Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

This post is a copy from between D1 and D2 that I made by accident:

@Toony & Web: How exactly are Jim and I not on the same team? I'm not seeing it. Please explain, as I would like to see it.

What I mean is that I don't think you're both mafia. I feel like the grievances Jim is showing of you is very natural. He mocks you here. He implies you're Onyx here. He supports Roden's caution of you here. This reasons you're both town or only one of you is scum.

Toony, I think, just wants to be nominated. Look at how Toony clears away anyone that might possibly get nominated.

What do you mean? I would like to be nominated, but I'm not shutting down players I think are town.

[ToonyMan]

Haaaaaa, who do I support: Reina or Roden?

(anybody notice something odd with the D1 vote count?)

I think Reina is the right pick between the two, for various reasons...

Knightwing, what do you think about Reina?

[webadict]

Maximum Spin has two votes, that's probably it.

[Jim Groovester]

If this were a game with a lynch reina is the player I would be voting after Egan_BW. With that in mind I couldn't possibly let my second top suspect get nominated.

My read on reina is tepid at best. I think they are playing a much weaker game than they're being given credit for. I think there are other players who are much safer town picks who we could nominate instead. Roden is one of them but there are also players I think are reasonably safe bets as well.

[EuchreJack]

Maximum Spin has two votes, that's probably it.

Why Max?

[EuchreJack]

@Roden: If you were to be nominated, would you be willing and able to accept that nomination?
You can answer by self-voting, if you wish.

[EuchreJack]

Reina for now.  Sit on the Pedestal.

[Roden]

Roden

I knew there wouldn't be much fanfare when transitioning to the next Day phase, but it still feels weird to me.

I'm curious about something. A lot of people are scum reading Egan, and he isn't really fighting it, though no one's really attacking or questioning him either. If he really is a Cabal member, what would this suggest about the game state?

To me, it makes me think that the Cabal team might not have much influence over the game state. Which adds up with how "set" the game feels right now, there are very few viable candidates and the status quo doesn't seem to be changing much as the game goes on.

[Roden]

@Roden: If you were to be nominated, would you be willing and able to accept that nomination?
You can answer by self-voting, if you wish.

My self vote wasn't actually an answer, I didn't pay attention to the preview edit before answering lol. But yes I'd easily accept a nomination.

[webadict]

If this were a game with a lynch reina is the player I would be voting after Egan_BW. With that in mind I couldn't possibly let my second top suspect get nominated.

My read on reina is tepid at best. I think they are playing a much weaker game than they're being given credit for. I think there are other players who are much safer town picks who we could nominate instead. Roden is one of them but there are also players I think are reasonably safe bets as well.

Name them.

[webadict]

Maximum Spin has two votes, that's probably it.

Why Max?

Based on what he said earlier.

[Jim Groovester]

If this were a game with a lynch reina is the player I would be voting after Egan_BW. With that in mind I couldn't possibly let my second top suspect get nominated.

My read on reina is tepid at best. I think they are playing a much weaker game than they're being given credit for. I think there are other players who are much safer town picks who we could nominate instead. Roden is one of them but there are also players I think are reasonably safe bets as well.

Name them.

Voting for one and also named one already. Roden and ToonyMan I'm okay with. If EuchreJack gets nominated I doubt that loses the game for the town. I'm also not going to go out of my way to promote him but I don't think Knightwing64 loses the game for town either.

What about you, webadict? You've said reina and ToonyMan. Who's your third? Maybe in the intersection of the set of my town reads and the set of your town reads there are two players we both agree on.

[ToonyMan]

I feel like Reina has vocal detractors (it's not just Jim), while Roden does not. Is there anybody that's vehemently against Roden?

[EuchreJack]

@Roden: If you were to be nominated, would you be willing and able to accept that nomination?
You can answer by self-voting, if you wish.

My self vote wasn't actually an answer, I didn't pay attention to the preview edit before answering lol. But yes I'd easily accept a nomination.

And I would gladly second/third that, Roden

Maximum Spin has two votes, that's probably it.

Why Max?

Based on what he said earlier.

I didn't take Max's claim to mean he was a double voter.
@Max: Care to elaborate?

[webadict]

If this were a game with a lynch reina is the player I would be voting after Egan_BW. With that in mind I couldn't possibly let my second top suspect get nominated.

My read on reina is tepid at best. I think they are playing a much weaker game than they're being given credit for. I think there are other players who are much safer town picks who we could nominate instead. Roden is one of them but there are also players I think are reasonably safe bets as well.

Name them.

Voting for one and also named one already. Roden and ToonyMan I'm okay with. If EuchreJack gets nominated I doubt that loses the game for the town. I'm also not going to go out of my way to promote him but I don't think Knightwing64 loses the game for town either.

What about you, webadict? You've said reina and ToonyMan. Who's your third? Maybe in the intersection of the set of my town reads and the set of your town reads there are two players we both agree on.

I wrote an entire list of people.

reina
ToonyMan
Roden
EuchreJack
Jim Groovester
Maximum Spin
Knightwing64
Egan_BW

In that order. I can even tell you why, because I've done it a couple of times for each person.

The problem I have, however, is that I'm still going to continue voting reina because I don't fully trust you.