Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[FallacyofUrist]

What makes you think TBF is scum?

[Tomasque]

^{It's pretty embarrassing for me to ask this... But why does the scum keep losing? Is there something obvious I'm missing?}
Round over - Town wins!

Votecount
hector13 (0)
FallacyofUrist (0)
TheBiggerFish (1)-hector13
Starver (0)

 Not voting: FallacyofUrist, TheBiggerFish, Starver

TheBiggerFish was the Phantom

Spoiler: Phantom (click to show/hide)

Phantom
You are the wind that rattles the windows. You are the whisper that spreads lies into people's thoughts and the madness already inside that accepts them.
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you equal or outnumber the other players.

(a) Incorporeal: Your vote shows up on the vote counter, but does not count.
(n) Convince: Your target replaces their wincon with "You win if the Evil role wins." Their wincon reverts once they die. You cannot use this power until your target's wincon reverts.

hector13 gets one victory point.
FallacyofUrist gets one victory point.
Starver gets one victory point.

Spoiler: Player Roles (click to show/hide)

Phantom
You are the wind that rattles the windows. You are the whisper that spreads lies into people's thoughts and the madness already inside that accepts them.
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you equal or outnumber the other players.

(a) Incorporeal: Your vote shows up on the vote counter, but does not count.
(n) Convince: Your target replaces their wincon with "You win if the Evil role wins." Their wincon reverts once they die. You cannot use this power until your target's wincon reverts.

The watchful one
You're always looking out for your friends. If they're lost, you know where to find them. If someone looks at them funny, you stalk them to their house. They say you might be a little paranoid, but they don't understand: You're just doing what's best.
Archetype: Investigative role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated.

(n) Follow: You are informed of whom your target visits.

The protective one
Your friends like you because they know you're always going to keep them safe. You've been there to put a band-aid on their scrapes and cuts, to stand in the way of bullies, and to lock them in your house when you know they'll go out and hurt themselves.
Archetype: Special Town role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated.

(n) Protect: You keep your target safe, preventing them from acting and preventing all actions targeting them.

The rational one
Your friends are a little weird, but they look up to you - and over time, your companionship has definitively improved their... stability. You think it's time to bring them up to your cabin to calm their stress caused by their constant exposure to the city.
Archetype: Special Town role
Wincon: You win if the Evil role is eliminated.

(a) Sensible: All the Evil role's actions targeting you fail.
(a) Idol: Your vote breaks ties.

Spoiler: Action Log (click to show/hide)

Night 0
TheBiggerFish convinced Starver (action failed)
hector13 followed TheBiggerFish (action failed)
FallacyofUrist protected hector13

[TheBiggerFish]

D'aaaargh!

I think you need slightly more players.

By the way, who blocked my action on Starver N0?

[TheBiggerFish]

Also, hector,

I mean, call me the rational one

WASN'T you claiming investigator?

[hector13]

Town wins. Will add stuff later.

 It's pretty embarrassing for me to ask this... But why does the scum keep losing? Is there something obvious I'm missing?

It's probably the number of players. I had a bad claim round 1, and FoU was super obvious round 2 (though arguably the scum ability was super obvious too) and I think we were lucky this time round.

I knew FoU was claiming true because my action failed (or at least it seemed the most likely reason) so that left Starver and TBF. TBF gave me a gut feeling, so I voted for him.

I claimed nothing but that's what I was, you quoted Starver though.

Nice how I'm the only one voting scum

[TheBiggerFish]

Oh derp.

[TheBiggerFish]

I'll tell you now, I suppose.
I was The Phantom, I had a single-target convert and an auto that left me functionally voteless.

[Tomasque]

More players you say... Well, I'll see if MoonlitShadow wants to join - seeing he seems to be following this thread quite closely.

[TheBiggerFish]

Just, recruit 2 more, have a scumteam, and start over.

[Tomasque]

Just, recruit 2 more, have a scumteam, and start over.

Two more... Nah.. Starting at that point the game might get too big. Of course, if 5 is too small...

 Anyway, don't expect the game to change too dramatically. Just pretend nothing happened. A'right? 

[TheBiggerFish]

Two, The Moonlit Shadow being one of two for six players.

[TheBiggerFish]

But yes, pretending nothing happened, check.

[hector13]

I think five players would be best, unless you're increasing the size of the scum team.

[TheBiggerFish]

I think two scum four town is probably better.

[Tomasque]

A scumteam of two is something I don't want to do... for reasons I cannot reveal. Anyway, am updating the Town Win post right now.