Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Knightwing64]

Jim has been acting unusual, not as aggressive, I guess? Maybe I’m being fooled but Lidku has a point about Jim not being a asshole this game, which is very strange and weird for him

So do you think Lidku is town? This relates towards my question to you.

Who would you shoot tonight if you were around?

Maximum Spin, I think.

[webadict]

Who would you protect?

[Knightwing64]

Who would you protect?

Uh, You.

[Lenglon]

Why?

[ToonyMan]

D1 Reads:

Town
Lenglon
Jim
Web
Max
NQT

I can't read ever
NJW

Mafia
Lidku
Knightwing


I doubt Knightwing is town considering I feel like I'm in Demon Mafia again agreeing with Max and Web about everything.

The difference is that I don't think Jim is with Knightwing this time. Lidku could be fighting hard to keep KW alive unlike Jim's more hands back approach. I think I always shoot Lidku here if KW is mafia.

If Knightwing is town? Then I think I still believe in Webadict...but I feel worse about Max. I also like Lidku more than NJW.

[ToonyMan]

If there's some world where Webadict is mafia, then I think it's with Lenglon, not Max like Lidku has been saying. Max is town if Web is mafia.

[ToonyMan]

For comparison, here are my D1 reads during Demon's Mafia (Jim and Knightwing were mafia):

D1 Reads

Townie
Max - actively hunting, thinking
Web - same as Max (why don't they like Jim?)
Tric - claimed miller!
Hector - really laying out their thoughts, don't think they're phony
Jim - feels good

Null
NJW - he's being mean, probably town

Mafia
NQT - Mr. bad plans, did they get stuck with KW this time?
KW - he's mafia, if he's not then that means me, Max, and Web are all wrong on our read which seems bad

[Knightwing64]

Why?

Dunno, he seems trustable this time.



Seriously Toony? It isn’t like you to be wrong so many times in a row.

[Maximum Spin]

For comparison, here are my D1 reads during Demon's Mafia (Jim and Knightwing were mafia):

Hmm, doesn't that mean you should be most suspicious of one of your townreads this time? It would be most straightforward to say that Jim still fills the same role as Jim (certainly, Web and I are doing the same thing as that time), but maybe NQT or Lenglon could be the new Jim this time, since Lidku is filling in the NQT slot on your old list.

I don't really think it's that direct a comparison, but it's interesting to think about.

[ToonyMan]

@Knightwing:

Seriously Toony? It isn’t like you to be wrong so many times in a row.

I...when have I been wrong about you? You won't even take my advice to show me how a mafia!Max is setting you up like in the previous game I wasn't a part of. You could literally pull examples from that game about how you're town like in that game. Or you could prove I've been wrong about you more than I have been right, but do you really want to go back and check? Because I bet the result won't be in your favor.

@Max:

For comparison, here are my D1 reads during Demon's Mafia (Jim and Knightwing were mafia):

Hmm, doesn't that mean you should be most suspicious of one of your townreads this time? It would be most straightforward to say that Jim still fills the same role as Jim (certainly, Web and I are doing the same thing as that time), but maybe NQT or Lenglon could be the new Jim this time, since Lidku is filling in the NQT slot on your old list.

I don't really think it's that direct a comparison, but it's interesting to think about.

It is interesting to think about. I admit I'm subconsciously against a Jim/Knightwing scum team again due to Gambler's Fallacy even though I was scum with KW multiple times in a row.

[Maximum Spin]

It is interesting to think about. I admit I'm subconsciously against a Jim/Knightwing scum team again due to Gambler's Fallacy even though I was scum with KW multiple times in a row.

I'm subconsciously against it too, but not so much for the Gambler's Fallacy reason, as that I think Jim would be handling it differently this time.
That said, I think I said that about YOU back then, too.

[webadict]

Who would you protect?

Uh, You.

...

Dunno, he seems trustable this time.

...

?

I don't really believe you on that. That makes no sense and sounds way too much like trying to buddy me. It's bad. You could be picking literally anyone, like NJW or Lidku or... Really, anyone, but I'm just not sure why you'd say me.

If I had to guess, I think you being a Doctor is probably true. But, I think scum having a Doctor is entirely plausible.

[Knightwing64]

It’s true lol, I sense a distinct lack of asshole energy from you, so I guess that kinda made me think better of you, I guess.

[webadict]

It’s true lol, I sense a distinct lack of asshole energy from you, so I guess that kinda made me think better of you, I guess.

That doesn't make me Town, though.

[Knightwing64]

It’s normally a sign of a townie, at least in my book. Although, you being nice could be because your scum and are trying not to get shot