Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

You don’t have time to fully mourn yet as you continue to Jim Groovester’s lodge.  You see that he, like Persus13 the day before, has been cut open and had his organs laid out in a meticulous circle.  Searching through his pockets, you find the tattered remains of a Wizard scroll in what amounts to a Witch’s robe.  Combining the secretive magical arts like that, The Elder explains, would be only possible from an Eclectic Witch.

Wait...what?? I didn't read this paragraph clearly when the day started. It does say Wizard and Witch here wtf

[hector13]

@NQT: I don’t, I just don’t think a Max elimination gains traction as it stands. Which is fine as Jack and No Lynch are at least being considered right now.

PPE: @Toony: my list said there’s 1 Wizard, which is Jim, who was also 1 of the 3 Witches.

[ToonyMan]

Okay so Max is an unknown role, but that still doesn't make them Evil because players like myself and Lenglon have also not been divined by Hector. Although now I'm curious what Max is.

[ToonyMan]

I've heard Toony's (flimsy) reasons for town reading Max, but Vector, Hector, Euchre— why do you think he's legit?

I've got a better idea.

Jack

[Lenglon]

Unvote
What's going on now?

Spoiler: N1 actions (click to show/hide)

notquitethere -- attempted to destroy Tric's body, Roleblocked by Max.
Knightwing64     -- Offered Jack a Devil Deal
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT
4maskwolf        -- Transformed Lenglon into someone that can Jailkeep
Egan_BW          -- No Action, currently reviving Tric At Day's End
EuchreJack       -- Stole roleblock + prevent mafiakill from Max, got another Monster ability (Bind Souls, redirects two targets to each other), accepted Devil Deal from Knightwing, got a Watch action.
hector13         -- received three role names, and how many of each there are in the game. The roles received were Mystic, Wizard, and Sage (1 each).
Jim Groovester   -- Lookout (or Watch) on Hector, nobody visited Hector.
Lenglon          -- Bug Max (action succeeded), gift monster action of NQT's to Jack
ToonyMan         -- Tracked Vector, claims Vector no-visited
Vector           -- no-actioned, limited kills to Perseus and Hector as D1 action, seen as no-visiting by Toony.
Perseus          -- died, unknown action

Spoiler: N2 actions (click to show/hide)

notquitethere -- attempted to destroy Tric's body, Roleblocked by Max and Lenglon.
Knightwing64     -- Offered Max a Devil Deal
Maximum Spin     -- Roleblocked NQT, accepted Devil Deal and vanilaized Knightwing.
4maskwolf        -- Died and Transformed Lenglon again.
EuchreJack       -- Protected Vector
hector13         -- received three role names, and how many of each there are in the game. The roles received were 1 Dreamwalker. 1 Sexton, and 3 Witches.
Jim Groovester   -- Died, Protected Toonyman
Lenglon          -- Roleblocked NQT, was transformed by 4mask again.
ToonyMan         -- Shot 4mask.
Vector           -- unknown action.

Spoiler: Rolenames (click to show/hide)

4maskwolf -- Dreamwalker
Egan_BW -- Priest
EuchreJack -- Thief
hector13 -- ?Sage?
Jim Groovester -- Witch, ?Wizard?
Knightwing64 -- Witch
Lenglon -- Pixie (has changed each night due to 4mask visits)
Maximum Spin --
notquitethere -- Sexton
Persus13 -- Mystic
ToonyMan -- Monster Hunter
TricMagic -- Guard
Vector -- ?Witch?

[EuchreJack]

I've heard Toony's (flimsy) reasons for town reading Max, but Vector, Hector, Euchre— why do you think he's legit?

I've got a better idea.

Jack

Well, I guess I better answer this.

I believe Toony is a Town Vigilante because his Day 2 lead up to the reveal seemed natural. And on Day 3, he admitted to one of the kills without contradiction. He's also claimed Monster Hunter, which implies a killing ability. If Toony we're Mafia, it means Mafia has two kills and we're probably screwed.
Toony could be Third Party, but I'm just not seeing it.
Toony's trying to solve, rather than trying to kill us all off.

