Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Egan_BW]

Oh, I probably should have figured out what PDE meant before I used my power. Tric will be around for next night, then.

[Knightwing64]

Huh.

You revived Tric… for a single day?

Excuse me, I need to smash my monitor

[Maximum Spin]

Not really? You could’ve gave Jack and a ability as mafia and then loudly proclaimed it to make yourself seem more townie. There isn’t only two options there

That's a half-assed justification and I expect better. Anything can be waved away as WIFOM after the fact, but why would I make this particular choice in that case? It was entirely voluntary, and there are plenty of ways to make myself look town, especially when I think Jack already townread me, without giving mafia an explicit Achilles heel. I even have other abilities I could have given him that don't block the mafiakill. I specifically gave a player I think is town a strongly town-positive ability, because I want to help town.

I think NQT is a reasonable vote, however they couldn't have killed Persus if Max roleblocked them.

So who killed Persus?

Persus being an angel - Archons are what D&D call angels so it can copyright them - makes me really curious about the composition of Evil here. I can SEE angels being "Monsters" for the purposes of the flavor I mentioned before, but the description in the start of day flavor makes him sound a little SKish too, so maybe, if NQT is right about SKs being Evil, this really was a mafia kill? How many third parties could there reasonably BE, though? Anyone have any suggestions from previous games?

[Knightwing64]

While I agree there is probably a third party, I only think there is one third party faction, and I’m not part of it. Thanks.

[Maximum Spin]

While I agree there is probably a third party, I only think there is one third party faction, and I’m not part of it. Thanks.

There's already one admitted third party, Lenglon, so.

[ToonyMan]

All right, I'm not planning to hang around the rest of the day, so I guess I might as well spill what I know. It's not much, but it might be helpful still.

There's a devil-summoning witch, the "Summoner", who has an ability called Devil Deal that I imagine is somehow related to the devil role someone mentioned a long time ago. There also seems to be a team of "Monsters".

The "Monsters" are only suggested in flavortext, but the witch is just about definite, because my role specifically reacts (badly) to the use of that ability, which would have effectively recruited me if it had hit. It's hard to imagine something that specific would be meant as a red herring.

Hmm. A Demon Summoner? Sounds cool

Also, if any of you have a bodyguard role, I would like it to be used on me due to my crippling fear of death

Hohoho

@Max:
If someone wants to claim slaying Evil Persus that would be great.

If no one claims then we can theorize that Evil killed Evil...but why?

[Knightwing64]

Not really? You could’ve gave Jack and a ability as mafia and then loudly proclaimed it to make yourself seem more townie. There isn’t only two options there

That's a half-assed justification and I expect better. Anything can be waved away as WIFOM after the fact, but why would I make this particular choice in that case? It was entirely voluntary, and there are plenty of ways to make myself look town, especially when I think Jack already townread me, without giving mafia an explicit Achilles heel. I even have other abilities I could have given him that don't block the mafiakill. I specifically gave a player I think is town a strongly town-positive ability, because I want to help town.

I think NQT is a reasonable vote, however they couldn't have killed Persus if Max roleblocked them.

So who killed Persus?

Persus being an angel - Archons are what D&D call angels so it can copyright them - makes me really curious about the composition of Evil here. I can SEE angels being "Monsters" for the purposes of the flavor I mentioned before, but the description in the start of day flavor makes him sound a little SKish too, so maybe, if NQT is right about SKs being Evil, this really was a mafia kill? How many third parties could there reasonably BE, though? Anyone have any suggestions from previous games?

Also, this is kinda irrelevant, But I thought the blanket term for angels in DND was celestial

[Knightwing64]

All right, I'm not planning to hang around the rest of the day, so I guess I might as well spill what I know. It's not much, but it might be helpful still.

There's a devil-summoning witch, the "Summoner", who has an ability called Devil Deal that I imagine is somehow related to the devil role someone mentioned a long time ago. There also seems to be a team of "Monsters".

The "Monsters" are only suggested in flavortext, but the witch is just about definite, because my role specifically reacts (badly) to the use of that ability, which would have effectively recruited me if it had hit. It's hard to imagine something that specific would be meant as a red herring.

Hmm. A Demon Summoner? Sounds cool

Also, if any of you have a bodyguard role, I would like it to be used on me due to my crippling fear of death

Hohoho

@Max:
If someone wants to claim slaying Evil Persus that would be great.

If no one claims then we can theorize that Evil killed Evil...but why?

Yeah. I wanted to hold off on admitting I was a witch until I had at least one soul. Kinda a, don’t wanna get killed before I use my action type of thing.

[Knightwing64]

I do have a monster tag on my devilish deal ability, but I’m a townie overall, are you sure monster isn’t just a flair thing for abilities?

[Maximum Spin]

All right, I'm not planning to hang around the rest of the day, so I guess I might as well spill what I know. It's not much, but it might be helpful still.

There's a devil-summoning witch, the "Summoner", who has an ability called Devil Deal that I imagine is somehow related to the devil role someone mentioned a long time ago. There also seems to be a team of "Monsters".

The "Monsters" are only suggested in flavortext, but the witch is just about definite, because my role specifically reacts (badly) to the use of that ability, which would have effectively recruited me if it had hit. It's hard to imagine something that specific would be meant as a red herring.

Hmm. A Demon Summoner? Sounds cool

Also, if any of you have a bodyguard role, I would like it to be used on me due to my crippling fear of death

Hohoho

I thought that at the time, too.

[Knightwing64]

I think what the thing is, is the mafia team has a monster tag in their abilities, and my role is kinda like someone who defected? Which is why I have the monster tag, but I’m town, if that makes sense.

[Lenglon]

N1 actions:
notquitethere -- unclaimed action, Roleblocked by Max
Knightwing64     -- Offered Jack a Devil Deal
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT
4maskwolf        -- Transformed Lenglon into someone that can Jailkeep
Egan_BW          -- unclaimed action, currently reviving Tric At Day's End
EuchreJack       -- Stole roleblock + prevent mafiakill from Max, got another Monster ability (undisclosed).
hector13         -- unclaimed action
Jim Groovester   -- unclaimed action
Lenglon          -- Bug Max (action succeeded), gift monster action of NQT's to Jack
ToonyMan         -- Tracked Vector, claims Vector no-visited
Vector           -- unclaimed action, limited kills to Perseus and Hector as D1 action, seen as no-visiting by Toony.

[ToonyMan]

I do have a monster tag on my devilish deal ability, but I’m a townie overall, are you sure monster isn’t just a flair thing for abilities?

It is. We have a number of players with monster tags who probably aren't Evil.

So from what I gathered, the most likely players to have killed Persus are:

Egan
Jack
Hector
Jim

Everyone else was doing something or couldn't do anything.

[ToonyMan]

@Lenglon:
Oh you're right, Jack did an action.

[Lenglon]

@Toony, I'm not interested in finding who killed the Evil right now. They might be able to do it again and I don't want them targeted if that is the case.