something by Jim
TolyK: Gave the Toon a choice. Toony confirms this.
TricMagic: Arr, apparently inspected & followed NJW, which if NJW is telling the truth would have inspected & followed Jim. Jim claims to be on fire backs Tric's actions AND NJW's. Either way, the result was that one of them apparently targeted Web, but both NJW AND Jim deny this, so it seems like Tric is lying OR something's gone awry in the claims or my understanding o' them
NJW2000: did a bus. This is confirmed by Jim being on fire from targeted NJW, so confirmed by Tric and Jim combined.
webadict: Soaked a whole deck o' people, that's confirmed, and apparently tried to kill NJW which would have bussed to Jim who was set on fire by Tric, countering the effect. Claims to have roleblocked the target's target. Jim's target was Toony, who claims the roleblock.
ToonyMan: Block was confirmed by Web
Completely Unconfirmed
juicebox: Says he doesn't have a kill, I know he does. His lack of a night action is of course unaccounted for by anyone else.
Vector: Inspected web as town, probably redirected to Max (their claim was after KW claimed the redirect, though they apparently didn't notice)
Messy
Maximum Spin: who knows but it could have involved soaking or setting people on fire, given there's a few of those effects unaccounted for
Knightwing64: Redirects Web to Max. Do we know that happened for certain? Toony was blocked, Vector wouldn't know they were redirected. Odd thing to claim if false though.
Nakéen: Delay is not confirmed per se, but it not working would be explained by Web's block on Toony as blocks supercede delays.
---
Aye so clearly the killer was Juicebox, or, possibly Vector. Dry land is in sight, me hearties!
(O course, scum can mutually back one another's claims. A task for after another set of flips would be to unpick all the groups of mutual claims. Let's swab those decks when we get to them...)