Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Roden]

How many scum are there in this game? That's pretty important information.

My best guess would be 1 Mafia + 1 Ally.

Yes I am a townie

I don't quite believe that yet.

Knightwing64

[webadict]

How many scum are there in this game? That's pretty important information.

BluearianKnight, if I vote you with no reads would I be correct yet again about you being scum?

I am town.

Are you town, Knightwing?

I'm trying to decide if I believe this or not. I think I might almost be able to.

Good question. How many scum are in this game, Jim?

[BluarianKnight]

BluearianKnight, if I vote you with no reads would I be correct yet again about you being scum?

Honestly, it'd be funny if it was.

But, no.

I am town.

Are you town, Knightwing?

... are you sure, Maximum Spin?

[Roden]

If no one's gonna talk then can we at least get some more votes on Knightwing?

[Jim Groovester]

HEY LUCKYOWL WHERE ARE YOU FRIENDO DON'T MAKE ME COME AFTER YOU

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Well.

Good question. How many scum are in this game, Jim?

I don't know! That's why I'm asking!

I would assume two. 1 v 6 with power roles would be very rough on the scum player.

If no one's gonna talk then can we at least get some more votes on Knightwing?

Okay.

Knightwing64

What am I voting him for? Literally the only thing he's done is say he's townie.

Yes I am a townie

I don't quite believe that yet.

Knightwing64

I am town.

Are you town, Knightwing?

... are you sure, Maximum Spin?

I'll grant you discussion is pretty anemic but two players voting for the same reasons is eye catching.

[Roden]

I just expect him to talk more in general. I don't really know what he's like when he's scum, so I'm not about to say that being quiet is a scum tell, but it is at least a bit out of character. I figure if he is town then he'll start town telling at some point if we pressure him. Plus it gives content for everyone else to talk about as well.

[Knightwing64]

I was sleeping….


I’m a townie that shows up as mafia when you investigate me.

[EuchreJack]

I am officially looking for a replacement for Luckyowl.  If you are interested, please PM me.
My apologies for starting this while Luckyowl was missing.
Attention Luckyowl: If you still want to play, you have until I find a replacement to send me a PM and post in thread.

[BluarianKnight]

I'll grant you discussion is pretty anemic but two players voting for the same reasons is eye catching.

brain be mush
embrace shroom

Give me an hour or two and I'll actually put some work into a real post, e

[webadict]

I just expect him to talk more in general. I don't really know what he's like when he's scum, so I'm not about to say that being quiet is a scum tell, but it is at least a bit out of character. I figure if he is town then he'll start town telling at some point if we pressure him. Plus it gives content for everyone else to talk about as well.

I don't like this post.

[BluarianKnight]

Alright! Tophats on, let's see..

1

HEY LUCKYOWL WHERE ARE YOU FRIENDO DON'T MAKE ME COME AFTER YOU

Dead as hecc.

I'll grant you discussion is pretty anemic but two players voting for the same reasons is eye catching.

Eh, I didn't exactly have much thought to the vote past it being funny.

But, given what little we have right now..

Yes I am a townie

You gotta give us more, Knightwing.

I was sleeping….


I’m a townie that shows up as mafia when you investigate me.

This.. isn't enough to help your case. Claiming the miller after what little you've done so far is.. eughh.. I want to see you more, at least asking a few questions. You'd have vote, but..
I don't like the look of Roden so far.

How many scum are there in this game? That's pretty important information.

My best guess would be 1 Mafia + 1 Ally.

Yes I am a townie

I don't quite believe that yet.

Knightwing64

Jumping on the Knightwing suspicion of Maximum with a vote, which isn't bad typically but..

If no one's gonna talk then can we at least get some more votes on Knightwing?

He pushes it, without interest of discussion - he wants to vote without question. I don't like that - a townie would want to at least give Knight a chance to speak, but it feels like he wants to vote him out without discussion.

I just expect him to talk more in general. I don't really know what he's like when he's scum, so I'm not about to say that being quiet is a scum tell, but it is at least a bit out of character. I figure if he is town then he'll start town telling at some point if we pressure him. Plus it gives content for everyone else to talk about as well.

I don't.. buy this. This feels like reaching for an excuse, here. Add it all up, and I feel like he's pretty scummy so far.

[webadict]

Hey Max, of Roden or BluarianKnight, which one has got to go first?

Jim is removed from suspicion for now.
Knightwing is scum only if Roden is scum.

Roden looks bad.
BluarianKnight looks slightly less bad, but also looks bad for stealing my take on Roden.
No Luckyowl == Bad

[BluarianKnight]

Hey Max, of Roden or BluarianKnight, which one has got to go first?

Jim is removed from suspicion for now.
Knightwing is scum only if Roden is scum.

Roden looks bad.
BluarianKnight looks slightly less bad, but also looks bad for stealing my take on Roden.
No Luckyowl == Bad

... taking your take?

Okay, fuck that.

I just expect him to talk more in general. I don't really know what he's like when he's scum, so I'm not about to say that being quiet is a scum tell, but it is at least a bit out of character. I figure if he is town then he'll start town telling at some point if we pressure him. Plus it gives content for everyone else to talk about as

I don't like this post.

is equal to my post?

Because there's fuck-all to post about in this fucking thread so far. Of course I retread ground.


Forgot to ask questions.

Jim - Why hop onto the Knightwing bandwagon?
Webadict -

Knightwing is scum only if Roden is scum.

Explain how this makes any sense to me. I don't think Roden's scum-play is ballsy enough to target his team-mate D1, or that awful to do that either.

Knightwing - Gimme anything at this point. I can't read you if you're not participating.

I'd like to put out a few thoughts;

A) Without Luckyowl, we have no idea possible mafia comp. If Lucky was town, we're already down a townie. If he was mafia, then trying to connect people into mafia pairs is meaningless.

B) Roden - You've been targetting KW for not talking, but Maximum Spin has less posts then them at this point. Why aren't you arguing against them for the same issues?

[Maximum Spin]

Hey Max, of Roden or BluarianKnight, which one has got to go first?

Man, that's a tough question. I guess I'd have to say Bluarian, as I think Roden's play here is theoretically consistent with d1 town Rodens past, and I expect him to become more legible over time. The caveat is that I may be overweighting my most recent Roden experience. I have tried not to, but it's still very possible.

Re: post posted while posting: I am only one person.

[EuchreJack]

A blackboard has been hastily repurposed to track votes in chalk.
Votecount:
Maximum Spin
(2) Knightwing64: Roden, Jim Groovester
(1) Roden: BluarianKnight
(0) Jim Groovester
(1) BluarianKnight: Maximum Spin
(0) Luckyowl
(0) Webadict

Game ends Wednesday, March 2nd @ 2:48pm EST
It is now Monday, February 28th @ 4:38 pm EST.  T-minus 46h 10 minutes