Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mightymushroom]

I asked a clarifying question and it appears that my ability would block IcyTea's after all. Sorry for the confusion, I honestly didn't realize it is that expansive.

It seems safe to conclude I was regular blocked and not jailed.

[FallacyofUrist]

What ability? Did you gain it?

[REDACTED]. Yup. It's very useful.

[hector13]

So you have gained how many abilities, FoU?

Tiruin evidently didn’t use her jailkeeplng ability then.

BHK presumably told us about what ability he gained earlier, can’t look it up right now.

[randomgenericusername]

If FoU gained a new ability, shouldn't have he won and left the game? I feel that's what happens when a third wins.

[FallacyofUrist]

If FoU gained a new ability, shouldn't have he won and left the game?

Well... I did sorta kinda... already have... won the game. For some reason, winning didn't make me leave the game.

That said, I'm still going to try to get as many abilities as possible. For fun, y'know. How high can I go?

[randomgenericusername]

Then if you already won, could you give us your full claim? You can't lose anymore and there's no reason to keep anything secret now.

[FallacyofUrist]

One action please.

[hector13]

Could just kill ‘im. He’s maintaining the mercenary style despite not needing to, and is consequently a detriment to town.

He also roleblocked a known killing role at the behest of a survivor (like seriously BHK wtf) despite being able to get an action from using the roleblock elsewhere (presumably) plus the action rom RGU.

Current madhat theory is FoU and BHK are the scumteam conning town into giving them actions and making us think they’re benign TP.

BHK has no reason to block RGU, unless RGU had a reason for killing BHK. The only reason RGU would have for killing BHK is if BHK is scum (unless RGU is scum, but that feels unlikely if FoU blocked RGU at BHK’s behest) ‘cause RGU would get their mafiakill.

BHK got some splainin’ to do.

[FallacyofUrist]

Could just kill ‘im. He’s maintaining the mercenary style despite not needing to, and is consequently a detriment to town.

Or you could pay my fees and do your best to aim my actions to stop the mafiakill.

[hector13]

Could just kill ‘im. He’s maintaining the mercenary style despite not needing to, and is consequently a detriment to town.

Or you could pay my fees and do your best to aim my actions to stop the mafiakill.

You've won, what does it matter what happens to you?

[hector13]

Actually no.

FoU, he's the vehicle for BHK being useless to town, lets get him out the way first. If he has BHK's roleblock, he's going to be able to get a free unblockable kill at some point:

I win if I survive, quite apparently. I have a roleblock that lets me permanently gain one of three abilities from the target, being immunity (), a protection, and a 25 MPH boost. Getting all 3 of my abilities gives me a single one shot kill that pierces absolutely anything that I can use as a free action.

Which he won't use for town unless we pay him, probably an exorbitant fee given the kill's utility and the fact it's single shot.

If BHK's a good boy, I'll keep him alive once FoU is gone. This is conditional on him scumhunting and being otherwise useful to town.

[BlackHeartKabal]

He also roleblocked a known killing role at the behest of a survivor (like seriously BHK wtf) despite being able to get an action from using the roleblock elsewhere (presumably) plus the action rom RGU.

Current madhat theory is FoU and BHK are the scumteam conning town into giving them actions and making us think they’re benign TP.

BHK has no reason to block RGU, unless RGU had a reason for killing BHK. The only reason RGU would have for killing BHK is if BHK is scum (unless RGU is scum, but that feels unlikely if FoU blocked RGU at BHK’s behest) ‘cause RGU would get their mafiakill.

BHK got some splainin’ to do.

He gets abilities from the roleblock itself. That, plus, why does the killer have to go unblocked? What's the benefit of not blocking him? Random blocks are unreliable to begin with, so it's best to block the most suspicious/threatening one, which would be the Spanish Inquisition that could just kill me and get away with it. I have a vested interest in keeping myself alive, and I gotta work with the town while doing so. How was directing the block to the killer not the best option with the current lack of info?

[hector13]

He also roleblocked a known killing role at the behest of a survivor (like seriously BHK wtf) despite being able to get an action from using the roleblock elsewhere (presumably) plus the action rom RGU.

Current madhat theory is FoU and BHK are the scumteam conning town into giving them actions and making us think they’re benign TP.

