Day 1 StartHector with meta-question.
Tomasque with answer.
Fish starts posting
in/as Sans.
Moonlit has meta-question.
Fish conjectures.
Moonlit queries conjecture.
Fish answers query.
Moonlit queries answer.
Fish answers query answer query.
Myself being flippant, as promised.
Fish asks for my role.
Moonlit keeps on about the conjecture.
(Page summary: Heavy/obscure hints of role from Fish, depending on the recipient, but nothing from anyone else.)
Fish on the same track (
further hints as to character, that I still hadn't understood).
Moonlit seems to get it.
Fish confirms.
Fish suggests checking lore.
Moonlit asks Hector for role.
Fish asks Moonlit for role.
Moonlit reveals 'Asgore' (which seems to have been a lie, by
Chara).
Fish surprised at this and/or finds it noteworthy...
Myself showing my ignorance. (Also I asked Moonlit of TBF had replied with the role yet. I
meant "
had Hector?")
Fish asks for my role, again!
Hector announces
Chara role. (Later turns out to have be a lie.)
Fish finds that interesting...
Moonlit does too. (And it later seems for even
better reasons.)
Hector practically suggests he's not being honest.
Fish puts forward doubts about Chara (misplaced, maybe it turns out).
(Page summary: Confirmation from Fish; Moonlit and Hector make statements later retracted. I'm actually absent more that I'd like to have been.)
Fish is
suspicions about Chara.
Fish thinks anyone who was Chara wouldn't claim it.
Moonlit agrees (
because...?)
Hector doesn't like being asked names, nor given names.
Fish restates role.
Hector suggests Sans==Evil out of the air.
Fish proclaims Sans==Investigator.
Hector doubts that.
Fish banters back.
Fallacy has meta-ideas/questions.
Fish has meta-answer.
Hector with more meta-queries.
Myself has only partly-informed meta-ideas.
Fish opines that it's a Genocide Route version of the game (whatever that means about Fish's character).
Fish also goes OOC, for my benefit.
(Page summary: Big doubts placed upon Hector=>Chara. Fish restates Sans-ness. Hector argues the point/points the finger.)
Fallacy announces 'blocking skill', looks for candidates.
Fish diverts possibility towards me, but not sure how serious.
Myself doesn't think that's useful.
Hector doubts the Genocide Route concept. Hints he knows what my and Fallacy's roles are, and some meta (that later is informed to be wrong).
Fish still doesn't like the Chara claim.Hector doesn't think the Evil role is "evil", yet. Wants Moonlit 'smothered' by Fallacy.
Fallacy wonders why Moonlit?
Fish makes a semantic correction, only.
Tomasque gives meta-information. (Note: I misunderstand something about this, but never mind.)
Hector just thinks Moonlit is evil. (May even have been correct, but I don't understand the reasons.)
Fish queries.
Hector doesn't like all this claiming stuff. Apparently drawn conclusions.
Apparently everyone else could also do this. (Nobody seemd to go "oh yeah..." about that)
Fish has meta-idea. (Dog?
I've not seen anything about a dog, yet!)
Tomasque gives Meta stuff.
Don't ignore the Lore!Fish with meta-followup.
(Page summary: First appearance of Fallacy's Blue SOUL whatavyer thing; Hector seems to have reasons to think (or state) that it isn't a Genocidal Route; Some meta-info, etc, but not much else of significance.
To me!)
Fish states (whatever character) doesn't change at all, between Routes?
Moonlit seeks character names because of own Role. (And states again that Hector is lying about being Chara. Might have been a big clue, there, if I'd have been keeping an eye on things.)
Fish had spotted Hector's retraction.
Hector now makes it official and
re-claims as Asriel, shutting the door on everything else.
Fish points out the problems with an Asriel-claim, and henceforth the implications vis-a-vis Flowey.
Tomasque minor meta-stuff.
Fish doesn't trust Hector.
Hector acknowledges. Starts up "names or be voted for" policy.
