First thing's first, I'm really not happy with either of you. OSG, your D2 game has been fishy as hell and your recent post just feels to me like you switched gears and figured it'd be easier to get me to off Elephant Parade rather than the other way around. Meanwhile, Elephant Parade has a knack for playing a neutral town game and I feel like he fills the classic scum hammerer position except he feels squarely neutral.
I'll continue by stating that my original theory regarding OSG hanging back to solidify his D2 game was a bit of a longshot, and is a bit shallow in retrospect. It was frankly easier for me to believe that OSG would obsfucate things rather than the alternative, that being Elephant Parade's good play as scum outside of his position in the hammer. OSG's waffle-y position at the end of D1 is understandable, if he indeed is town and realised that two scum were on the TempAcc bandwagon. I didn't like how he didn't follow that up, or how he opened D2, however.
On the other side of the coin, Elephant Parade bought my theory against OSG and provided little in the way of his own ideas, and I feel like he has been pulling his punches all game. This is my strongest point against him. Understandably, a new player will be nervous (moreso as scum), and the way he avoided blazing his own path in the weeks we've been playing reflects that.
I've made my decision. Elephant Parade, this was a promising first game for you. You're very eloquent, but for future reference, try to not be so meek if you can. You've contradicted yourself in a few of your posts, and this is where I got the feeling you were pulling punches. You need to assert yourself (especially as scum and for when it comes down to the wire like this).
Author
Topic: Vengeful Mafia 11: its over town won (Read 42902 times)