BHK has no reason to block RGU, unless RGU had a reason for killing BHK. The only reason RGU would have for killing BHK is if BHK is scum (unless RGU is scum, but that feels unlikely if FoU blocked RGU at BHK’s behest) ‘cause RGU would get their mafiakill.

BHK got some splainin’ to do.

He gets abilities from the roleblock itself.

So he blocks someone who said they were going to give him another ability?

Random blocks are unreliable to begin with, so it's best to block the most suspicious/threatening one, which would be the Spanish Inquisition that could just kill me and get away with it.

How is the Spanish Inquisition the most suspicious/threatening thing? It's a known element. You wanted to block quinnr earlier, and given they are one of the few people who could've performed the NK, thus helping town, why didn't you do that instead?

I have a vested interest in keeping myself alive, and I gotta work with the town while doing so. How was directing the block to the killer not the best option with the current lack of info?

Working with the town means paying attention to the thread which you obviously didn't do because RGU said he was going to do something other than murderate you during the night.

Working with the town means stopping scum during the night, which you clearly didn't do since your directed block didn't stop the NK.

Working with the town means scumhunting during the day. Haven't seen much of that from you.

Pretty open and shut case, don't you think?

I guess we can remedy the last one easily enough. What are your current reads, and why?

[randomgenericusername]

My vigkill is a 1-shot that can be used once, it would be plain stupid to use it on the first night possible. 

You could have roleblocked anyone else to get tha ability, and I have 0 reason to kill BHK (or anyone at all.) Like hector13 said, there's the chance FoU and BHK are the scum team we're looking for (if the scum team is a pair.)
But I would like to hear what the other think before voting either.

[BlackHeartKabal]

He also roleblocked a known killing role at the behest of a survivor (like seriously BHK wtf) despite being able to get an action from using the roleblock elsewhere (presumably) plus the action rom RGU.

Current madhat theory is FoU and BHK are the scumteam conning town into giving them actions and making us think they’re benign TP.

BHK has no reason to block RGU, unless RGU had a reason for killing BHK. The only reason RGU would have for killing BHK is if BHK is scum (unless RGU is scum, but that feels unlikely if FoU blocked RGU at BHK’s behest) ‘cause RGU would get their mafiakill.

BHK got some splainin’ to do.

He gets abilities from the roleblock itself.

So he blocks someone who said they were going to give him another ability?

Random blocks are unreliable to begin with, so it's best to block the most suspicious/threatening one, which would be the Spanish Inquisition that could just kill me and get away with it.

How is the Spanish Inquisition the most suspicious/threatening thing? It's a known element. You wanted to block quinnr earlier, and given they are one of the few people who could've performed the NK, thus helping town, why didn't you do that instead?

I have a vested interest in keeping myself alive, and I gotta work with the town while doing so. How was directing the block to the killer not the best option with the current lack of info?

Working with the town means paying attention to the thread which you obviously didn't do because RGU said he was going to do something other than murderate you during the night.

Working with the town means stopping scum during the night, which you clearly didn't do since your directed block didn't stop the NK.

Working with the town means scumhunting during the day. Haven't seen much of that from you.

Pretty open and shut case, don't you think?

I guess we can remedy the last one easily enough. What are your current reads, and why?

1 - RGU is not confirmed to be town. He could just as easily be mafia, and I'm suspicious of it. I personally feel frustrated that others don't share my suspicion, so I acted on it the only way I could.
2 - I could only assume that they'd be glimpsed by an investigative sort of action through the night as such a particularly standout suspect, which leaves me for *my* main suspect. If I thought I could get a feasible case and following on quinnr, I would. I'm a survivor, however, so my input will matter less to the town because of the "Thirds stick out for nobody" meme (which, honestly, makes sense, but makes things difficult for me still.)
3 -
FallacyOfUrist - I'm not going to argue with someone who can protect me.
hector13 - You're town. That or you're scum that's taken head of the town very well.
IcyTea31 - Null, slight town. Not notable, but not in a suspicious way.
mightymushroom - Null. Slight town through process of elimination, unless there are 3 scum.
quinnr - Scum leaning. Them and RGU are my votes for the scumteam.
randomgenericusername - I really do think that RGU is not town, but I have no evidence or means to obtain it.
Tiruin - Null. This is Tiruin, so that goes without saying.

As for RGU being a known element, an absolute, known element in a setup like this is an anomaly. They are an exception, not a rule, and they should be scrutinized because of it.