Will the military tactics skill affect combat rolls for on-site squads, or just while they're off on missions?
I assume you'd need to implement actual tactics for that. Off-site it's easy enough to abstract the clever tactical decisions and use of terrain dorfs are considering. On-site, they'd revert back to 'crossbows out and charge!'
That could happen eventually, but in the short term something like an accuracy boost would suffice.
Yeah, it would. I guess...
Doesn't really...make much sense though?
I mean, if you're ignoring the combat reports and what's going on on-screen, then yeah, some boost to the chances of your dorfs coming out unscathed at the end of a siege might seem OK in the long-term.
So, how would that work? A boost to anyone in a squad based on their captain's tactics skill? How about the military commander too? And the Champion? The individual dorf? And is that for anyone in the squad wherever they are on the map? Or limited to just those fighting within a certain range of the Captain? Does the boost switch off the moment the captain goes down?
Seems like either a lot of thought, or none at all is required to apply military tactics to on-map battles. And as tactics are generally 100% player-based right now due to the limitations of dorf fighting methods, it kind of seems a bit arbitrary.