Fish promises 'investigation' on Hector (never happens, SFAICT, thanks to lynch).
Fallacy claims as Papyrus (later retracted).
Fish is in character as Sans.
Hector responds to Fish/Fallacy
Fish gives passive support for possibility of Fallacy==Papyrus.
Fish asks about Flowey, again.
Hector comments upon some bit of the Lore, in response.
(Page summary: Hector re-classed as being an Asriel-claimaint. Asriel tends to be considered not-necessarily-nice. Fish
might be threatening Hector. Fallacy claims Papyrus name, for Hector. Flowey distractions.)
Fallacy expands upon caimed blocking skill.
Hector talking about Toriel/Undyne. (When I finally read that, I definitely perked up by ears. Errr... eyes. Whatever. Given who I hadn't yet said I was.)
Fish wants Fallacy to 'guard' them.
Fish wonders about that, actually...
Fish decides it's Ok, after all. (Never actually happens, for various reasons.)
Moonlit tells Fish that Hector is/claims Asriel.
Fish wonders about Flowey, still.
Fish links to re-roling...
Moonlit asserts Hector is Asriel (
still not sure why so definite about this, especially as I hadn't arrived back on-board and announced my own role!)
Hector votes against me, as I'd been voiceless. (Can't complain, except that it's not exactly logical...)
Fish thinks that that was too hasty, too...
Hector reasons his own activity, time left, etc.
Fish disagrees... (With what turns out to be an ironic statement.)
Hector argues for the lynching approach.
Fish argues against. (Anyone for tennis?)
(Page summary: Fallacy's blocking skill. Fish's willingness to be blocked. Asriel role 'confirmed' (although is it, really?). My role remains a mystery (sorry!).
Hector continues the volley.
Fish counters with a good point (not yet confirmed/dismissed!)
Hector persuades.
Fish acquiesces.
Hector starts to actively campaign against nolynches.
Fish alludes to his investigative role.
Hector has good arguments (but a bit unbalanced, IMO).
Fish backs down.
Fallacy will use ability on TBF (strange statement, has to be a misdirection, but could be for any purpose...)
Hector responds to Fish with a hard-to-parse statement...
Fish forgot about the three-day limit.
Hector is the only one voting.
Hector makes a minor correction.
Fish has a plan. (It is secret, though!)
Fallacy asks a meta-question.
(Page summary: Not much learnt. Fish has(/had) a plan, Hector wants lynches. Fallacy possibly misdirects (or else has to change his mind later).
Hector switches aim to Fish, for speculative reasons.
Fish OMGUSes.
Fish announces intended plan. (
Starts to looks threatening to scum?)
Fish appends.
Fish queries Hector on a point.
Hector thinks there's Lore involved. (Also insists that roles
will be replaced...)
Fish says Hector has the wrong end of the right stick.
Fish thinks Investigation will happen, yet.
Fallacy announces more about Blue Attack.
Fish says "bring it on!" (essentially...)
Tomasque answers meta-questions.
Hector aims back at me, whilst I'm still absent.
Fish unvotes.
Fallacy aims at Fish and (I missed this, first time round!) announces a Blue Attack on me... (oh, right, missed that).
Fish aims at me, and mentions the non-flip.
(Page summary: General fighting. A bit more about Blue Attack, things get hectic. I'm sorry I missed this.)
Hector wants to get rid of me and have Fish blocked. (Makes me wish I'd later stayed silent, when I arrived, it might have been more interesting.)
Myself arriving, apologising, trying to catch up.
Fish reiterates Investigator ability.
Fish asks me who I am.
Hector gives a frankly nonsensical reason for disbelieving anything.
Fish claims more than I'd personally believe, but I guess we're not meant to know if it's true or not, until round-end, so...
Fish laconically expands. Not sure what to make of it, but we obviously have no reason to.
Hector gets a bit more aggressive against Fish (who, by the way, has claimed great things).
Fish stands by his unresolvable claim...
