Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Supernerd]

It seems pretty straight forward to me. Once you play Hell Broth, any of your opponent's cards that are destroyed before the end of your turn would be under your control. There's nothing on the card that would cause a delay on this.

[notquitethere]

Yes I can see that now. I've had a fuzzy head with a cold this week and keep making dumb reading comprehension mistakes. I'll edit my turn with the good news.

[NUKE9.13]

I think that should be a BFG, not a Mystery Ghost.

[notquitethere]

I've had a fuzzy head with a cold this week and keep making dumb reading comprehension mistakes.

I think that should be a BFG, not a Mystery Ghost.

Case in point. I've edited again!

[Happerry]

"I play another Wooly and send your resummoned ghost back to the graveyard before my ghost sends your stolen Wooly to the graveyard as well."



--------
My stats:
Hearts: 9
Stars: 4
Board: BFG (2/1 - FACE DOWN), Mystery Ghost (2/[1/3]), Wooly 2/2

Your stats:
Hearts: 7
Stars: 2
Board:

[notquitethere]

Draw two, shuffling oldest in.

"Let's start over..."



Everything is wiped clear (including face down cards apparently).

My stats:
Hearts: 7
Stars: 2
Board:

Your stats:
Hearts: 9
Stars: 4
Board: BFG (2/-3 FACE DOWN, DEAD ON ARRIVAL)

[TricMagic]

(Well, once those cards get flipped anyway)

[notquitethere]

(We really decided this was the best way to process damage on flipped cards?)

[NUKE9.13]

It makes sense, since you might not know how many hearts a face-down card has. It might have zero, if it's a face-down spell.
Relevant, since the BFG's ability will presumably still work, even though it dies immediately. After all, a 0/0 card's ability works, and it dies immediately too.

[notquitethere]

OK reasonable point I guess. I've edited the last go to reinstate the Big Friendly Ghost.

[Stirk]

It makes sense, since you might not know how many hearts a face-down card has. It might have zero, if it's a face-down spell.
Relevant, since the BFG's ability will presumably still work, even though it dies immediately. After all, a 0/0 card's ability works, and it dies immediately too.

Can you return a card with 0 hearts to the hand though? It doesn't seem like there would be any valid target for BFG's effect.

[notquitethere]

Can you return a card with 0 hearts to the hand though? It doesn't seem like there would be any valid target for BFG's effect.

Not right now, but Elric the Brown Haired is just going to keep the ghost there to dissuade me from casting a powerful card like Pacifist Gun Waifu.

[Stirk]

Can you return a card with 0 hearts to the hand though? It doesn't seem like there would be any valid target for BFG's effect.

Not right now, but Elric the Brown Haired is just going to keep the ghost there to dissuade me from casting a powerful card like Pacifist Gun Waifu.

If it stays on the board that invites all kinds of goofiness

[TricMagic]

Such is life. Otherwise facedown spells wouldn't stick around either.

[Stirk]

Such is life. Otherwise facedown spells wouldn't stick around either.

It would also mean those cards that can attack while face down are completely invulnerable, which is probably not the intent.