Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Starver]

Sorry for that edit, and I can't find my orignal text by backpaging.

Start again.

You're not contributing much either, cha know. You said you have an auto, and that's it.

(I was saying as how) You seem not to respond to my attempts to get a little bit here, a little bit there, and I don't want to reward you for that, but let's see if you (Hector) can respond sanely enough with equivalent information to the following:
I am a puppet hand who passes on commands. I have had in mind to say that there's a script-writer's hand behind my actions, but nothing now seems to bear that out.  I have had no idea what my commands may do (until I see the roeflips, at least, which is why I trust Moonlit's declarations) and I presume that there is just one person who would not mind my winning. (I didn't say that the first time round.)

If you can give me enough filler-information from your side, Hector, then my vote goes back onto Fallacy (noting that I'm the only one who has even tried to vote, this time round) and you can easily double up that (writing it correctly, this time) and doubtless to your benefit. Whether mine or not.

@Fallacy, it is an uphill struggle, but if you can be more sane n your reply to explain all the gaps in your all-over-the-shop approach, before I get to react to Hectorvs doubtless revelatory coredump of information, then therevs a chance I will switch.  Make it good, though, because you're starting in defecit.

Shortcut to my trust: Guess how many wincons I have, and the points for each. I'll look favourably upon the one that gets it correct, but seems like a longshot,.

[hector13]

Well one thing we have to consider, Starver, is that FoU has claimed a night kill. If he's telling the truth (in regards to his role and alignment) then any townies left don't want him to be alive for the night.

If he's telling the truth about his role but not his alignment, then any scum left don't want him alive neither.

If he's lying about both, he's just a dick. This seems the least likely scenario.

Anyway, this raises the question of how to proceed. Do we take our chances that you and I are the same alignment and take out the FoU NK, or do we gamble that FoU is the same alignment, and thus lose if we're wrong?

[hector13]

Also, are you claiming middle management, Starver?

[FallacyofUrist]

Interestingly, Hector always seems to be the last to claim. And a claim from him would be nice right now, just saying.
~~~

@Fallacy, it is an uphill struggle, but if you can be more sane n your reply to explain all the gaps in your all-over-the-shop approach, before I get to react to Hectorvs doubtless revelatory coredump of information, then therevs a chance I will switch.  Make it good, though, because you're starting in defecit.

Bay 12, mate, sanity is dead.

In any case: look at my perspective on this: both your and hector's behavior could have been generated by an Evil or a town motivation. And because of this round's particular alignment mechanics, it's even more difficult to use information on behavior.
Which leaves role mechanics(my preference). But, it seems, I'm not getting much of that information.

Perhaps if you both would full claim we can get into that. Until then, I don't have much to supply other than my cooperation. And interrogation.
~~~

Shortcut to my trust: Guess how many wincons I have, and the points for each. I'll look favourably upon the one that gets it correct, but seems like a longshot,.

Starver, why would you look favorably onto somebody who guesses your win condition? I'm not seeing any reasoning here...
~~~

[hector13]

Hah. That was silly. Also, reliance on mechanics is silly, but that's just muh pref.

I would much rather Starver claim his role name first.

[Starver]

I would much rather Starver claim his role name first.

Already given.  Puppet Hand.  Now you give similarly comprehensive info.  Or side with Fallacy for a somewhat hopeful speculation that that would grant you the instawin, I suppose.

(Fallacy: I have had my reasons to have suspected, and still somewhat suspect, that someone could give me chapter and verse on my character, after giving them just enough clues to let them know that they do. Now it looks like I'm probablynwrong, but if the round ends and it roleflips that they do know, and are staying aloof for no good reason, then I can't say that I haven't tried...)

[hector13]

The man with the strings. Interesting...

I am the Handmirror. I redirect; if someone acts upon me, they hit my target instead.

Now. We still stand no closer to figuring this out because we haven't said whether we're town or scum, though I can't imagine we would trust one another to tell the truth anyway.

Right. I will vote for FoU. If FoU would like me to vote for Starver instead, tell me why.

[FallacyofUrist]

Right. I will vote for FoU. If FoU would like me to vote for Starver instead, tell me why.

Bah. Sadly, I've got nothing.

(Fallacy: I have had my reasons to have suspected, and still somewhat suspect, that someone could give me chapter and verse on my character, after giving them just enough clues to let them know that they do. Now it looks like I'm probablynwrong, but if the round ends and it roleflips that they do know, and are staying aloof for no good reason, then I can't say that I haven't tried...)

Well, okay. Would unvote now, but I don't want to be lynched. For obvious reasons.
~~~
I don't suppose either of you folks would be willing to claim alignment?

[hector13]

Would you believe is if we did?

[FallacyofUrist]

Would you believe is if we did?

