Heads up, this is probably my last post of the day. I'll try to check back but no promises; certainly won't be any cases with details.
LuckyOwl:
Luckyowl, are you genuinely busy somewhere else this week? I want to hear from you.
yeah, I work during the day and finish in the evening. So I'm mostly not here for a good while. When the game started on weds I came back to 7 pages of nonsense rvs and memefeast post that I didn't wish to give a 'read' on those sort of nonsense so I went off to play some M&B:2. Here I am and now it seems I'm up the chopping block. So I'll laid out a proposal. I am the priest and I think we should lynch webadict. Mainly for two reason. If he is scum, then we just outted a pretty terrifying scum player, if he is town then I can rez him at night bringing him back into the game as a more powerful confirmed town. It's a win-win in all account. A dead scum! Web is great and a confirmed town! web who was brought from the dead is even better.
This plan is bad. I haven't done the math but I'd give resses about 50% chance of ressing back into town. We have seen survivors, SKs, and conversions to scum team. A bit into meta reads here, but I read this plan as "I don't know how Supernatural resses work mechanically" bad instead of "I am either lying or have a sinister plan" bad.
Webadict:
I swear, I still don't know why Toaster is going after Jim Groovester. It's the COMPLETELY wrong move, and Toaster's doubling down on it STILL. It's wrong. I don't think I'm interpreting it wrong, I seriously think Toaster's trying to cast doubt on Jim, but I don't think it'll work because Jim is too Town. I think even worse than the vote on Bluarian (which... like, okay, I can't really fault them for it because I'm the only one that actually thinks Blue might be Town still, so maybe it's not awful) is the FoS on TricMagic. I feel like I'm running in circles with this one because I think Toaster doesn't see a future for TricMagic elim today, but does see Town equity in the Bluarian elim, even if Blue misflips. I'll give points here, if Blue flips scum, I'll chuck Toaster into Townread because it's definitely not a bus. Like, you could bus Blue, but I think in this case, there's too many other viable elim candidates for it to matter.
I think you're reading too deep into my issues with Jim. I'd love to see more out of him, yes, and know he can do better. Maybe he is just having an off day? I'll tell you when I have more data, which isn't now. His lowest possible rank for me now is "keep an eye on." There's a read list coming, so check that toward the bottom.
NQT:
Hangers-on - Toaster and Juicebox both like each other
I don't recall mentioning juicebox ever this game; my general sentiment leans ever so slightly negative but I'm about to read over juicebox's content. Oh hey it barely exists!
Toaster, Jim, I don't think either of you have given a definitive reads list though you have each scattered your impressions. Care to enlighten us?
Because I don't like doing full read lists this early on because that's not how my brain works. That said, I'm okay with doing one now.
Tier ListThey're fine, whatever tier: People I don't suspect. Unordered.
webadict
ToonyMan
Persus13 I'm gonna be frank, I've run out of time to read over Persus's new posts with any detail. Okay I speed-analyzed
this post and there are no obvious flaws.
IcyTea31
Luckyowl If we buy Lucky's role claim, his behavior makes meta sense as someone not really sure how Supernatural priests work. This is a bit of a free pass, but one I will absolutely not extend to D2.
Slightly Arched Eyebrow tier: Keeping an eye on these folks.
Vector Vector pinged my gut in the first half of D1. I have nothing specific to put my finger on, and it's a pure gut read, but Vector basically has one foot here and one foot in the above tier.
Jim Groovester Like I said, I feel he could be doing better.
Don't like their play tier: People I have specific reasons to suspect.
TricMagic My suspicions of Tric have fallen, but he's not out of the woods yet.
notquitethere NQT has multiple big posts with high word count and little scumhunt count; see the past Supernatural game analysis and the "relationship" matrix which he states specifically that it doesn't currently mean much for scumhunting. I am not happy with NQT so far.
Scum tier: People I'm totally okay with voting.
Juicebox No wonder Juicebox wasn't strong in my mind; there are hardly any posts to reference. See below for more detail.
BluarianKnight I've made my case on BK.
Claimed Survivor tier:
4maskwolf is in my "problem to deal with later" tier. The more he tries the safer his neck is, and he appears to be trying so far.
On Juicebox: So far Juicebox has voted twice.
Once he voted for NQT while saying his top scumpicks in the same post:
Since you asked NQT
[snip]
That leaves Secretdorf and LuckyOwl, both of whom have been mostly absent for D1. It's unusual for both of them to have this little presence in the game, and I can see an argument that they're both lurking scum.
That's odd.
Here Juicebox moves over to Secretdorf. Well, at least he's following his own words.
Then...
unvote as well, now that Secretdorf has been replaced
After that, he asks Webadict a question on his read of me, then later posts
a couple comments. No current vote, basically no current suspects. Nothing.
TL;DR I'd be happy to hang BK, Juicebox, or NQT today.