Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Tiruin]

I am a kook.

I am a Kook. I would like to hear everyone's opinions on whether it is correct to claim this immediately (I believe it is).

No you're wrong, you've outed yourself as scum, Leafsnail.[...]

Doll said they're a kook o_O  So raise that to possibly + those other two, perhaps. Unless there's a post I've missed?

[webadict]

I am a kook.

I am a Kook. I would like to hear everyone's opinions on whether it is correct to claim this immediately (I believe it is).

No you're wrong, you've outed yourself as scum, Leafsnail.[...]

Doll said they're a kook o_O  So raise that to possibly + those other two, perhaps. Unless there's a post I've missed?

Doll said a lot of things. You gotta keep up!

[Shakerag]

TheBiggerFish:

@Shakerag:
More like 'I'm not going to go through the effort of tracking down all the questions people asked me in a vast morass of longposts'.

Maybe you should put on your big girl panties and search through the vast morass of longposts like every other player in this game does. 


hector13:

RattyB strikes me as new, and B12 is generally quite lenient toward newer players, so also probably not a D1 lynch. They also haven't said much, and B12 generally doesn't policy lynch, 'specially not on D1.

Curious.  This has not been my observation.


IronyOwl: Would you/have you policy lynched on D1?

4maskwolf: Are you lenient toward newer players throwing out scumtells?

[4maskwolf]

4maskwolf: Long time no see. You played any Mafia recently?

Yes and no, but mostly no.  Depends on your definition of "recently".

4maskwolf: Assuming you had an investigative ability, how would you decide who to target?

Investigative ability is too broad of a category for a game like this, where investigative roles can do a wide variety of things, but I'll take the Agent for an example.  I'd choose based on who I wanted to clear, or who I thought was scum, situation dependent.  Check for scum first, check for town if I don't have any good scumreads.

4maskwolf
Asking someone a good question makes both players look townsided, because it gives and opportunity for both to give good reads.
Do you agree or disagree with the above statement?

There are no good questions in RVS, you're just throwing shit at the wall until something sticks and the game begins in earnest.

4maskwolf: Are you lenient toward newer players throwing out scumtells?

Incredibly context dependent, but generally yes.  New players can often be overenthusiastic in their efforts and make beginner mistakes and accidental scumtells that intelligent players (both scum and town) can avoid.


I see doll has managed to one-up me on the gambit front, and if I weren't so busy with work I'd have to challenge them to reclaim my place on top there, but meh.  I'm an old-ass man, I'm too old for that shit.

I am not Spartacus, because fuck that noise.  I have no idea what's going on there, but it isn't anything good.

[hector13]

webadict

@hector13: Where's the reads? Also, because I think you're fishy, what would you offer me to claim my role?

Something most people would consider unpleasant, like haggis. Unless you mean in game terms, in which case nothing. Too early in the game to be trusting folk, and there's a role's list at the start that can be cherry-picked from easily enough.

However, turn that question around: what would you accept as reasonable compensation in return for you claiming your role?

Didn't know I was s'posed to offer up reads, since we're still in the midst of RVS.

I only have gut feelings, presently, which are:

Spoiler: gut feelings (click to show/hide)

- doll is probably not scum (by which I mean relative to everyone else) due to the "I'm this and that and the next thing, but maybe I'm not" nonsense being not very useful for scum to do at this point. It could very well be that they're scum muddying the waters early doors, but once we get some concrete stuff going, it's going to be fairly easy to discard their madness.

The best explanation for it would be that, on a scale from 0-10 (0 being town) doll sits at 4, while most everyone else sits at 5.

- The interaction you, Leafnsail and IronyOwl had regarding kook claims didn't sit well with me. That has mostly dissipated.

- TDS' questions all can be construed as having an anti-town bent to them, but it's RVS, and they're typical of his RVS questions. Still gets a very slight scum lean 'cause of it.

- TBF's inaction is typical, but I don't think I've ever seen him ask other people to do the work for him. He also hasn't asked people any questions himself, beyond that. Last time he was so active lurk-y, he was scum.

In fact, I think I'll vote for him.

TBF

4mask

I have no idea what's going on there, but it isn't anything good.

What makes you say that?

[4maskwolf]

4mask

I have no idea what's going on there, but it isn't anything good.

What makes you say that?

Because three people claimed kook (granted, one of them was probably claiming how kooky they are IRL) in a relatively small Paranormal game.  While I can kinda buy there being two kooks in the game, I do think it bears investigating.  Especially since one of them is Leafsnail.

[TheBiggerFish]

Hey!  I'm pretty sure I asked someone a question!

...Have I seriously not asked anybody any questions?  Wow, real life.  Stop getting in the way when I'm trying to play Mafia.

Gonna go read all the things.  *sigh*

[TheBiggerFish]

webadict:Why would you be confirmed tomorrow?

oh hey look a question

[TheBiggerFish]

In order!

@filipk: Nobody, because insufficient data.

@Shakerag: Poorly.

[TheBiggerFish]

@TDS:dopp strategy?  Well it depends on how everything's worked out.  As just vanilla doppelganger on a team of vanilla doppelgangers, probably much as I'd play town.

[hector13]

In order!

@filipk: Nobody, because insufficient data.

@Shakerag: Poorly.

How is answering the questions like that any different from getting people to find the questions that were asked to you? There's no context, so people have to go look for the questions you're answering...

PPE: goddamn. Really?

[TheBiggerFish]

@hector13:These people presumably know when they asked me a question.

(also, there were fewer questions than I was expecting.  Huh.  Time and posts did not fly.)

[hector13]

So you're just trying to placate the people asking you questions then?

[TheBiggerFish]

No.

[hector13]

So what is it, exactly, that you're doing?