Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

yup. As I thought, hector13 was scum. Real scum, anyway.

That round was horribly biased against town. Day game is far more important now.

[Tomasque]

yup. As I thought, hector13 was scum. Real scum, anyway.

That round was horribly biased against town. Day game is far more important now.

I agree. The round was very biased against town, but it wasn't meant to be played as a standard round - it was a puzzle. If everyone figured out that their roles were from round 2, people's true wincons would be revealed, and a massclaim would root out the true evil role.

[FallacyofUrist]

If only I figured it out before I died.

Something seems... odd, though. Multiple things, actually.

1. The detective role in round 2's flavor seems to foreshadow this round. Did you really plan that far ahead?
2. There are no role blocks in this round. Yet Divine Immunity includes role block immunity.
3. What was with the day thing "? falters ?"? Something's up with Melody.
4. Fingertips. Odd role name...
5. "The world will be ending soon." Foreshadowing. Something's happening round 21, something special. I wonder if there will be a bonus round, though.

[Elephant Parade]

All of the roles are from previous rounds, I'm pretty sure (with the possible exception of Fingertips).

[Tomasque]

1. The detective role in round 2's flavor seems to foreshadow this round. Did you really plan that far ahead?
2. There are no role blocks in this round. Yet Divine Immunity includes role block immunity.
3. What was with the day thing "? falters ?"? Something's up with Melody.
4. Fingertips. Odd role name...
5. "The world will be ending soon." Foreshadowing. Something's happening round 21, something special. I wonder if there will be a bonus round, though.

 1. The role flavor actually wasn't meant to foreshadow this round - I hadn't fully planned this one yet.
 2. That  was just there to prevent hector from gaining too much if he exploited the information Divine Immunity gave him about existing abilities.
 3. The day flavor was hidden except for a single word that would reveal if Melody was autoactivated.
 4.
 5. Something special indeed.

[Elephant Parade]

Tomasque: How did you set the topic icon to "cell phone", anyway? I checked the dropdown and it wasn't there.

[hector13]

yup. As I thought, hector13 was scum. Real scum, anyway.

That round was horribly biased against town. Day game is far more important now.

Confirmation bias. I was the only person doing anything that entire round

[Tomasque]

Tomasque: How did you set the topic icon to "cell phone", anyway? I checked the dropdown and it wasn't there.

Huh. It was available when I began this game - I guess it was removed. Why would Toady do that?

[Starver]

Confirmation bias. I was the only person doing anything that entire round

Though I didn't know why, it was why I was definitely angling at you. Too much aggressiveness (except that it worked, of course, long enough for the secondary kill to get me).

[Starver]

Fish, even without the (unexpected) second evil, I'd probably have not gone for the Neutral kill just to get my Wincon back. That's me, though. But my numbers were 1-3 too, so when you later gave that, I realised you were doomed.

[hector13]

I think it was just 'cause you were getting frustrated with what I was doing, which was borne of frustration with what you were doing.

You're like the difference between a calculator and showing your work; town!hector wanted you to explain what you were saying, whereas you seemed content with just displaying the answer again :p

[Starver]

Oh, and...

I'll say right now that I am not. Or at least that doesn't fit my question marks, if that's even what one would expect. Which, BTW, was given away far too early. I wish you'd let me get in on the bandwagon with a subtle acknowledgement before giving the game away. Or, to put it another way.

Right to now, in this flap be bromidic, effendi. Enigma. Surreal.
(Too soon have you given back, in to view, hidden persona tableau / fact volcano.)

Just to stake my claim in advance.  I don't even known what else to do right now...

...I hope that at least Hector saw that (not that I really wanted the Evil/True Evil to know it) easily, especially once revealed....

Post ninja: I think I made my workings clear enough. I was actually wrong about EP (because eager-to-seem-normal EP blew the question marks thing in a Town-like way, hence the contrivance above for exactly the reasons I gave!) and Fallacy should never have been considered dangerous (before revealing the damning evidence that confirmed, but probably doomed, Fish, and you have my reasoning about afterwards...), and I wasn't initially as sure about Fish (the bandwagon I had decided against getting on myself), but you were always scummiest-looking, and I know I hit a button, but I was just unsure as to whether I was actually accidentally hitting a Townie berserk button or a Scummy one, and I couldn't work out how to tell the difference between the two.

[hector13]

I was pissed off nobody was talking and you weren't expanding on your answers so I couldn't find anything beyond "obfuscation" to pin on you :p

Anyhow, did anyone get that secret message?

[TheBiggerFish]

Tomasque: How did you set the topic icon to "cell phone", anyway? I checked the dropdown and it wasn't there.

Huh. It was available when I began this game - I guess it was removed. Why would Toady do that?

SMF update might've changed defaults.

[Starver]

Obviously I failed to act decisively enough, and I missed some signs (remembering what the "1-3" meant last time, grasping at the "falters" keyword, etc) that might have helped, but now I'm left wondering....

Did anyone really know enough? Neatly ended dead 'cause our real rogue initiated dully ordinary rogue's special nastiness. E xcept that remained ostensibly unknown, not deducible. Questionably unlucky effects? Should those insidious obscurations negate most actions, realistically?

Those were my first thoughts, and I've not seen it said otherwise, but maybe by the next round it will prove itself as one conclusion or the other.  I can be silly, sometimes, just repeating previous analyse, but just in case it is useful to come back to it anyway.