I typed this post last night and never submitted it. Whoopsie.
NQT:
Toaster, the point is to get a conversation started, right? In itself a useless question gets the ball rolling. Get some conversation. What was scummy about your response? Nothing overtly, I wanted to see how you'd react.
Sorry; I was a bit unclear. I meant "What is a potentially scummy response to that question you asked?"
MORNING AFTER EDIT: Well, you've pretty much answered that. So instead...
Conclusions: Lucky can't even raise himself to the lowest bar of "reading the thread". Clearing his slot is probably sensible. Secret is also moderately disengaged from reading. Vector must have figured I didn't care about the answers because they complained about the questions and then didn't answer the one I asked them, despite it being the most game relevant question I asked anyone.
Why are you voting Secret over Lucky?
Secretdorf:
The countdown was probably just flavour. And I doubt anyone will claim that but maybe luckyowl as they haven't posted after that yet.
I find this a dangerously flimsy assumption.
My day action is townish and confirmable. But we need a town player to confirm it. This
However, if someone needs a night action...tell me.
You can do me as well if you don't want to do Toony.
FallacyofUrist: Why claim you have a daykill at all outside of "I have a daykill and just shot X player?"
TricMagic:
To note, Fal's Mansion play is kinda similar to his Fries play. I recall him being town in that game. Either way the mansion does not seem like a bad thing. Unlike the countdown and Secretdorf's fishing for people to roleblock. That said keeping a luckyowl around who doesn't post is not a good game plan, we kinda need his posts to determine alignment, crazy as they are at times. Keeping him silent is something his team could tell him to do, though rather that would work is another question.
As Toony said, FoU was scum that game. How does this change your analysis?