Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

Technically there were three, I was a neutral in the last game.

[TheBiggerFish]

Yes, that's why I find it strange.

And yes.

Wait what now?  Seriously?

...Still vaguely suspicious but less so.

Starver:Talk?

[hector13]

Yes, that's why I find it strange.

And yes.

Wait what now?  Seriously?

...Still vaguely suspicious but less so.

Starver:Talk?

RE: Starver: asking a question might do it.

Also, what were you referring to with "seriously"?

[TheBiggerFish]

Three Weakness/Neutral roles last game.

[hector13]

We only had two townies a few rounds ago, 't ain't that bizarre

Though I'd certainly appreciate you trying to confirm or reject your suspicions about FoU.

[FallacyofUrist]

Hmmm....
I don't trust FoU...

I could do with a "why" to this question.
~~~
How would a "thief" even work in this round? As far as I know, we don't have items...

[hector13]

Hmmm....
I don't trust FoU...

I could do with a "why" to this question.
~~~
How would a "thief" even work in this round? As far as I know, we don't have items...

...

...

...

What's your point?

[FallacyofUrist]

...
wait a minute, we've already had a thief role before...
~~~
My point is that I don't see how a thief role would work in this round.

[hector13]

...
wait a minute, we've already had a thief role before...
~~~
My point is that I don't see how a thief role would work in this round.

Well, the thief role before stole roles, rather than items.

Perhaps you just don't want us considering the possibility?

Have you never seen "The Thing" before? (again, the old one. Not sure if the newer one is any good)

[FallacyofUrist]

((Never seen said movie before.))

Eh. There's nothing wrong with considering the possibility of some sort of thief, but it doesn't seem likely to me.
Instead of theorizing about a thief, I would prefer to hunt down the evil role in this round.

[Tomasque]

Votes are PMed to me. They can be changed.

[Starver]

You also might just be over-thinking things;

Hey, that's not allowed!  I'm the one who should be overthinking things!

Starver:Talk?

RE: Starver: asking a question might do it.

Naw... That was just for the pretend role I was trying to pretend I had the last game.

(Only just come back, after some late-night shopping.  That's RL, not gamelife.  So I skimmed the last three pages, I'll go back again over it when I have a moment, but for the time being...)

Now you're arguing over how many different roles there are, and knowledge of how Round 7 went, it makes my question from Round 6 of "What roles do you think there are?" quite a sensible one, it seems...

Anyway, this round I've only seen one Weak claimed (and with an outline!), one "might as well be Weak" (either Neutral or something Special that isn't appreciated? ...not much more information), one Special (unknown aspect of the flavour), I've missed Fish's claim (if one was made) and I know mine, but that's something I really don't want the Evil (who has, by now, fairly probably said something untrue) to know.

And four five new replies whilst writing that.  Busy!

[hector13]

Fair enough. Just letting you know my thoughts on the matter.

Starver: thoughts on proceedings?

FoU: thoughts on TBF's weakness claim?

Moonlit: you seemed awfully quick to dismiss my thoughts about a thief, suggesting overly complex ability combinations before considering simpler things. What was that about?

TBF: you're suspicious of FoU as he claimed weakness role. Why should we, and FoU specifically, not also be suspicious of you for the same reason?

PPE: telling TBF to ask a question was mostly because "talk?" isn't encouraging you to do anything useful heh. Also, Fish claimed weakness.

You also made the "I don't really want Evil to know my role" in the last round

[TheBiggerFish]

@hector:It just struck me as odd that a) he claimed THAT FAST and b) he claimed my archetype.

[FallacyofUrist]

I am a Psychologist. I can inspect people to see if they are town or not.

This is one example of me claiming early in this game.
There are several others.
~~~
And there's nothing stopping there from being two town weakness roles, as last round demonstrated.
~~~

FoU: thoughts on TBF's weakness claim?

He's given no details other than being town weakness, for starters...
and thus far, we don't have any evidence for him being town weakness, oui?