In the interest of giving TDS the opportunity to present himself the way he wants, I'll avoid commenting on players for whom my reads have been colored by his claim.
4maskwolfYou are correct that TBF played a consistent anti-town game during D1.
Is it your intent to use pressure to try and force out a claim (rfom TBF) during this D3?
Is TBF scummier than TDS (who asked for Leafsnail to out his night action)?
TBFOther than nicely stepping in when your mechanical knowledge was contradicted by seeming scum, you haven't contributed much.
On a mechanical note: will you be fullclaiming today, or does it not serve town's interests to have you do so?
Below is just mechanical speculation, more or less written for my benefit. I don't see any reason not to post it at this stage though.
Nobody is confirmed town.
That said, for Tiruin to have done what she did, she'd either need to have gambled on Shakerag not visibly visiting anyone, or actually be an intelligence scientist/reporter. If she is a dopp information power role, pretty well the only scenario where what she did would make sense is if she was trying to push out a mislynch today and it's actually lylo/mylo due to a survivor or scum siding dopp and massive dopp one-shot kill reserves and scum really wanted to get a scum player out of the lynching pool.
Even in a doomsday scenario like the above, Tiruin still isn't the best pick for scum, since there would need to be two other scum players with additional kills. Such a situation is even less believable than the unstable premise would suggest due to the simple fact that the RattyB lynch gave town's unannounced power roles another day to do whatever it is that the power-roles we have do.
Under the assumption that Tiruin and myself are town, we can always confirm another player (or two) as town once it's down to one dopp just by checking that they don't visit the nightkill. I find it unlikely scum have a stun orb, and for them to be carrying a psychic warden which nobody has outed as being touched by would suggest that they are keeping in reserve just to prevent late-game PR guarding.
Given the danger that swinging at players whom an observant guard has already announced they protected in the past holds for scum, I find this unlikely.
I'm comfortable enough with webadict to leave him off the lynch list until such a date as we can use Tiruin to confirm his role.
Unfortunately I'm not aware of any easy way to get rid of spore spreaders at this point. If Tiruin isn't infected yet and I continue to guard her, it'll probably be fine though.
I'm not worried about a hivemind because I'm fairly certain they would win and I'm fairly certain that they'd convert me since I'm a guard with fullclaims from two other players (though TDS should out today and I'll out him if he takes too long or doesn't give an excellent reason why I shouldn't). My comments D2 about hivemind were based on step two out of four of my thinking of them as a cult which can convert scum, through which I later realized such would always win by converting the entire town.PPE:
Leafsnail is embroiled in the TDS drama (due to TDS asking him what he did N1 during D2, and for no other reason than that that I am yet aware of) but, again, he hasn't done anything
wrong yet so he's far from the player I want lynched.
DA has a lot of work to do to appear town, as in literally becoming more active. He's one of the players with absolutely no mechanical interaction with others that I am aware of, lurking is a strong accusation indeed in his case unless he can justify trying to avoid drawing suspicion.
As it stands my lynch pick is between TDS and TBF. Originally I preferred TDS due to his fishing question to Leafsnail D2, but any case on him I make is now based on mechanical speculation so either I'm definitely voting TDS or along TDS defined lines, or I'll try and lynch TBF for doing the least to help town.
Author
Topic: Paranormal 25 - Game over! Town victory! (Read 79610 times)