Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

... there is no contradiction.

[TheBiggerFish]

... there is no contradiction.

Oh?  How, pray tell?

[Starver]

Now... Hector claimed Town, Starver said he was Neutral. Someone's lying. And Hector would only lie if he had a wincon against Town, so... what do y'all say we lynch them both?

Starver.

Hector is neutral,  and I say,  as Town,  that the nature of his neutrality is not opposed to a Town win,  although I think he might be tempted to not help us. Also I wouldn't blame Hector for /claiming/ Town,  and nor should you.  IMO.

/If/ I am lynched,  and proven as Town (as I will,  but you won't know that for sure)  I thus implore you not to lynch Hector. Right now,  I think that's the worst idea. Yes,  worse than lynching me,  even. .  When all is done,  you'll understand this,  I promise.

If you don't Lynch me,  then I appreciate that you are without confirmation..  Nothing I can do about that. But my death or Hector's overnight might give you a clue,  if that's possible,  and might cause 'problems'  of some kind (not to mention the issue of the Orb,  which I'm hazy about a small detail of) .but also clear up one side or other of the equation...  Maybe Scum doesn't want to risk that,  but I am willing to do so if I can't stop a bad guy night-kill.   Should that exist in tbis game.  (I have doubts about the kill function,  I suspect corruption is the name of the game,  but I need more data.)

[TheBiggerFish]

Fallacy.

[hector13]

That's essentially a vote for Moonlit, TBF.

[hector13]

Obviously the "contradiction" doesn't matter anymore.

[FallacyofUrist]

Hector...
Are you neutral, or are you not neutral?

Fallacy.

Why?

That's essentially a vote for Moonlit, TBF.

Why?

[TheBiggerFish]

Because I trust Starver after that one.

[hector13]

You and I are voting for Moonlit. Voting anyone who isn't Starver or Moonlit isn't really a vote at all.

There's no reason for me to answer your other question.

PPE: you just said earlier you didn't know if you could trust him. He said nothing new. What?

[hector13]

Does it just take repeating an argument to convince you?

[TheBiggerFish]

At least enough to lodge a vote that will do nothing.

But now, hector, you're pushing the not-answering-questions button again...

[TheBiggerFish]

Hector:Are you neutral or town, for approximately the fifth or so time?

[FallacyofUrist]

But now, hector, you're pushing the not-answering-questions button again...

THIS.
hector, why no answer neutral or no neutral question?

[hector13]

Apparently Starver knows my alignment better than I do. Ask him.

[hector13]

No answer.