So, cogitated.
On the face of it...
Neutral Fallacy flipped (as in discovered) and seemingly no longer part of the game.
Presumed-Investigator Moonlit flipped (as in crazy) and throwing around insane talk.
Presumedly-Special Fish will not accept overtures.
Presumedly-Special Hector will not listen to (or read) overtures. (Fakeclaim, but maybe for good. Actually Weak, if Town?)
Self-Affirmed-Special me will ignore overtures.
There's an assumed conversion routine. Witnessed by Fallacy (initial claim), myself (second claim) and Moonlit (possibly clashing second claim). Fallacy/Moonlit interactions N0 seemed to confirm third-party targetting ability (seemed to confirm Moonlit as refusable-Cop!). Moonlit/Hector interactions N1 reinforces Cop!Moonlit idea, but third-party interacts with two people?
It really makes no sense for Moonlit, converted by an Evil me, to not then accuse Hector, get Fish on side, scumwin happens. Alternately, clear Hector and lay the pain down on Fish for scumwin, with or without giving Hector a chance to join at night, depending on exact wincon.
Vanilla!Moonlit would not fake a third-party interaction, effectively a counter-claim to my own. Converted!Moonlit would not reveal the interaction, and expose the apparent recruiter. Moonlit was visited, whether or not in the way that I revealed, and is forced or fooled into making that declaration.
Option 1: Moonlit remains (secretly) under the post-mortem thrall of Fallacy, whose flip did not reveal the full 'recruiting' action (or as a function of Moonlit's own autos/etc), and is now a recruiter aiming for lynching one claimed recruitmentproof person (could have been Fish.. It would have been easier to exploit my initial ambivalance and cleared Hector whilst aiming at Fish) while making Hector receptive for recruitment tonight.
If this is true, Moonlit should be targetted, to remove the remaining effect, lest he engineers the lynching of me today, A.N.Other tomorrow and is one-to-one with the final opponent of Fallacy the last day. (Note, there's still room for Evil to play around this, in complicated ways.)
Option 2: As an 'infective' action, it has now two recruiters. e.g. applied to Fallacy, N0, who then visited Moonlit later the same night, leaving Moonlit a carrier plus the original Patient Zero (any of us). Then, N1, Hector gets 'bit', through Infected!Cop!Moonlit's arrival, whilst I think I escaped my visit by the Prime Infector (but maybe I won't know until I wake up tomorrow, if such was same with Moonlit). I'm not sure Tomasque expected such a quick N0 spread.
If this is true, the source can actually only be Hector, or else there'd be three 'infected' people as of now (Prime Infector, Moonlit, Hector) leaving me/Fish, whoever isn't the PI, already having lost the game. What happens if we lynch Patient Zero? (Well, we know what happens with vampires, but no sign what the tbeme is here...)
Option 3: Fish gains power, per round, and multi-targetted, last night? And with Hector (fake)-claiming invulnerability, avoided him and then finds I'm the truly night-invulnerable one so goes after me. But it's unlikely with just one conversion-proof player (me, not Hector, Fish just Cop-proof), that there'd be an exponential recruitment gain. No, that's quite unlikely, without something I'm missing.
Option 4: I could not receive the one Beneficial Enlightenment from the Townie provider of same. It wasn't Moonlit (or he wouldn't have attacked me...unless he presumed I was evil for refusing, as per Fallacy might have), and it wasn't Hector (with the same tentative caveat), so Fish is the good guy, as the true bad-guy is doubtless aware... But no nearer to working out who is the bad guy from the remaining.
I don't OMGUS (my vote for Hector was from Hector showing actual guilt in his blitz attack at day-start, when I had started off yet unsure), but Moonlit would be prime target (for the crazy attack that practically exonerates me). Right now, I'm sticking with Hector, because of both attacks, which tend to point more to a Patient Zero situation, for which one good lynch would save town (rather than just delay things, to unknown result).
But this won't change any minds, I'm sure. May even be too late.
Author
Topic: Mafia Marathon (Read 231265 times)