Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[sakiskid]

ORO for me! Sounds pretty sweet, I like the idea of dungeon-crawling with my character.

[Hapah]

I'm not sure how to read that table.

[AoshimaMichio]

To me it looks like ORO is winning, but I'm wearing rose-coloured glasses. If I have time, I'll confirm the numbers later today.

[Moopli]

I'm not sure how to read that table.

Columns moving rightwards are the votes for each option, one round of removing-lowest-first-choice after another, until we get a majority. First round, ERB lost because it was nobody's first choice, second round homunculus (and the people who ranked it first were reassigned to their second choices, except for one person who I guess only ranked homunculus? wait. nobody did. shit.), third round is moot cuz it turns out I miscounted.

So someone else with more patience than I can have a go at tallying, yay!

[NJW2000]

I think Oro just won anyway. From the first count of first choices.

[AoshimaMichio]

Starting secondary count now. Please wait.



Total 35 voters.

First choice:
16 - ORO
8 - ER-ORO
6 - MAINSPRING
5 - MMWW
3 - Homunculus
0 - ERB

The three extra votes here comes from Hapah who couldn't decide what he liked most of games having no ER connection, so I put ORO, Mainspring, MMWW and Homunculus all as his first choice.

The second to sixth choices do not really matter because first choice shows clear difference, but for sake of completeness here they are:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Second choice
9 - ERB
7 - ORO
6 - MMWW
4 - ER-ORO
3 - MAINSPRING
2 - Homunculus

Third choice
10 - ERB
6 - ER-ORO
4 - ORO
4 - MMWW
3 - Homunculus
2 - MAINSPRING

Fourth choice
7 - Homunculus
6 - MMWW
3 - ER-ORO
3 - ERB
2 - ORO
1 - MAINSPRING

Fifth choice
8 - Homunculus
6 - ER-ORO
3 - MMWW
2 - ERB
1 - ORO

Sixth choice
1 - ERB
1 - MMWW
1 - Homunculus

[syvarris]

It annoyed me slightly that AO doesn't seem to understand how instant runoff works, so I did my own count too.  More data can't hurt, right?

Spoiler: Data barely contained inside (click to show/hide)

 ORO:15
 ERO:8  -1 (Hap)
  MS:5
MMWW:4
   H:2
 ERB:0   -1 (Hap)
 
First runoff doesn't do anything, because nobody voted for ERB first.
Second runoff becomes:

 ORO:16
 ERO:8  -1 (Hap)
  MS:5
MMWW:4

Harry Baldman was dropped because his second vote was for ERB, and he had no third.  Oz went from H to ORO.
Third runoff becomes:

 ORO:17
 ERO:9  -1 (Hap)
  MS:7
 
Nunz swaps to ERO.  syv swaps to MS, as does KJ.  Beirus swaps to ORO.
Hap's weird vote here might make ORO win by majority, but the fact some people prefer ORO after MS means there's definitely a majority.
Regardless, fourth runoff becomes:

 ORO:22
 ERO:13  -1 (Hap)
 
TBF, KJ, and Corsair swap to ERO.  Egan, syv, Emp, and MJ swap to ORO.  Total voters: 35 and Hapah.

[AoshimaMichio]

I'm not much into more complex voting systems, I simply counted numbers. Seems straightforward enough. And the end result is still same, isn't it?
Sorry for annoying you.

[piecewise]

I'm not much into more complex voting systems, I simply counted numbers. Seems straightforward enough. And the end result is still same, isn't it?
Sorry for annoying you.

Sy is easy to annoy. I think he might be Jamie Hyneman.

[syvarris]

Eh?  I used to watch mythbusters fairly frequently, and I don't remember him having a temper.  Seemed fairly stable actually.

[Egan_BW]

Quick, everyone change your vote to Mainspring!
... Right?

[piecewise]

Eh?  I used to watch mythbusters fairly frequently, and I don't remember him having a temper.  Seemed fairly stable actually.

It's not a temper, it's just a gruff dislike of things not being exactly right.

[syvarris]

Oh.  Well... yeah, that sums me up pretty well.

[TheBiggerFish]

Quick, everyone change your vote to Mainspring!
... Right?