INFINITE NINJAS, NINJAS R SCUM
@Roo
Of course it was nonsensical, it was random after all, there was just an abstract reason behind it, but none that made it necessary for the vote to be towards you.
Well, I kinda already said how she reacted already :v, though not fully, so here's a better explanation.
My initial vote on you was random in the sense that I didn't have any idea of who could be what, so I picked you for no real reason to see how people would react to it. I had no reason to vote for reverie at the time, altough she did vote for me, I just took it as a random vote.
After that point, she went a bit on the odd side claiming I was ~backpedalling~, which doesn't make any sense, since I had nothing to backpedal from at the time, and at the same time, she insisted on defining you as townie, while painting me as scum. I thought this was odd, and I figured she was trying to protect you and trying to paint me as scum, so I changed the vote to her to gauge everyone's (and hers, specially) reaction to it. Her actions after that just further solidified her as scum to me, and others seem to be picking up on it. OSG also did mention how she was kinda "tunelling" me, which maaay indicate they're on different teams, meaning I'm either getting a lucky shot on a mafia member or serving as cannon fodder to a mafia plot in which OSG is involved. I dont have enough reads to change my current votes, though.
TL;DR: I didn't suspect reverie all along, I became suspicious after her reaction to my vote on you, and changed my vote to her when she seemingly only reinforced this outlook.
@Reverie:
At the time of the initial post, I was mostly joking and part roleplaying it out (which is something common in every mafia game I played, mind you, and which I'm kinda still doing since I assume this is just what people do :v). There was no special reason for me to claim you made mistakes at the time, altough I guess it did serve as a convenient excuse for you to use against me. Using something so trivial as argument fodder seemed specially ~forced~, among other things already mentioned, which helped cement my current vote on you.