Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

Okay then.
So assuming Deus Asmoth told the truth, my kill was the only one that got through last night.

[notquitethere]

Fallacy
I'd prefer it if next time you read the game and figure out a compelling reason to kill someone rather than picking blind. Random.org isn't going to save you from lynches.

The fact yet didn't see DA's claim doesn't bode well.

So who is scum if not you?

[FallacyofUrist]

That is always the question.
~~~
FallacyofUrist(I know I'm not scum)
NQT(doesn't seem scummy to me, plenty of analysis and whatnot)
4maskwolf(do we have verification of the toxic goo thing? If not, he could be scum trying to make himself the opposite of a target, of course now, got ice creamed, possibly...)
Shakerag(ice cream man apparently. Verified?)
Teneb(has he posted yet today?)
Deus Asmoth(used to be a ghoul, now batman?)
~~~
Wait a minute.

WAIT A MINUTE.
Batman is not a valid role to pick(I'm pretty sure). Check the OP.
Hence, if Deus Asmoth is now Batman...
Of course, he didn't submit the role himself, he got it from Persus after I shot him...
But then how could Persus have got it?
Which is to say, unless I'm missing something, Deus Asmoth has lied.

Explain.

[Deus Asmoth]

I never claimed Batman. I said I have a roleblock now. From what we can currently tell, hector submitted Bruce Wayne and presumably investigated, blocked or protected Persus at a later date. Persus then copied him as a result and you transferred the role to me. Of course, you'd know all this if you actually bothered reading the thread.

[FallacyofUrist]

Le humph.

Unvote.

[Deus Asmoth]

FoU again, I might be home late tomorrow.

[Teneb]

Teneb(has he posted yet today?)

Wow, you are really not reading the damn game. The day started with NQT attacking me and me defending myself. I'd vote you to make a point of how shittily you are playing, but then that'd be hammer.


Should we hammer, or let the day proceed as normal?

[FallacyofUrist]

You see, this is why I need to improve my day game.

[4maskwolf]

I vote hammertime, but that's just my liking for haste.

[notquitethere]

You see, this is why I need to improve my day game.

Fallacy, if you're not going to even try and make a coherent case, you might as well save us all some time and self-hammer. If you don't read the game, then you're obviously not hunting scum.

[FallacyofUrist]

Alright then.
I'm not giving up yet, though.
~~~
Currently, my only idea for seeking out who to hunt is to see who jumped on my bandwagon the fastest.
~~~

Spoiler: Mr. Wolf's Initial Attack on Me (click to show/hide)

Oh fucknuggets I had a whole post written out and then FoU claimed the kill.

So in other words.

We have no idea who the mafia is

It could be you!  It could be me!  It could even be...

* 4maskwolf is shot

Actually.

Let's start with the people who would have nothing better to do than kill and so probably would have.

4maskwolf (toxic goo)
notquitethere (vanilla)
Teneb (green goo)
Deus Asmoth (suiciding to avoid actions seems dumb as the only scum)

Unless one of us is being really sneak (which, okay, NQT and I are on the list, that's totally a possibility) none of us are mafia, since we'd have chosen to kill rather than sit on our asses.

That leaves Shakerag (who's dead today anyway, no need to lynch) and FallacyofUrist

FallacyofUrist

...And I ended up voting for the person I was going to vote for anyway.  That's fine by me.

Spoiler: Deus Asmoth's Initial Attack On Mwa (click to show/hide)

Claiming a role with a kill still doesn't change the fact that there was only one kill last night. The king not killing still doesn't make much sense during N1 unless they have something better to use. So either the king picked the same person as FoU or FoU is also the King. I'm in favour of cutting the knot, so FoU.

Spoiler: Not Quite There's Semi-Pressure Vote Post on Me (click to show/hide)

4mask was definitely toxic, sorry Shakes.

Fallacy, yes the rationale for killing in general is obvious but why Persus specifically?

Okay then. Let's play 3 Questions and a Vote!

...And I ended up voting for the person I was going to vote for anyway.  That's fine by me.

4maskwolf: What was your argument against me going to have been if I didn't claim the kill?

Deus Asmoth: I know this question will get into wine territory... but... why would I claim the kill if I was King Mafia?

NotQuiteThere: And now suddenly I realize it was your vote that brought me to L-1. And interestingly enough...

Fallacy, yes the rationale for killing in general is obvious but why Persus specifically?

This looks like a pressure vote to me.
A pressure vote(if I'm reading it right) that brought me almost to a hammer.
As some people say: what gives?

And here's some more stuff I've got to use: Wait, never mind. Your 1-shot corrupt bureaucrat claim solves everything else I was thinking of using.
~~~
I know it's not much, but it's all I've found(so far), so I'm going with it.

[4maskwolf]

4maskwolf: What was your argument against me going to have been if I didn't claim the kill?

Lucky you!  I still have the post I was going to make!

Nope.

Nope nope nope.

None of this flies.

None of it.

You're all bad and you should feel bad.

There is no reason Persus13 could not have mutated Deus Asmoth's role last night

If he became a ghoul any time before the end of Day 2, his power gained from Tinfoil's death could have been a one-shot mutate, which he used on Deus Asmoth.  This is easily possible without him being a goo if he has a role that can copy another player’s role, which definitely exist in this game.  N0 he copies Deus Asmoth, N1 only god knows, and N2 he mutates DA’s role since he knows DA is a ghoul as well.  If that is the case, there is no reason FallacyofUrist is clear of making the kill.  None at all.  Absolutely none.  And given the player arrangement and the nightkill that was made, I find it likely.

FallacyofUrist

And yes, I was a toxic goo and Shakerag is going to die.  Sorry Shakerag, but you're a dick for using that role on me

[notquitethere]

Fallacy, I'm unimpressed. You're a killer. My wincon is to kill a killer. I was asking you to justify your kill. Voting you is part and parcel of that. I'm happy to see you flip: so long as you can use your kill we're going to be unsure whether you have the mafia kill.

[FallacyofUrist]

Justify my kill.

Now, I'm going to note that some of you may hate this reasoning. But it's what I've got.
I killed Persus because he was there. I decided that having fewer suspects to deal with was worth potentially killing a townie. We've got the numbers advantage. We can afford to lose a few people. The King... well, mr. King Mafia is... drum roll... one person.
Persus being town was unfortunate, as it would have been preferable to shoot the King. But him(Persus) being dead means there are fewer suspects to consider, and thus we're more likely to lynch the scum.
In short, I did it to help speed up the game and simplify the issue at hand.

This.

[notquitethere]

So I'd have understood if you'd picked a dangerous player, or a disengaged player, or a hard to read player, but you apparently just picked randomly.

Who are you going to kill tonight if we don't lynch you?