Also, for magical attacks you have to be unconscious somewhere. Any shmuck who wants can saunter along and stab the offending brainiac in the throat.
PW, the rules say doing stuff in the deep sea rolls transcend. This is for all deep-sea related actions, right? I know I can't fire a gun using transcend, but what about eg. finding the soul of a teammate who misplaced his for rezzing?
Oh, and when enter lvl. 6 of the sea you get access to your other skills as well, but can one choose whether or not to use these instead of transcend, or is it 'mandatory'? I think the former, but not entirely sure.
On levels 1-5, you have literally nothing but transcend.
At level 6 and higher its kind of a mix. attacks are still transcend, but other physical stats like move or dodge come in.
Also I'm not sure what you mean by "fail when succeeding."
-edit- sorry.
I meant that even if you roll under your Hide, Find can still get ya. 80 hide vs 20 find is, if I'm reading it right, would be about 75% chance of a successful hide, with the extra 5% coming up when the 20 find succeeds better.
I'm not sure of the exact statistics of it, but it would be 80% chance of you rolling under and a 20% chance of them rolling under. However, they would have to roll much better to beat your success. Essentially if you rolled 60 or lower you'd be completely unbeatable by a 20 skill player.
Regardless, the practical side of this is that most of the time, for most enemies, they'll have combat related stats but no other stats, so I'll just roll a generic test of your hide and if you pass, you pass.
Also, the one who plans on hide is the one with 80 hide.
That's kinda the part that's rubbing on me. If I want to ever be able to do something, I need to apply max points to it right now. I've played too much Wesnoth to ever count on 60% chances, particularly ones that are really lower than that (assuming some defense). Fight physically? pick an attack stat, max it, and likely the defense stat at that range as well. And then the other defense stat or recover. That leaves you with two other choices. Fight magically? Max transcend and make four other choices, not counting the two physical defence stats because they're probably meaningless to an unconscious character.
And if you really want something to work, you need to max it out harder by stacking relevant implants and such to get it to say, 100 or 120 or something, so that you can have a 50% or better chance of success. So by maxing something you have a decent chance of success, and if you don't max something, putting say 40 points in it, it's roughly equivalent to zero as the actual odds of success will be something like 20%.
It might be more basic than all that. It's that I can't take advantage of weaknesses. I can't take advantage of an 0 find by hiding, because if I come up with 30% in bonuses to hide, that's only a 30% chance of success against a zero. Or something similar. I'd need to decide now which weaknesses I can ever take advantage of.
Thats a reasonable dislike. But you forget that if a creature has 0 find I probably wouldn't even force a hide roll. If the weakness is obvious or easy then its not usually gonna need a roll.
I'm really hating dodge right now. I don't really want to put a lot of points in it because I'll be using blast weapon almost explusively, so I don't plan on letting myself get into melee situations if I can help it. Then again, if I somehow do get into a melee situation I absolutely need dodge to even stand a chance at getting out of it. I can't just, say, put 80 points into move and try to disengage after tanking one hit, because I also need to make a dodge vs fight roll to even be able to run away. Argh.
You could, however, use actions that say "If a melee enemy runs up to me, cancel my attack and run away." which would force a move vs move roll for them to attack you. Of course if they DO catch you you're fucked, and I can't say that actions like that will always work depending on the situation. But it's something to think about.
Oh, one last bit. Against someone with 80 of the relevant defense, you need about a 120 to have a 5/6 odds of scoring a hit. Against someone with zero, you need about an 83-84 to have the same odds.
Really, targetting weak spots is for chumps.
And in RTD you fail 50% of the time.