Completely fair point. I don't suppose either of you are neutral?
~~~
This situation is rather annoying. But...

hector13, simply based on game logic, the best I have. If you're town and Starver's lynched, I can't kill you, based on your claim. If, after your lynch, you show up Evil, I should be able to off Starver.

Best I've got.

[Starver]

Yeah, looks like I'm inevitably going for FoU again. With the distinct chance of someone's reversal before day-end...

[hector13]

Nah, day ends too early for me. Annoyed it has come down to this, but ah well.

[FallacyofUrist]

Yeah, looks like I'm inevitably going for FoU again. With the distinct chance of someone's reversal before day-end...

Pity.
Also, I say you have one wincon for two points.

[Tomasque]

Round Over - Scum Win!

Votecount
hector13 (1) - FallacyofUrist
FallacyofUrist (2) - hector13, Starver
Starver (0)

FallacyofUrist was the Hand of Justice

Spoiler: Hand of Justice (click to show/hide)

Hand of Justice
When the law fails, and punisments are not carried out, you will deliver them to the guilty yourself.
Archetype: Special Town role
Wincon: You win if the Evil roles are eliminated.

(n) Execute: You may only use this ability if there was no lynch the day before. Your target is nightkilled.
SECRET: (a) Swift Justice: You win as soon as there is only one Evil role left.


 In addition, some information:

- You are the only town role in this round. All other players are Evil roles with generally "anti-town" wincons.

- You are the de facto "Evil role" of this round.

hector13 gets one victory point.
Starver gets one victory point.
TheBiggerFish gets one victory point.
The Moonlit Shadow gets one victory point.

Spoiler: Player Roles (click to show/hide)

Hand of Justice
When the law fails, and punisments are not carried out, you will deliver them to the guilty yourself.
Archetype: Special Town role
Wincon: You win if the Evil roles are eliminated.

(n) Execute: You may only use this ability if there was no lynch the day before. Your target is nightkilled.
SECRET: (a) Swift Justice: You win as soon as there is only one Evil role left.


 In addition, some information:

- You are the only town role in this round. All other players are Evil roles with generally "anti-town" wincons.

- You are the de facto "Evil role" of this round.

Handmirror
Your shiny exterior disguises your dark interior. It's a good thing you show your exterior when you use your powers, then, isn't it?
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you are alive when the town is eliminated  (1 point)

(n) Reflect: Any actions against you switch to your target instead, with the exception of your target's actions against you.

Puppet Hand
Chaos is fun - control is better.
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you are alive when the town is eliminated  (1 point)

(a) Marionette: One player this game is desgnated as your "controlled player." You do not know who they are, or their role.
(n) Instruct: You suggest a person for your controlled player to target. If they agree, their action will happen. If they disagree, they will have no action that night. If you do not use this action, they may target whoever they wish that night. They are aware of all these things.

Grip of Terror
Anyone can be in your grasp - except for one. You'll take care of that, soon.
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you are alive when the town is eliminated  (1 point)
                           you are alive when the town and your controller is eliminated  (2 points)

(a) Controlled: Instead of choosing your target, your "controller" (another player) will suggest who you should target. If you agree, it happens. If you disagree, you do not act that night. If you controller does not use their action, then you may target who you wish.
(n) Menace: Your target is roleblocked, and cannot post - except to vote - the following day.

Stranglehold
Soon, you will be the only one here. Then you will have absolute power!
Archetype: Evil role
Wincon: You win if you are alive when the town is eliminated  (1 point)
                           you are alive when the town and your controller is eliminated  (2 points)

(a) Controlled: Instead of choosing your target, your "controller" (another player) will suggest who you should target. If you agree, it happens. If you disagree, you do not act that night. If you controller does not use their action, then you may target who you wish.
(n) Muffle: Your target cannot vote the following day.
(a) Undercut: If your vote is the only vote, then the person you voted for is still lynched.

Spoiler: Action Log (click to show/hide)

Does anyone actually read this? 
 Night 1
FallacyofUrist executed The Moonlit Shadow  (roleblocked)
hector13 reflected FallacyofUrist
Starver instructed targeting FallacyofUrist
The Moonlit Shadow agreed
TheBiggerFish agreed

 Night 2
FallacyofUrist executed The Moonlit Shadow  (roleblocked)
hector13 reflected FallacyofUrist
Starver instructed targeting FallacyofUrist
The Moonlit Shadow agreed  (auto Predictable triggered)
TheBiggerFish agreed

 Night 3
hector13 reflected The Moonlit Shadow
Starver instructed targeting Starver
The Moonlit Shadow disagreed

Night 4
hector13 reflected Starver

[FallacyofUrist]

Oh well. Pity.
It was a fun round. GG.