Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Lidku]

My reads for suspicion go like this:

TricMagic for his general strange behavior this game.

Egan & Fallacy in the same row of things that are either/or here for me. I'm just generally confused about this whole "Miller" phenomenon in general and the fact that it can misrepresent someone's alignment to read as something else (maybe some trauma from the last game O_o).

I'm leaning to maybe change my vote to Egan, to just end this very drawn out D1, but I'm afraid to be the one to hammer without consensus..

[Egan_BW]

It might be possible to me to be shown to be the role I say I am, if someone redirects the mafiakill to me since I have a one shot mafiakill resistance. I didn't mention that in hopes that I'd get targeted by the nightkill for being double voter, but I'm pretty sure I'm not making it out of this anyways.

I mean hell, I'm not even particularly confident in my Fal vote, I just couldn't decide on anybody better.


And yeah it might have been silly to send in a Challenge Mode role prompt when I don't even know what I'm doing.

[Egan_BW]

Might have been better to have just not claimed miller for the increased chance of getting through a day. And maybe picked a night move to use on that night. Eh.

[Egan_BW]

I'm leaning to maybe change my vote to Egan, to just end this very drawn out D1, but I'm afraid to be the one to hammer without consensus..

I'm pretty sure you have consensus dude. But hold off if you think the remaining hours of day could have some insights.

[TricMagic]

The only ability I have potential access to is Great War>Deception is Truth, which could let me steal an Ability. No clue how effective it would be though.

I'm leaning towards Lidku as the day nears it's end though.

[Lenglon]

I'm leaning towards Lidku as the day nears it's end though.

Could you go into detail as to why?

[Egan_BW]

I'm not really sure why Fal decided that me and NJW are scumteam, though. Because we both used the same stupid argument? Does that really tie us together?

[TricMagic]

Mostly the lack of impact during this game, and feeling Egan isn't really scum here. Webadict loves punishing people for mechanical solving, so I would see him putting an mega-Miller in the game just to mess with people.

I can't really read Fal though, and like you said, Egan's dayplay has not been all that good.

[Shakerag]

The only ability I have potential access to is Great War>Deception is Truth, which could let me steal an Ability. No clue how effective it would be though.

I'm leaning towards Lidku as the day nears it's end though.

That's worth noting for D2, but if you switch your vote with 45 minutes remaining you'll give us a tie.

[FallacyofUrist]

I think we've pretty much given everyone a chance to contribute to the end of day outcome. I'm okay with a hammer now.

My reads for suspicion go like this:

TricMagic for his general strange behavior this game.

Personally, I want to see how TricMagic and Shakerag act on Day 2. Along with some Spin. And Knightwing. Actually I want to see how everyone acts on Day 2. Because while I'm pretty sure NJW2000 is the second mafia player, I'm not as certain about him as I am about Egan. More information will still be helpful.

The only ability I have potential access to is Great War>Deception is Truth, which could let me steal an Ability. No clue how effective it would be though.

I'm leaning towards Lidku as the day nears it's end though.

That's worth noting for D2, but if you switch your vote with 45 minutes remaining you'll give us a tie.

Oh, yeah, no. No ties. Ties very bad. Unacceptable, that.

[Egan_BW]

Unvote. No ties. And Fal may very well be town anyways.

[Shakerag]

It is worth noting that mafia chooses a tie-breaker as opposed to there being a no-lynch, but if Egan and FoU are both town, then that could just lead to mafia getting 2 free lynches.

[FallacyofUrist]

I'm not really sure why Fal decided that me and NJW are scumteam, though. Because we both used the same stupid argument? Does that really tie us together?

You following NJW's lead and exhibiting similar behavior patterns. Like I said, I'm not 100% confident NJW is the other scum, it just seems very likely.

[Egan_BW]

What will your opinion on NJW change to when I flip as town, then?

[Shakerag]

Personally, I want to see how TricMagic and Shakerag act on Day 2. Along with some Spin. And Knightwing. Actually I want to see how everyone acts on Day 2. Because while I'm pretty sure NJW2000 is the second mafia player, I'm not as certain about him as I am about Egan. More information will still be helpful.

As far as progressing to a goal, D1 is usually a wash and town is lynched.  But on D2 we've had a round of night actions (and probably a scum NK) and we can start analyzing D1 behaviours in light of the roleflips.