[EuchreJack]

Also, only 3.5 hours or so until end of day. And Mafia chooses if we tie.

[Maximum Spin]

To clarify: town-sided lies are good and appropriate,  but this constant low level fabrication, avoidance, misdirection. What's it all for?

Honestly, you can do better than this. You keep pushing this line, but what "constant low level fabrication, avoidance, misdirection"? I set up a trap to neutralize a player I thought was anti-town, particularly one nobody wanted to vote out; and I made a joke to cover my d1 vote for you like I've often done. I might be forgetting something, but most of this fabrication is in your head because you don't LIKE the truth I'm saying. Or more accurately, really, you just want to pretend that to justify voting me out.

You don’t have time to fully mourn yet as you continue to Jim Groovester’s lodge.  You see that he, like Persus13 the day before, has been cut open and had his organs laid out in a meticulous circle.  Searching through his pockets, you find the tattered remains of a Wizard scroll in what amounts to a Witch’s robe.  Combining the secretive magical arts like that, The Elder explains, would be only possible from an Eclectic Witch.

Wait...what?? I didn't read this paragraph clearly when the day started. It does say Wizard and Witch here wtf

For the record, I noticed that immediately, but I wanted to softball it to see if hector would screw up.

Although now I'm curious what Max is.

But, while I won't tell you so that hector still has the chance to screw up, you can probably tell just by looking at the town roles and thinking hard.

[ToonyMan]

Can you find the hints I dropped in D1 as well Jack??

There's at least two.

[Maximum Spin]

Can you find the hints I dropped in D1 as well Jack??

There's at least two.

I saw 'em

[Maximum Spin]

There also seems to be a team of "Monsters".

The "Monsters" are only suggested in flavortext,

Did Max give up on this idea? I'd forgotten he said this.

Oh, I forgot I wanted to respond to this.

It's still true. What more is there to say? I was told in my opening flavor that monsters were causing problems. I'm not even sure which monsters it means at this point, but the mafia are the obvious choice.

[EuchreJack]

@4mask:
Very funny. I'm happy you aren't claiming TP (because I'd kill ya), but are aware of last Supernatural enough to vote me. Your playfulness is neutral in my eyes. You would do this as town or scum.


Monsters eh...there's a lot of players in this game so I'd wager 3 or 4 non-good players if I could read my cards right.

I can't think of an interesting icebreaker so I'm gonna ask Knightwing a question.

Knightwing, how was your morning today?

One

[ToonyMan]

Although now I'm curious what Max is.

But, while I won't tell you so that hector still has the chance to screw up, you can probably tell just by looking at the town roles and thinking hard.

Yeah I think I could make a good guess.

One

The hunt begins.

[EuchreJack]

@Persus13:

Given that you've played at least 7 out of the 10 regular Supernatural games, what's your favorite moment from those, and what's a mistake you hope not to repeat for this game?

Oh right...

As for mistakes I don't wish to repeat, some of them are out of my control, like if there's one mafia that converts a vig tonight I'm just going to be mad because finding one scum is annoyingly hard already with so many players and then the extra kill power would push me beyond upset. I don't think Web would do that, but he'd maybe subvert it in some way. There's a lot of Monster stuff going on here.

If we had listened to Luckyowl on D1 of Supernatural 10 and lynched Web we would have been most likely victorious, but we didn't. So maybe I need to take into account even the most inexperienced player's opinion for success. I can't be too dismissive of things that are actually possible, especially when a lynch is happily going through and nobody but the person being lynched is doing anything. Contentment is probably our demise.

Toony: I am rapidly coming to the conclusion that you are correct, and that it wasn't a concern after all, but I did not know that at the time, and thought that the Good players might only be a sub-faction of town, which would require protection. At the time of Jack's question, they were lacking the same information I was, and so I remain concerned about their questioning, but it is currently only a cause for mild suspicion, as I said to Knightwing earlier.

If you can help find Good just as much as Evil that would be appreciated, Lenglon.

Two?

[ToonyMan]

Two?

You could say that counts, yeah. Not one I was thinking of though.