Ok, sat down and still again. Sorry, took a while, had to go shopping first. (And thanks for the fruit suggestions. I actually ended up with some apple turnovers. Somewhat unimaginative. But with a copious amount of fresh cream. Yum.)
I remain very cynical about these "if you were..." questions. No significantly surprising answers (Fish might have been revealing something, but I've made bigger bluffs myself, both as Townie and non-Townie), and too much WIFOMability.
Scrapping the essay, the TL;DR; is that everyone has something to hide, and if anybody has anything they're trying to selectively reveal to someone else, then its nothing I've picked up on. Or I have but I'm being equally secretive in my acknowledgement.
I could say that (or generally act as if) I have the ability to nullify the Evil skill, but am I telling the truth (looking for protection), bluffing (intending to be the Fainting Goat) or outright telling porkies (if I were Evil). Or a fourth option that I'm witholding? So much Wine, all of it In Front Of Me...
And it is trivial to play as a different character (holding back and not committing to anything lest your assumptions of others are wrong) in either alignment setting. Hardest of all to do right are the small breadcrumb trails laid down to support a later day's claims when you bounce back in with something definitive about your role, showing as how your carefully protected identity was mentioned all along. (Assuming you hadn't put multiple such identities behind various closed doors, and you open up exactly the one, for people, thst is the most convenient one to allow them through.) I wonder if any of you have done this, honestly or otherwise. But such things don't even need questions, and ate probably easier to do unbidden and unprompted, as it gives one a free hand to craft one's easter-eggs, rather than shoehorn them into a restrictive question-and-answer format.
Okay, that was three entire rewrites, to try to make it short. Didn't work. Probably didn't help, either. Oh, fuggit.
(Have I spent, more than an hour on that? Seems like I have.)
@Hector, I don't want to do Evil's work for them. NoLynch suits me, as the likely roles/counter-roles will be hit hardest from a random lynch, IME.