Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[BlackHeartKabal]

This is King of the Mafia. All mechanics are player chosen, so speculating over something being a "common mechanic" is useless. People are going to choose roles that are powerful.

So why would Fallacy lie about being poisoned, and why would that attract someone to kill him?

Because I tried to redirect the poisoning itself, thinking it wasn't a morning kill, so I thought he lied.

[Persus13]

It's also not a morning kill, because it happens the day before. Unless you had a day redirect you wouldn't be able to do anything about it.

PFP

[BlackHeartKabal]

It's also not a morning kill, because it happens the day before. Unless you had a day redirect you wouldn't be able to do anything about it.

PFP

Can you not redirect the actual kill?

[TheDarkStar]

It's also not a morning kill, because it happens the day before. Unless you had a day redirect you wouldn't be able to do anything about it.

PFP

Can you not redirect the actual kill?

Unless you can retroactively redirect where the poison ends up, no. The action itself occurred yesterday.

[FallacyofUrist]

Yeah. Poisoning is an action that kills the poisoned player at the start of the next day. I know I was poisoned because when I was a yellow goo I gained the poison ability(and promptly shot Shakerag with it).

Currently, it looks like BlackHeartKabal is going to be lynched.

[hector13]

Can y'all relay why you're voting for BHK?

[BlackHeartKabal]

Yeah. My logic was faulty. Explaining why I went down that path, I'm a Bus Driver turned vanilla townie due to yellow goo. I bussed Fallacy and myself the last night of the first round, and thought he was lying, and I had redirected a vig again. It seems bandwagony, but I'd be voting in my situation.

[FallacyofUrist]

Well, what is there to say now?

Except you should all be voting hector13. BlackHeartKabal doesn't seem scummy to me.

[hector13]

Well, what is there to say now?

Except you should all be voting hector13. BlackHeartKabal doesn't seem scummy to me.

BHK has never been scummy. I don't think the rest of the players are going to indulge you on your OMGUS.

[Deus Asmoth]

hector:

I don't understand the question. Well, more specifically I don't understand why you're asking the question.

I'm asking the question because I was interested in your opinion on someone killing a trigger-happy day killer, though now I'm more interested in the reason for your unwillingness to answer.

As regards BHK, rolefishing seems pretty scummy to me.

FOU: If hector were king mafia, don't you think it would be more likely that he'd have killed Shakerag because he had the ability to daykill rather than for revenge for past actions?

[hector13]

hector:

I don't understand the question. Well, more specifically I don't understand why you're asking the question.

I'm asking the question because I was interested in your opinion on someone killing a trigger-happy day killer, though now I'm more interested in the reason for your unwillingness to answer.

I'm not sure how my not understanding the question is unwillingness to answer the question. I don't think it's unreasonable to want to know what the questioner wants answered prior to answering.

We knew when you asked that Shakes didn't have a kill, day or night, so I'm not sure how I was s'posed to divine that your intent was to do with whether or not having a trigger-happy day killer killed was beneficial to town.

From my perspective, the question didn't make sense because it appeared you were asking if I thought it was a benefit to the town that someone who was town-aligned had been killed, which is obviously no, hence the confusion.

[FallacyofUrist]

FOU: If hector were king mafia, don't you think it would be more likely that he'd have killed Shakerag because he had the ability to daykill rather than for revenge for past actions?

Daykiller Shakerag was last round(he died from my poison). This round Shakerag was a Dirty Bomber. Hilarious, but not a daykiller.

Also, how would the King Mafia know that Shakerag could day kill, if Shakerag could day kill this round?

I find your question interesting.
~~~

[BlackHeartKabal]

As regards BHK, rolefishing seems pretty scummy to me.

And as one of the top two suspects, you've the utmost authority on this, especially since I was doing it for the sake of winning the round (with what turned out to be faulty logic, welp)?
It's not like I can affect the game any other way, right now.

[Persus13]

Speculating on the Night Kill is usually worthless and is always WIFOM.

I mainly found BHK scummy because he was rolefishing hard. I'm trying to decide if it was malicious in intent or not, but I'm going to keep my vote on him until I figure that out.


Again, still reading the hector vs. Fallacy debate as town on town.

[hector13]

What makes you think FoU and I are town?