Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

I'm not sure if I find that agreeable.

[hector13]

Starver, then

[TheBiggerFish]

Anywho:Reads.

1)FoU (who I have already voted for):Claims third mechanic and strikingly useful power for Town Weakness pattern.  Eliminating an unwanted nightkill...Not a weakness.  Immunity to the alleged conversion mechanic...Not a weakness.  Irrelevance to scum wincon...Not a weakness, unless you go blabbing about it!  If he wasn't already on Moonlit's radar, he's the guy I'm passing the bomb to, unless something comes up and proves my suspicions wrong.

TMS:Didn't use daykill despite plenty of viable opportunities.  Probably not scum.

Hector:Talkative.  Advising caution, but simultaneously pushing for a day end.  I'm not sure about you.

Starver:
I'm really not sure.
Trying to ferret out what other roles we have.  That's not necessarily a town thing or a scum thing.  Might even be neutral.
All the same, I'm not seeing a lot from your direction.

[TheBiggerFish]

But it's even less scumhuntable.

[hector13]

I'd quite like the day to end, thanks. We're stuck in a quagmire of "ooo I might be wrong" and not getting much done. Excuse me for not finding the situation entertaining.

We all seem to unsure about Starver, so if you don't want to end the day, ask him some bloody questions.

[FallacyofUrist]

Do I get a vote? Because if I get a vote...

hector13. In my opinion, it's either him or Starver.

[TheBiggerFish]

Starver, who are you?

[Starver]

Starver, who are you?

I'm just a guy in the street looking for answers (unofficially, right now, as it's not currently my phase to be directly useful), but getting knocked back by someone who refuses to answer questions then asks everyone to ask me questions...

(I'm not voting, although you can see where I'm personally minded.  Across this whole round, Hector has already voted twice for me, you voted twice for Fallacy, and Fallacy just the once for Hector, by my reckoning.  Votes that ultimately aren't relevant.  Moonlit's got to decide based upon appearances, which I'm not perfectly sure I can objectively know and wouldn't want to 'play with' anyway.  Moonlit's own role motivations are going to influence things most of all, and I'm sure that's the sticking point.)

[TheBiggerFish]

I see.

[TheBiggerFish]

Do you have any questions for any of us?

[Starver]

Do you have any questions for any of us?

Me?
Well, I already thought I'd get something (not personally revealing, obviously, but philosophically so) from the "What distribution of roles..?" one.  But that got kicked straight into the long brush, for whatever reason, and I'm pretty sure that the people who should be on their guard against that definitely now are, thanks to the conversation I felt forced to have about it, so it's rather ruined my best attempts at gaining (and providing) further enlightenment ahead of the inevitable (if directionally-uncertain) gunshot.

Hang on, maybe I can still trick our enemy into revealing himself, with one last clever gambit:

@everyone: Are you the scum?  @everyone, as a follow-up question: Are you sure?

[TheBiggerFish]

*snrk*

@Starver:No.
@Starver:Yes.

@Starver:For some reason, I think we have two investigators this round.  A scum, and then special and weakness probably.

[hector13]

The reason I knocked back your question about the role distribution was because it's not useful. What will speculating about the setup do? Will it allow us to find scum? I don't think so.

Don't let me being a dick discourage you from asking questions. If you ask a question I don't think is very good, I'll tell you. If you ask a question I think is reasonable, I'll answer it.

One thing I will say is scum generally don't want the town to get information in the game, but they need to look as though they're doing something. Asking about the setup is one way to look like you're engaging without providing useful information for the town.

I'm also feeling very ill right now, so would like other folk to put effort into finding scum.

[FallacyofUrist]

@everyone: Are you the scum?  @everyone, as a follow-up question: Are you sure?

No. Yes. Why would you ask these questions?

[Starver]

(Well, at least I'm getting answers now.)