He has nowhere left to go! FINISH HIM
Clarification: get down from the tree and bash Gentlefish's head in.
Drill into the mower. Put some lethal holes in that son of a bitch!
5v3v5
The two beast grind against one another, a stalemate developing as the egg refuses to puts its owner at risk, while the Bloodmower refuses to back away. Gentlefish stabs at the mower's wheels before succumbing to another round of sleeping gas, and falling back groggily.
6v2
IcyTea descends, or rather falls out of the tree, on top of Gentlefish, hammer held spiky end down. He manages to smash a couple of toes upon impact, but hits Gentlefish in the cranium, knocking him out. We'll just assume he's beaten to death at this point, he's not going anywhere anyway. IcyTea can no longer run properly.
IcyTea is now in the same tree-creature-evil lake -creature position as Gentlefish was, except his beast is ridable. The egg shows no signs of relenting, and seems more than ready to roll over Gentlefish's body.
Gentlefish is now dead. And no, you don't get his weapon, its attached to his hand. And I don't think I'd enjoy running a duel with each person holding four unique and overpowered weapons.
Command the strings to further encase and protect me.
Grab Doc as I pass over him, and make him fake. Then make this little drawing I have, of a desert eagle .50 cal? Make that real.
5v6
Nunzillor leans over the side of his beast, as McTaalik writhes from the Tesla arcs dancing across his body, and falls off, grabbing him in a double Nelson on the way down, as both become encased together in strings an inch in diameter, covering them, with some airspaces, but firmly tying them together.
3v2
Nothing happens as Nun desperately taps away at the controls. You're going to have to roll pretty high to instakill somone like that.