Re: Chinese social credit
So it has nothing to do with tracking and disempowering dissidents? ... Right.
Yeah, but they don't actually need to have a social credit system for that. They can just arrest you. For example, they mention in the below article about someone blacklisted from certain services, but that had absolutely nothing to do with any sort of scoring system, and no such scoring system is necessary to do that. For the purposes of control generally governments
don't want to build a system with any sort of transparent scoring, they want to keep all that information hidden. If a scoring system comes in, and the rules are transparent then that actually conflicts with the arbitrary execution of power, it doesn't enhance it.
Most of the stuff about individuals is about tracking credit history, the same thing the west has with credit scores. Currently China barely has any way of tracking that stuff. So it's just western-inspired credit history tracking, since, you know, China doesn't actually
have a credit-rating system currently. This is really for the benefit of business and not the state. If the state rates you and then makes that rating
publicly available then that's revealing information, which they're generally against doing so. For example if a journalist writes a critical story, then their rating drops, then it's now public information that the government dropped his rating because of the story he wrote. Which is ... not a thing they want to reveal. It makes good drama in a dystopian sci-fi or spy thriller movie, but that's generally not how reality works.
This is what I mean by clickbait. China is implementing stuff that's 99% the same stuff we all have in the West, then suddenly that's big brother gone mad. There's stuff like being declined train tickets, but if you look at the examples of reasons, it's mostly fucking up on trains that causes them to do that. Even in free America, they can ban you from public transport for being a repeated nuisance.
https://www.wired.co.uk/article/china-social-credit-system-explained