Magna Mongadizafra, Pregame History Turn 2.
While the lands were rocky and not well suited to agriculture, the hills were as rich as any other Spanish Colony. Of course, this forced us to rely upon shipping a fair bit, bringing in fruits and other assorted crop to the island, while many lived on a diet of varying seafood, and in time our capital would become as famous as Nantucket for it's whaling and fishing industry. Even so, before such fame came to be, the colony had much in the way of raw resources, both valuable and practical. Even so, other than the occasional fleet to take the gems back to Spain, the colony was left be to it's own devices, and there were no real issues...Until a Italian named Napoleon came around and took over Spain after France. This caused a major amount of unrest in the colonies, and essentially caused the collapse of the Spanish Empire. With all the Spanish Colonies breaking away, we decided to...
1. Declare Independence. Naturally, with our colony being one that required much in the way of food and being relatively small compared to the other Spanish colonies we were able to do so fairly peacefully. The few Spanish soldiers on the island either joined us, or left for home or another colony. The biggest issue was trying to get legitimacy and seen seriously as a minor power in the region and not merely a part of one of the recently made independent colonies in South America.
2. Declare Independence. Naturally, with our colony being one that relied upon the sea, we took quick action to take a number of Spanish Ships and prepare them for war. While there was fairly limited attempts to try anything against us, it was stopped by our skilled sailors and ships. Though, realistically, we hardly had to fight much due to our importance being extremely lacking in comparison to many other colonies that became nations, along with the British causing issues for the Spanish
3. Remained a part of Spain. While some liked the idea of independence, others thought of such things as foolish. The Spanish Government hardly bothered us, and we hardly bothered them. Why would we change that? Of course, that didn't stop the Spanish from suffering in the war against the British, but that hardly mattered. After all, our island was still peaceful and our own, and our autonomy quite high purely due to the distance involved. Even if there were times where things were a bit disagreeable, these were worked out without rash action.