That makes zero sense since that confirms I was uninformed, but ok, give Toony another free win by fake claiming again I guess.
Next time I'll just let the game die? I guess that's the lesson.
That's not the problem, and I think you know that.
The problem isn't being suspicious about Knightwing. It's fine to be suspicious of Knightwing. But, your suspicion had no deduction on it.
Let me quote you my post.
I just expect him to talk more in general. I don't really know what he's like when he's scum, so I'm not about to say that being quiet is a scum tell, but it is at least a bit out of character. I figure if he is town then he'll start town telling at some point if we pressure him. Plus it gives content for everyone else to talk about as well.
I don't like this post.
BluarianKnight points out exactly why this post is scummy, which is funny because she's scum, but that's not the main point. The point is that there's no optimal outcome from this type of post. You can say Knightwing is scummy no matter how he reacts because Knightwing is an unknown. I think there is a lot that can be said about this, where it takes almost no stance other than to feel out whether it could fly as a potential vote.
If you combine this with a seeming struggle to swap everyone to Knightwing near the end of the Day, it really
does point to you being scum.
Now, I think if you want to convince me, you have to explain why ToonyMan decided to Track you, but it unfortunately ends up pointing more towards Toony being Town because ToonyMan as Town knows 3 things:
1) I claimed Cop and that I was likely to target Maximum Spin
2) You are unlikely to be Nightkilled, but one of Jim Groovester or I are, and
3) You are a suspicious target if Maximum Spin can be potentially cleared.
As scum, ToonyMan is still forced into the same tracking target, but I think scum ToonyMan has to wait to figure out if you are me are the Vigilante. I think he slowballs for a post or two instead because he can't leave the Vigilante alive unless he's Bulletproof.
That's actually WHY there's another point here: It's very likely that you are, in fact, Bulletproof. The reason why is that you shot Jim Groovester, who you likely believed was a potential candidate for the Vigilante due to his last post, since it would make no sense to have Bulletproof otherwise. And, worst case scenario, Jim Groovester still is a good target for that.
So, in short, I am fairly sure you're scum, Roden.
Author
Topic: Warplant Mafia (Game Over, Town Wins) (Read 14218 times)