[1] I'd like you to notice that in 2/3 of your cases, I voted first and then Tric. Shuffling around the timestamps doesn't make that less true. [2] You can also notice that I had a midterm this morning, so comparing my activity (with midterm) to Tric's activity (presumably no midterm) doesn't make sense.
Here is a short history of why I think you are scum:
[3] - Lousy questions with no vote in first post of game.
[4] - Claiming miller right after running a game where we had a fuckton of talking about "anyone who plays miller is town!!" (in conjunction with the other stuff)
[5] - Comment on "whoo, I'm so glad that I didn't vote to mis-democratically murder the townie!"
[6] - I could comment on your shitty-ass case some more where you manipulated the order of posts, but nah. "The RVS is coordinated!!!!!!" ? You are working hard to cover your butt here, kid.
Here's you in your first post. [7] Yeah, I'm gonna mess around with flavor. If we can solve the game through flavor, then we might as well do it. [8] A bastard mod means that there's a puzzle and we need to figure out that puzzle.
[9] I don't believe that LO was actually town. I have played a ton of games with LO. LO was bonafide lurking (on the forum and barely a couple of posts). [10] LO had a weird slip where they seemed to have extra info about the scumteam and claimed it was 3P. What gives?
We also KNOW THAT THERE ARE MISFLIPS.
Your response feels pretty weak to me.
[1]: The shuffling was more of an aesthetic thing than anything else.
[2]: If anything, it's a point in your favor, that you were nearly as active as Tric even with the midterm going on. I'm listing the post count as a way to segue into the
content of your posts, which is much more damning.
[3]: You'll need to explain why my questions were bad. I was waiting for someone to actually
act scummy to vote.
[4]: Would I claim miller as mafia? I'd absolutely be willing to do that sort of crazy gambit. But it'd be
risky.
[5]: So? Luckyowl didn't read as off to me. You're the one who went with Tric and bandwagoned him. Who was the third person to vote Lucky again?
[6]: You're just insulting my work without actually proving
why it's bad.
[7]: Messing around with flavor is fine. I recognize its value. But you were doing it to the
exclusion of actual scumhunting.
[8]: But this isn't a bastard mod. If it were, it would be listed in the first post. It's just a 'crazy closed setup'.
[9]: This doesn't seem like actual... evidence of
scumminess? Just of inactivity, which could mean any number of things. Appealing to meta isn't valid if you don't provide proof that's what the meta suggests.
[10]: That weird slip may be the only valid point about Lucky you have, but I'm not so sure. Same thing. Prove it. What about it makes you think he's scummy? What about this setup makes you think scum will flip town in particular? Who was he if not Sarah Connor? Who was he acting together with, in the day? Because if he was scum but the game hasn't ended, then there was someone who was partners or otherwise
with him, right?
From what I've seen, you're a lot more proactive than this as town. We do know that there can be misflips, but you've given me no reason or logic to point towards there being one in
this case.
Author
Topic: Skynet's Seduction [Resistance Victory] (Read 21464 times)