On RodenOK this is weird right when you consider that Roden has claimed not to have been commuting on N1:
What did you do last night Max?
How would have Max info? (or is it distancing...?)
Also why did they target Tric? Did they expect him to fake claim? I mean, he has before, but only to pretend his role was stronger than it actually was. It's a weird kill.
"First one to speculate on the kill choice is scum" is an old tell but it sometimes checks out.
I will say, though, that this is a good question to ask:
Tric, just to make sure I understand your role, you're claiming that if Jack dies, you'll also die? And that he's the only one you can't protect with your Doc ability? If so, why did you tell everyone this...?
I would guess that Tric is either lying or just likes to talk about how smart they are. Still, it's this from Roden is an example of rolefishing over scumhunting, something Tric is guilty of themselves. Jack was right to pick up on this dynamic.
Funny that neither NQT or 4mask have yet to react or respond to the PoE plan.
This is the first post where I've properly addressed D2, but go off. Anyway, it's nonsense, clearing people on the flimsiest of pretexts. Exactly the sort of thing I'd expect from mafia!roden.
On JimJim doesn't know how his power works. To be fair, my power is a big ole wall of text so I can see how reading comprehension can go awry. NAI. But it does mean he spent a lot of effort on speculation based on bad info. That residual bad feeling appears to have spilled over into the latest vote.
On MaxMax's suggestion of No Lynch is a very dubious play. Not solving at all.
Max Spin
Their play is really weird. They turn on Vector with basically no reason. Just pure wagonning. Is it because Vector hasn't posted much? If so, why not say? They really don't give much that's good to work with. After my D2 read back, I'm going to drill down on this one.
I am only one person.
Not if you're on a mafia team, you're not.
On TricTric is snipey but not very proactive. He's dedicated to extracting info from Max. Not hunting so much as bleeding dry. He confesses to having blown his load on N1. Which is a Choice, I guess. It means we have no info from the mafiakill. If he's telling the truth. Also, I could see mafia builds with a power along these lines, so I'm not sure why people are taking this as if it means Tric is cleared town.
On 4maskYes. I have an auto that tells me I can give away the items it gives me as a free action. It does not, however, provide a priority, since it's, y'know, an auto.
Not seeing why a scum!4mask would claim his power gives things for free when this opens him right back up as the mafiakiller. But, also... this opens him right back up as the mafiakiller!
On EuchrejackEveryone else: Do you have two abilities? One ability? Anyone else think they're as weak as 4mask claims to be?
I mean, sure there is probably a power curve. But I'm not buying the "I'm the only townie+" bit.
My power got the expected fiddliness (one-shots etc) you'd expect from Wuba, but it does essentially do one thing consistently: tracking. Expect a tracking result from me tomorrow.
On Toony— Toony has been active and solvey. Nothing to complain about for a D2.
ReadsMy scum chart is much the same:
TownToony
Jim
EuchreJack
HmmmTric
4mask
ScumMax Spin
Roden
Author
Topic: Webadict's Simple BYOR 2 - Game Over: Town Win (Read 56573 times)