Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[fatcat__25]

After review, I would like to cast a vote for The Dwarven Language Codified. Such an effort is worth legendary status in my mind.

[Eschar]

Casting a vote for McCreary's Planet.

[Imic]

If I haven’t given it my vote already, I vote for the Dearven language codified. If I already have voted for it... I’ll go over to the ditch of shame, don’t mind me.

[Immortal-D]

Hey folks.  First, apologies to fatcat_25.  I thought I'd recorded that vote, and waiting multiple months for recognition is not normal.  Or shouldn't be.  Bridgeflickered and Modded Hell were nominated about ~15 months, with 3 & 5 votes.  Perhaps next time.

After review, I would like to cast a vote for The Dwarven Language Codified. Such an effort is worth legendary status in my mind.

If I haven’t given it my vote already, I vote for the Dearven language codified. If I already have voted for it... I’ll go over to the ditch of shame, don’t mind me.

Dwarven language codified reaches 6 (Imic already voted).

Casting a vote for McCreary's Planet.

And a +1 to McCreary makes 5.

That's all for now, enjoy your Summer!

[Imic]

(Imic already voted)

Time for the ditch of shame!

[Immortal-D]

(Imic already voted)

Time for the ditch of shame!

If you mouse-over the vote total, it shows a list of names.

[Uthimienure]

I cast a vote for The Dwarven Language Codified, an impressive work.

[King Zultan]

I'll also vote for The Dwarven Language Codified.

[Immortal-D]

Happy Summer everyone!  Stay cool out there.

I cast a vote for The Dwarven Language Codified, an impressive work.

I'll also vote for The Dwarven Language Codified.

Dwarven Language Codified now at 8/10.

[Quantum Drop]

I would like to add my vote to The Dwarven Language Codified.

[Naturegirl1999]

I would like to add my vote to The Dwarven Language Codified.

I searched and this seems like a General Topics thread, not a game thread, unless I missed something?

[Quantum Drop]

I would like to add my vote to The Dwarven Language Codified.

I searched and this seems like a General Topics thread, not a game thread, unless I missed something?

Quoth the main page, bolded and underlined for clarity:

Nominees need not be from a specific part of the Bay12 forums, nor is their format or subject matter a consideration- it merely needs to be worthy of preservation. Nominees that are not local to the Bay12 forums should be marked as such. To avoid suspicion of favoritism, I shall neither nominate nor vote for any nominee, no matter how deserving. I reserve the right to trim/alter synopses as I see fit (mostly to maintain a reasonable length).

So, to the best of my understanding, threads from General Topics and elsewhere on or off Bay12 can indeed be recommended for inclusion in the HoL (such as the Battle of the Gods series (Forum Games and RP), Elves of Amanereli (also FGaRP), everything in the Roll to Dodge category) so long as ten members of the site deem it sufficiently memorable/high-quality/ingenious/lulzy to be worthy of preservation.

[Naturegirl1999]

Oh, whoops

[TheImmortalRyukan]

I would now like to submit my vote for The Dwarven Language Codified, and I believe that makes 10!

[Immortal-D]

Greetings all.  I have nothing clever this time, so here we go.

I would like to add my vote to The Dwarven Language Codified.

I would now like to submit my vote for The Dwarven Language Codified, and I believe that makes 10!

With the final vote added a few days past the deadline, The Dwarven Language Codified becomes a Legendary Archive!  For the sake of clarifying precedent; I've said before that the cutoff will not be strict.  A few days past is fine, maybe a week if the final vote has a really good reason.  Any longer than that would need consideration.

I'm sorry to report that McCreary's Planet only hit 5 in one year.  Maybe next time, if it get a little more oomph.

I would like to add my vote to The Dwarven Language Codified.

I searched and this seems like a General Topics thread, not a game thread, unless I missed something?

Quoth the main page, bolded and underlined for clarity:

Nominees need not be from a specific part of the Bay12 forums, nor is their format or subject matter a consideration- it merely needs to be worthy of preservation. Nominees that are not local to the Bay12 forums should be marked as such. To avoid suspicion of favoritism, I shall neither nominate nor vote for any nominee, no matter how deserving. I reserve the right to trim/alter synopses as I see fit (mostly to maintain a reasonable length).

So, to the best of my understanding, threads from General Topics and elsewhere on or off Bay12 can indeed be recommended for inclusion in the HoL (such as the Battle of the Gods series (Forum Games and RP), Elves of Amanereli (also FGaRP), everything in the Roll to Dodge category) so long as ten members of the site deem it sufficiently memorable/high-quality/ingenious/lulzy to be worthy of preservation.

And just for emphasis.  Any suitably Dwarfy work may be considered here.  One of my personal favorite stories (that I've since saved locally just in case) is Glazedcoast, hosted on some random-ass gaming forum from ages past.