Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[IcyTea31]

Caz, do you have any actual, specific complaints about the various votes on the Jim wagon, or is yours just a call to be polite?

[notquitethere]

Juice was a lynch want for you yesterday. What changed with Caz?

I told Caz I'd give them a day to settle into the replacement role and do their best job as town, that's all. My view of their slot hasn't changed massively since, but I'd rather not lynch them when I said I wouldn't:

Caz, I know from bitter experience it's miserable to place in to a slot which people have already decided on. I'm willing to give you another day to show us that you're town. Just stop grousing.

[notquitethere]

Anyway, I for one am pleased with high activity end of days. It sure beats the old classic Bay 12 approach of dead air at the end of two weeks of extensions and then lynching a town player with three votes.

[Caz]

Uhm... if he's afk he can't defend whatever ideas come up, which can blow out of proportion easily, yeah. He's been pretty quiet today, but he seemed town d1 to me.

[webadict]

Uhm... if he's afk he can't defend whatever ideas come up, which can blow out of proportion easily, yeah. He's been pretty quiet today, but he seemed town d1 to me.

Then who?

[Caz]

Who what?

[Vector]

Who what?

Who's a better option to take out?

[webadict]

Who what?

We're not done voting until the Day ends. If you want to defend, do it. Why is Jim a bad elimination?

[ToonyMan]

Lucky, any thoughts?

I feel like I just mindmelded with at least half a dozen people.

[IcyTea31]

Uhm... if he's afk he can't defend whatever ideas come up, which can blow out of proportion easily, yeah. He's been pretty quiet today, but he seemed town d1 to me.

But his activity and effort dropped massively D2 (which it admittedly did for several others, including myself), and the lack of a nightkill puts conversion mechanics on the table.

[Caz]

I'm voting for Toonyman? But, sure. What's the reasons for Jim? If it's that they've been quiet, then just look to LuckyOwl or Bluarian for worse cases than this. If it's for passivity, Vector has been doing this except they've actually been here the whole time.

I'll take the point about his activity dropping, but since I think Toony is the converted... :L


A bigger point is, imo, attributing activity to alignment is just a crapshoot. So you are trying to lynch someone on a crapshoot reason who can't even defend themselves. What does that make you?

[4maskwolf]

Has Jim actually done anything especially wolfy, or is it just "Jim's activity dropped, kill Jim."

Because activity drops hit most of the players in this game and Jim's activity was only what it was yesterday since he had a chance to play more on the final day IIRC.

[Vector]

I mean, if people would like to CFD over to Toaster ...

[IcyTea31]

15 minutes is too little time for an informative CFD, in my opinion.

[notquitethere]

No, it's not just Jim's activity levels (though they were fairly low on D1 as well): for me, it's how rubbish his cases are. I don't mind people voting for me, every town player is wrong sometimes, but it's his complete inability to form a coherent case. His last vote was just pure opportunistic bandwagoning of someone who suspected him.