What we know (assuming nothing Millerish, etc):
Fish prevented votes, for a living. At the bequest of A.N. Other, perhaps some of the time, and was evil.
What is claimed (if I have it right):
Fallacy was action-blocked N1; post-restricted and vote-blocked, D2; Vote-blocked D3 (not silenced, no word on action).
Moonlight was instructed by S.M.N. Else (may or may not share anything with A.N. Other) to silence and/or role-block Fallacy N1/D2+N2/D3 (apparently refused by D3) and silence me D4 (definitely refused, or else I got a pass that I don't know about).
@Moonlit can you restate what you said you did? At least your latest version. Obviously you'll be not wanting to incriminate yourself, but its not as though you haven't got plenty of 'outs' for your behaviour...
I have reason to believe that neither Mr Other nor Mr Else actually have full control, but I don't think it is the right time to go into that detail.
Four Evils makes no sense. There must be one Town for the known Wincon to operate, and apart from the deviation of majority evil needing to survive to win, that would be just alignment mirroring. Or is that it?
No, I think there's two evils and two goods in command/obey pairings (except for a complication?). Either: Sith pair ('dead Sith Lord's Lightsabre' rules of advancement?) and Jedi pair; Evil commands good and vice-versa, or; Subordinates are both Evil, their masters are Good. There's ramifications for the Wincon in various of those combos, but not without chance of Autos adding fine-tuning.
Oh, yeah, if Fish got the Hand thing, even whilst not being a Hand (a 'hold', instead) then I can no longer accuse Fallacy of making up the Hand Of when there's not a consistant manipulatory naming convention, but you were still too bloody oblivious of the hand-based clues for words... I still don't believe the Hand Of, but that might of course not be scummy. Nor was the fact that you would have had to try to experiment on yourself, first night, excuse you of being the one that triggered your own repression, by proxy, in one or other of the manners you were repressed. Perhaps more likely if you were(/thought you were) doing it under the auspices of good, though.
Hector I haven't forgotten you, but I don't currently know what to say about you. Your logic is often impeccable, but that means nothing kuch, either way.