Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[juicebox]

I believe Silthuri is currently voting for Imic

[juicebox]

and Imic actually unvoted NQT, although he didn't put it in red.

[Imic]

Unvote, just in case.

[randomgenericusername]

I would prefer that we lynched someone because otherwise we are giving mafia a free night for them to kill. We would waste the kill-less night we had if we don't lynch anyone. A small chance to hit mafia is better than no chance at all.

[FallacyofUrist]

I believe Silthuri is currently voting for Imic

and Imic actually unvoted NQT, although he didn't put it in red.

Missed both of those.

[Imic]

I am actually suspicious of Maximum spin, but I don't really want to go straight forward for this, since he seems to have a track record. But nevertheless, he is starting to act reeeeaaaaaly suspicious. No vote though, I don't want to jump to conclusions.

[BlackHeartKabal]

Reviewing the thread, will respond when home.

[GigaGiant]

The Day is coming to a close in about 5 hours or so, so I recommend that each of us choose at least 2 people we would be willing to see lynched today, and describe our reasons for wanting those people lynched. I'll start.

kingawsume: Hasn't participated much. Knowingly hammered Maximum Spin, and was fine with what he considered a probable mislynch. Has yet to do any actual scum hunting. Hasn't done anything after I finished questioning him. My top lynch candidate at the moment.

BlackHeartKabal: Lurking. Null read, leaning scum. He's only posted 3 times during the game, 2 of which were RVS. His one other post is just him jumping onto the tail end of a bandwagon without any reasoning. I'm definitely okay with seeing him get lynched. (PPE: May change depending on what he posts next)

Imic: Null read, slightly leaning scum. Seems like he was disinterested in the game for most of Day 1. He could be passive town, active lurking scum, or just somebody who really doesn't know how to play. I don't know yet, but I'm fine with him getting lynched.

For the record, here's my read on Maximum Spin:

I'm leaning toward him not being scum. Several of the actions he's taken during Day 1 seem too risky for someone with a mafia win condition. He's certainly not afraid to be provocative and disagreeable either. If he was mafia, I would expect him to not be so reckless.

I also think this quote in particular implies that he is town.

And lastly, Imic: Imic, how suspicious I am of you would depend entirely on how you respond to that message you should have received last night. If you continue to ignore it, especially now that you know I know about it, well, that would suggest to me that you already have other allegiances.

He posted this in his reads before Imic revealed the cult message. At the time, there was a chance that Maximum Spin would be hammered upon FOU's return, so I think he included this as a clue for the town to figure out after his death. I suspect that Maximum Spin's role reveal combined with this clue would have been enough for us to figure out that Imic had received a cult invitation. Maximum Spin has mentioned how he understood this "cult" to be town-aligned, so it seems like he thought that Imic's refusal to join could indicate that he's scum. Furthermore, Maximum Spin's role reveal might have led us to same conclusions, that the "cult" was town-aligned and Imic not joining was suspicious.

That said, I'm not sure why he didn't just come out and say this. I could be wrong in my interpretation of this quote, but he refused to comment on this, so I think it's relevant in some way.

[Imic]

Gigagiant I think you have a very good point about maximum spin. As for my playstyle, most of my posts are done in brief periods, so I don't have much time to review my post or really read over the thread. I garuntee you I'm a townie, just one with not a lot of free time, and one who hasn't playe dmafia much in the past.

[Silthuri]

Pfp and very busy.

I think Max is just guilty of not conforming to the meta which is why I don't think he's a good lynch candidate.

I think imic is a decent choice because he was contacted by the cult and we can't take him at his word that he won't join it.

On the other hand, I think BHK could also be a decent candidate because of the blatant bandwagon and lack of posting but I really want to see him respond to the thread, hopefully before day end.

[kingawsume]

Hasn't participated much. Knowingly hammered Maximum Spin, and was fine with what he considered a probable mislynch. Has yet to do any actual scum hunting. Hasn't done anything after I finished questioning him. My top lynch candidate at the moment.

Yes, I knowingly hammered; this was also a point where I was still high on pain meds and annoyed at everything for existing. (Doesn't excuse it, I know that.)

