What? You thought I was through?
No, there is still a part 2.
Our attraction of note
is the dissection of this quote
and the things that I say will be new.
TricMagic
Persus, a better vote than anything else in info gained.
explain yourself.
TBF
I am so very tempted to vote Persus right now. This is just...why the carp even.
why?
(As for why I'm not, I don't know if anyone would actually follow me in that, being as there's already webadict arguing to policy-lynch me.)
this concerns me. why do you only want to lynch someone if others will follow suit instead of voting people for their merit (or rather lack thereof)?
(i lost which post i was replying to so this just became a general rant)
Thinking that webadict is town because they're active is the same lazy logic as thinking persus is scum because they have a rolename about lurking. You know we pick our rolenames but not our alignment, right? I dunno why that would make Persus more likely to be scum, infact since lurking is a sorta scummy behaviour and he has a legitimate excuse for it, "powers gained by lurking" I'd say that's a point towards him being town. (a very small point, but a point nonetheless) also it's been awhile since I played with persus but I think lurking is his... thing.
TricMagic – scummy. doesn’t scumhunt, just wants to lynch whoever looks worst in the moment. Gives no reasoning for their votes either. Still hasn’t answered my question.
Maximum Spin - scummy. just seems to want to follow the most recent possible lynch without reason or investigation.
TheBiggerFish – slight scum. Weird rolefishing. When asked about their goal for the day replies “lynching scum”. No duh. Going on about the vote tying was also a weird point. Wants to buddy vote with people.
Deus Asmoth – null. Doesn’t seem that concerned. Manages to post almost as little as Persus.
Rockeater – null. doesn't do anything as far as i saw.
randomgenericusername – null.
Persus13 – null. only post has been that he’s sad about “going out of town for a few days”
Webadict – wildcard. it’s webadict. Seems to care about the game. Has a big problem with TBF. Whether that makes him town or scum is beyond me at this point.
IcyTea31 - neutral. i don't agree with the roleclaiming etc but they atleast seems to believe their own arguments which is something.
Teneb – neutral. want to hear more from Persus before I make a decision on this one
hector13 – slight town. Their content is useful enough.
Sheldon - no idea. it doesn't seem to vote, so for now i'm considering it irrelevant.
We begin with the reveal of
TenebThat incentivizes pressure against
persusSmart people throw in votes, such as
WebGood, now that you tied the vote, I Hammer Persus13 Maximum Spin.
But look who shows up. It's
Caz! Curses!:
TricMagic
Persus, a better vote than anything else in info gained.
explain yourself.
Now whether it's hate, or he's helping his mate.
Is not the main subject, I'm here to debate.
But out of all the people who threw in a vote
he goes after the one who can't stay afloat
And rather than go after a lead who's a bit more concrete
He attacks someone else, just cause he has the skills of a NEET
Of course, going after someone weak is not his only crime.
He defends persus with arguments, that are weak like last time.
(i lost which post i was replying to so this just became a general rant)
Thinking that webadict is town because they're active is the same lazy logic as thinking persus is scum because they have a rolename about lurking. You know we pick our rolenames but not our alignment, right? I dunno why that would make Persus more likely to be scum, infact since lurking is a sorta scummy behaviour and he has a legitimate excuse for it, "powers gained by lurking" I'd say that's a point towards him being town. (a very small point, but a point nonetheless) also it's been awhile since I played with persus but I think lurking is his... thing.
This thing is quite the dense shopping cart
so let's look at the pieces, as I rip it apart
Thinking that webadict is town because they're active is the same lazy logic as thinking persus is scum because they have a rolename about lurking. You know we pick our rolenames but not our alignment, right?
No complaints, here you're completely correct.
I'd buy you beer, but the rest is kind of wrecked.
since lurking is a sorta scummy behaviour and he has a legitimate excuse for it, "powers gained by lurking" I'd say that's a point towards him being town. (a very small point, but a point nonetheless)
You take the good will, that you earned at the start.
and contradict it with an argument that's not very smart.
Regardless if he is mafia, or if he is town
he's incentivized to lurk either way to bring the opposing team down
In truth, you're right, rolenames do not indicate alignment.
yet you stray from neutral, and give him a remotely positive assignment.
What you don't understand, when we casted those votes in our hand
is that we don't do it cause we think he's scum.
We try to make him post, cause lurking is dumb.
Anyway, I'm done. I think I made my point
Caz is scum. If you agree let us all vote in joint.