Fish makes an argument I find convincing, but... meh...
Myself gets (nearly!) caught up. I claim. I say some things. Not sure I can influence things.
Hector replies to Fish, but re-aims at Moonlit. (Bloodthirsty, aint ya?)
Fish makes a good summary, I think.
Fish says something I still don't understand.
Fish worries about a mistake (I don't think there was one...)
(Page summary: I return! Hector ups the berserker activities, with nothing new said. Fish affirms his standfastness. Nobody else features, on this page.)
Fish responds to Hector.
Hector responds to Fish. (Nothing worth saying about this.)
Fish announces (RL) sleeping, and unvoting.
Hector doesn't like that (no change there!)
Fish thinks it's a tie.
Fish is sleeping...
Hector states Town Weakness. Expects something Secret to happen.
Myself, revealing not much more, except that I don't know much more.
Hector re-aims at now-absent Fish. (Sheesh...)
Myself thinking I'm happy with that. (Now, not so much.) And some OOC.
Hector OOC.
Hector regarding Lore, slightly overturning previous statements, but... it's your argument.
Hector asking me about my Lore-cramming.
Myself OOC. Plus obviously I'm still cramming.
Hector OOC. Plus trying to get me to vote for someone.
(Page summary: Hector flip-flops and strongarms. Fish sleeps. Sleeps, perchance to dream, aye, there's the rub...)
Myself, voting (as requested), even though it doesn't matter.
Hector doesn't like that.
Fish has awoken, and wants to vote for Hector.
Fish decides to vote for me instead.
Fish doesn't like the "lore" reason. (That wasn't the main reasin, anyway.)
Tomasque ends the day. (Makes me wish I'd voted for Hector, and let Fish make it a draw, because I don't now like how it turned out.)
Tomasque starts Day 2. Fish (lynched-replaced already) was killed overnight too, in the new-character of Frisk (Neutral). Don't know who did this, but I know it wasn't me.
Fish "bah"s...
Hector asks silly questions of me and Fallacy, and FOSses Moonlit.
Myself replying.
Fallacy (plausibly) confirms me as inactive, thus (plausibly) confirming Fallacy's actions. Considering Moonlit/Hector as maybescum but mostly Moonlit (for reasons I don't completely agree with..,). (Also error considering Fish-killed-at-night as the same as Fish-lynched-prior-day, but... meh...)
Hector goes off on the "your vote is important" thing (which it provably wasn't). I put this down to basic gameplay differences, but it doesn't help Hector's cause. Problems with Fallacy, too. More 'meh'.
Fallacy replies to Hector.
Hector replies to Fallacy.
Fallacy replies to Hector. (Does sort of lean on getting my confirmation, at this point, with the caveat of a Redirector, so isn't a
100% confirmation that I can give, but that's discussed later, anyway.)
(Page summary: Fish(D1) died - We don't know what Fish(D1) was. Fish(N1) died - We know Fish(N1) was Frisk, and Neutral. Fallacy(D1) continues to live and is seeking confirmation from me (and will more or less get it). Hector's all over the place. Moonlit is currently absent.
Hector demands scumhunting.
Fallacy either lays out his store or plays a gambit (either way, it'll work).
Myself confirming/correlating with Fallacy. I already don't like Hector's approach, it seems.
Fish whilst dead, clarifies a technical point only.
Myself, temporarily under the misconception that as well as lynch-replace there's also nightkill-replace of roles. Meh.
Hector corrects me.
Moonlit says nothing important.
Moonlit apologises for being busy.
Myself, still slightly confused about nightkills. (Fish's second post-death message didn't help.
)
Hector being helpful about this.
Moonlit (effectively) points out that Evil characters ought to try to kill more through lynches. ('strue! Or was, until the end of D2.)
Hector asks for my reasons (already given!)
Myself, giving them. Again.
Moonlit accepting Hector as Asrael, still. (I still don't know why so definite! Even if it is so!)
Hector makes generally stupid responses, IMO.
