LARD:How am I 'vaguely poking around'? I don't mean to sound self-righteous, but since I've joined the game I've done more scumhunting than you, Imic, OSG, and vishdafish put together. I was willing to ignore some of your bad reasoning beforehand, but now you're just pulling things out of nowhere, and when you do that you're scum.
Bogus. The only scumhunting you've done is to bother myself and Tiruin.
...yes? Do I need to scumhunt everyone at once?
You've prodded the others a bit to get them moving, but you had no reason to vote for Tiruin other than tunneling and question dodging, neither of which is characteristic of an experienced mafia.
You don't need to think someone's mafia to vote them. When I came into the game I saw that literally no one had pressured her the entire time, so I did.
That's what I call vaguely poking around.
How is it less scumhunting than what anybody else has been doing? I attacked you and Tiruin, and since the others had posted so little of substance, I prodded them to get them posting more that I could look at (besides, I already had town reads on them, so I was less focused on that).
And now you've voted for me which is fine because of circumstantial evidence, but not for the reasons you laid out. Those reasons seem like an excuse to avoid a bandwagoning accusation on the ideas of Vishdafish. Just vote for me for some reasonable reason, and there are several, instead of those you have already put foreward.
The fact that you were roleblocked last night has already been discussed a lot. I didn't feel like I needed to repeat it. And my evidence on you is fine. You're making up reasons to think people are scummy, which is something you do when you're scum.
TheWetSheep claims to have hunted a lot despite having come up with no good leads before the one that I was scum. This one doesn't count because he claims to have hunted a lot before I was voted by him.
This in no way means I haven't been hunting. Also, is that a massive slip I see in bold?
Basically your reasons for voting KJP make sense, but your manufactured reasons for why I'm scummy too just don't.
Imic: I'd suggest jailing Tiruin, if only because we know so little about her.
Author
Topic: Beginner's Mafia LX: The Noisome Nine - Scum Win! (Read 43818 times)