As for not doing anything, IRL has taken an unexpected turn. I have been more busy this past week that I was most of December. I had surgery a week ago (Pain Meds), and still haven't hully recovered. I have a lot of shit to do, and not alot of time to do it. Blah blah blah, don't in on a game you can't make, yadda yadda yadda.

[kingawsume]

EBWOP: Sorry about not saying much of anything, I haven't anything to say.

[Imic]

Why would I tell you all about a cult if I was then to join it? It'd be a dick move for one thing, telling everyone that something exists and then joining it, and since I have told everyone that there is a cult, I'm not going to join it, but if you think I will join it anyway, you're clearly mad, since it would be suicide for me at this rate. Now everyone knows there's a cult, they'll be in the lookout for it, wnd if I'm part of that, or if I ever look suspicious again, I'm dead, and so is the cult.

[BlackHeartKabal]

BHK, juicebox, Silthuri: I haven't heard from you much, lately. What are your ideas towards other people? This would be expected either today or tomorrow (because the mod may be out of commission due to sickness despite hammerfall, and usually the rule for hammers is 'do not speak when after the hammer has fallen'...which goes for everyone who missed it until the topic was brought up )

I don't necessarily have ideas towards everyone in particular.
Maximum Spin - cornered himself and is probably unlucky scum or unlucky town.
Imic - Should be killed immediately if MS turns scum.
Silthuri - Shares my hate for RVS, and is also one of the two taking lead of the town.
NQT - Taking lead of the town, as usual. Should speak up with what he gets.

On the other hand, I think BHK could also be a decent candidate because of the blatant bandwagon and lack of posting but I really want to see him respond to the thread, hopefully before day end.

Why not vote for Maximum Spin, if he's the primary suspect?

Also, I'm pretty confident all of these tropes are from submitted roles. Just pointing out the elephant in the room.

[Tawa]

Sorry for the lateness. I've just kind of forgotten about this, honestly :v

Spoiler: My reads (click to show/hide)

notquitethere: I'm getting a more or less town read from NQT. It's very typical Mafia playing, I guess. Enough posts, they're substantial, reasonably suspicious, investigatory.
kingawsume: Pretty fishy; see below.
Tiruin: Same kind of thing as NQT. Very regular townie read. I should add that I'm well aware Tir and NQT are vets notoriously good at covering up suspicion.
Silthuri: Townie read. They've been a bit lurky--as have I--but it definitely comes across as a "Sorry!" lurk rather than "Please don't notice me town-senpai" lurk.
BlackHeartKabal: Very scummy read. The lurk king; majority of posts were weird questions about very specific roles. See below.
randomgenericusername: See below. Their posts, IMO, have largely been really insubstantial commentary.
GigaGiant: Town read. I feel like they got unfairly targeted at the beginning and have suffered from "implied corruption" syndrome, where following a couple accusations lots of people assume "yeah that person's a fishy scumbag" without actually knowing what fishy, scummy things they've done.
Tawa: Hello!
juicebox: Similar to RGUN. I have more or less no read.
Imic: I'm not sure if I buy the cultist business, but has been relatively okay with activity and seems more or less normal. Neutral read; see below.
Maximum Spin: Still fishy and cagey, but I buy the "presumptuous noob" idea more now than I did before. See below.

Right now, I'm looking at two possible lynch candidates: Max or BHK, and, as you can see, leaning BHK. The way I see it, lynching BHK could give us tons of crucial information tonight.

When I put the first vote on Maximum Spin, RGUN, Tiruin, Silthuri, king, and BHK all voted after me. In my opinion, BHK was a blatant bandwagon. I feel like something is also off about RGUN's vote, and kingawsume's vote was almost certainly a suspicious bandwagon, but that's beside my point.

Now, if Max is actually mafia, then we can safely assume that if BHK is mafia, BHK wouldn't bandwagon on Max. So if we lynch BHK and find out they're scum, we can assume that Max is town. In that case, we can assume that Max is telling the truth about Imic and the cult message. If we lynch BHK and they're town, we're down a lurker.

Lastly, I have a hypothesis--a deeply grasping-at-straws hypothesis, but a hypothesis nonetheless--that BHK could be the cult leader. Their initial group of questions suggests that BHK could be third party. This would also explain the lurking as a ploy to keep the cult hush-hush. Again, this is pretty out there, and I don't expect it to be true--but I think it's definitely a possibility.