(Page summary: So... ummm... well, not much that we don't know about, right now. Slightly less, though.
Fallacy makes some points. (But boy am I fed up writing this list...)
Hector ...
Moonlit (Fakeclaim to a possibly real role status. As yet unproven.)
Hector on about the voting, again, with Moonlit...
Hector nudging me.
Fallacy responds to Hector. (Bear in mind that I'd confirmed the assertion, at this point, so making the claim/fakeclaim pretty definite, whichever it was.)
Hector aims at Moonlit.
Moonlit will not vote, because thinks Hector is scum. (Or so says. One has to drawn into question the motives for this statement, in hindsight, but still...)
Hector is hectoring.
Tomasque ends Day 2 (that was quick!), with Moonlit lynched, to be replaced.
Tomasque opens Day 3. Nobody died.
Fallacy reiterates that Hector is Scum.
Moonlit decides to go with Fallacy, instead. (Doubtless 'clears' Hector because of new status. Although that really doesn't mean much, with Secret alignment-transfers/awakenings or somesuch.)
Moonlit oopses...
Fallacy says Hector took no action last night. (Means nothing much, though.)
(Page summary: All change! We don't actually
know this, yet, but we lost Chara (Moonlit's lynch-out role), gained someone new (allegedly town-Weak) and Moonlit probably is free(er) to proclaim Hector as innocent, although that isn't necessarily going to be how it plays out, anyway...
Moonlit goes through some details. (I think there's a big mistake in considering "You have a kill" as significantly scummy... Scum
usually, although not always in this game, wants to
use a kill. And, when they don't, there's usually something else on the agenda, rather than a kill...)
Fallacy ...
Moonlit corrects Fallacy.
Fallacy is corrected, presses ahead with a prior question.
Hector WOTs us all... (Is wrong about "being able to tell if someone can take a night action", because I can. Is wrong about own role being confirmed by Moonlit, it only
agrees with stated circumstances. Starts slinging around "confirmation bias", and contradicts prior idea about what skill Fallacy actually has at the same time. Valid point about Fallacy's role not being
fully confirmed, but I think enough "not contradicted"ness. Also getting seems to be getting needy again.)
Moonlit confirms N1 kill was self, as Chara. (Or says so... always a chance that it still wasn't!)
Myself responding to a missed message, resulting in a WOT.
Myself responding to this round. More WoT, because I was sure if I missed anything out I'd just be asked for more detail...
Hector asks for more detail...
Myself starting to get a bit fed up, TBH, but tries best.
Myself with an EBWOP.
Fallacy is in *head asplode* mode, it seems.
Moonlit deals with some of what I said.
Myself, responding to Fallacy.
Myself, responding to Moonlit.
(Page summary: Walls Of Text, often requiring Walls Of Text in reply. Revelation of Chara's (prior) existence in the person of Moonlit. Exonerates Hector from being
original killer, but I'm not sure that's still the case. Never mind. Doesn't matter to me, but maybe it does to others.
Hector looks to be in damage control mode, from my POV. YMMV.
Myself pointing out that Hector hasn't made many defensive points. Asks for assistance from others.
hector takes umbrage at this.
Myself ....
Myself trying to set a logic trap for any non-Hector scum out there to wander blindly into.
Hector trips it, from the off. Annoying and/or telling. Hard to say which.
Hector WoTs against me. (Points out a couple of minor mistypes, by assuming them to mean something completely wrong.)
Myself clarifying. (And pondering.)
Moonlit ...
Hector responding to Moonlit.
Fallacy Metas.
Hector asking for votes again. (Bloodthirsty, still... Playing style, or...?)
Fallacy ...
Meta-answer
(Page summary: Everything I have to say about this page I've already said on this page...
Moonlit replies to Hector.
Fallacy replies to Moonlit.
Myself with a smaller WoT.
Hector misunderstands.
Myself clarifying.
hector makes the message above, setting me on the path to creating
this message.