The whole thing with the replacement roles is they got worse and worse...
Although once I realised I'd probably not get out of Day 3 alive, tried to work out what would happen and then
realised I'd be given a replacement, I definitely was rather hoping that it'd end up on someone either super-Townie or super-Scummy (according to what best balanced). As you know, from my in-private ponderings, but just so the others
Not that it changed anything, for me, as I'd already decided that (if I was right about Fallacy) that the Town Power was going to have to aim straight and true against the existing threat. Anything else was even more speculative than the current speculation...
As stated, I definitely ranked Fallacy as most 'friendly', Hector as least, on balance. But I was the most worried of ultimately ending up being wrong about Moonlit. Well in the background (although significant) were any worries that Fallacy just might actually being evil,
then behind that was Hector actually being non-evil (not insignificant, just the smallest predicted 'error bar'). It did even occur to me to switch to voting for Moonlit, to break the stalemate, but that'd have probably gotten me the lynch-vote by Fallacy even quicker.
Surprisingly enough, if you had gotten yourself lynched D2 by acting suspicious, you would've gotten the Nabstablook role and had a chance to win.
Ah, yes, the character that the (official?) Wiki doesn't even seem to admit exists..
(No, I haven't yet even checked to see if tEMMIE is mentioned..!)