Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

Okay, so yeah, I didn't realize Caz investigated roseheart N2. That should confirm me as a Sneak. roseheart, you're the only one that has no N2 claim.

[RoseHeart]

Also why are we still wondering if roseheart is confirmed as a detective, i already investigated him and told for that even tho he couldnt claim his own role name correctly.

That changes everything! Perfect. Now I don't need to backpeddle, because the reason I didn't see webadict is because Mephansteras made a mistake! Caz and I are both Detectives!

[Caz]

The whole game of mafia is figuring out the alignment of players by their actions, arguments and available facts.

There is a good reason why there would be no kill if roseheart is dopp (webadict hid, and his claim d1 made him a very likely target)

No good reason why webadict wouldn't have killed, that I can see.

The roles as they are seem insanely townsided to me though. Theres probably an alien or something horrible coming around the corner.


Also why are we still wondering if roseheart is confirmed as a detective, i already investigated him and told for that even tho he couldnt claim his own role name correctly.

Wait, then you saw me in roseheart's house, right?

No. I didn't go inside, but found evidence in his trash outside that he was a detective. (yes pro skills -. -)

[Luckyowl]

I'm also leaning towards Roseheart only because he haven't said his N2 claim which isn't helping us at all. That's honestly what's making you look scumming. If you don't provide your N2 claim I too will be voting against you. It honestly feel like you're no longer helping on catching the dopp anymore. Sure, everyone is pressuring you, but all we want is your N2 claim. So we can confirm you to be townie.

[Caz]

Also why are we still wondering if roseheart is confirmed as a detective, i already investigated him and told for that even tho he couldnt claim his own role name correctly.

That changes everything! Perfect. Now I don't need to backpeddle, because the reason I didn't see webadict is because Mephansteras made a mistake! Caz and I are both Detectives!

Sometimes I wonder if you are paying attention to the game at all

It is perfectly possible for there to be 2 detectives

[RoseHeart]

I ninja'd you Owl.

[RoseHeart]

Sometimes I wonder if you are paying attention to the game at all

It is perfectly possible for there to be 2 detectives

All I can say is I am doing the best I can.

[RoseHeart]

Look, have I atleast proven there is sufficient room for doubt?

You know night 1 I investigated TricMagic.

You know night 2 I investigated Caz.

I'm not withholding anything now. And it would have been stupid to claim Mephansteras sent me an error without first verifying my role.

[TricMagic]

This does not actually change anything though. At most you can switch the vote to webadict instead of you, but if he's town, you're getting voted next. And as noted, two detectives, a medium, an observant guard, a vengeful guard, that's 5 roles that can screw over dopps. Sneak is a 6th to a lesser degree.

[webadict]

Look, have I atleast proven there is sufficient room for doubt?

You know night 1 I investigated TricMagic.

You know night 2 I investigated Caz.

I'm not withholding anything now. And it would have been stupid to claim Mephansteras sent me an error without first verifying my role.

But it's already too late for this to be an acceptable answer. Caz claimed it both D2 and D3 before you did.

[RoseHeart]

But it's already too late for this to be an acceptable answer. Caz claimed it both D2 and D3 before you did.

Yes, but the fact that they are claiming me and I am claiming them means atleast one of us is town, and a fact.

[RoseHeart]

This does not actually change anything though. At most you can switch the vote to webadict instead of you, but if he's town, you're getting voted next. And as noted, two detectives, a medium, an observant guard, a vengeful guard, that's 5 roles that can screw over dopps. Sneak is a 6th to a lesser degree.

Ok, but why target me?

[webadict]

But it's already too late for this to be an acceptable answer. Caz claimed it both D2 and D3 before you did.

Yes, but the fact that they are claiming me and I am claiming them means atleast one of us is town, and a fact.

You being a Detective isn't the debate. You being a Doppelganger is.

[RoseHeart]

I am utterly unconvinced anyone is mafia for sure. That's why I think we should be smart and use our roles in a coordinated fashion to determine it.

[Caz]

Am I going insane or does roseheart still not get that there can be more than one of the same role (2 telepaths already) and that role has no bearing on alignment?